Posted on Jul 24, 2014
SSG Battery Trainer
247K
737
451
52
52
0
9c5afe01
AR 600-25, 1-5 states who is entitled to a salute. No where in this does it say cadet (who has not received his commission).
Avatar_feed
Responses: 161
CSM Mike Maynard
73
73
0
1) AR 600-25 states salutes are exchanged between officers (commissioned and warrant) and enlisted - Cadets are neither officers or enlisted

2) If Cadets are authorized salutes, why would they have a "First Salute" ceremony at their commissioning?

3) AR 600-20 states Cadets will be referred to as Mister, Miss or Cadet

4) Cadets are not paid E5 pay, they are given a monthly stipend
(73)
Comment
(0)
CDR Naval Aviator
CDR (Join to see)
7 mo
This is one of the few differences in services, as far as rank (and rank name) are concerned. Though typically treated the same, a cadet is considered a ‘status’ in the service, whereas a midshipman is considered a rank.

Both are treated as either a half-ensign or a half-2LT.

That said, I’m not sure of the 35% pay, but I can attest to the fact that that periodic 1.1% slap in the face we get every January has not applied to them in most years.
(0)
Reply
(0)
LCDR Frederick Hardy
LCDR Frederick Hardy
7 mo
CDR Gilson, years ago I (while enlisted) learned that a Naval Academy Midshipmen was to rank between W-! and CWO-2. Yes, Midshipman is considered a rank, while cadet is considered NOTHING more than a civilian.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SGT Military Police
SGT (Join to see)
3 mo
CSM Mike Maynard your correct on everything but number four. You are grouping all cadets under one umbrella statement but they're two types of cadets, USMA cadets and ROTC cadets which fall under two separate commands and two separate categories. As LTC Paul Labrador pointed out USMA cadets are paid a stipend that equates to 35% of a 2LT pay but ROTC cadets have a reserve obligation where they are paid as an E5 in the reserves and their cac card reads E5. That does not mean they hold the rank or privileges of an E5 but that is their paygrade for pay purposes while in IADT or ADT.
As for the saluting, this is a conversation I have had with many cadets as a drill sergeant that has trained summer camp at ft Knox and ft Lewis for cadets getting ready to be commissioned after their last major training event. They are not commissioned and are not due a salute and nowhere in regulations does it require any member of the armed forces to salute or to use any courtesies afforded to a commissioned officer.
They would never try these stunts expecting a salute or stand at parade rest when talking to them from the drill sergeant instructors as we kept them pretty scared of us but they did expect it from the support staff that were E4 and below and told quite a few to stand at parade rest when addressing them and usually got a big F@#k you in return which would cause incidents that we didn't need, so we would have to talk to the support staff junior enlisted about ,no you don't have to salute ,no you don't have to stand at parade rest ,but yes you should be respectful to them as your part of them learning to become officers and if you have a problem with one then find a drill sergeant and we will handle it and we gave a similar briefing to the cadets.
(0)
Reply
(0)
CSM Mike Maynard
CSM Mike Maynard
3 mo
Doesn't matter if they are USMA or ROTC cadets, neither receive E-5 pay. Both receive stipends based on the MS level.

Now, SMP cadets, which most ROTC cadets are not, are paid at the E5 level when they drill (just like you said), but that only applies to SMP cadets, not ROTC cadets in general.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar_small
SPC Charles Brown
68
67
1
A cadets overanxious reaction to being snubbed by someone they perceive as junior to them got him an answer he wasn't expecting from me once. I was coming out of the PX on Fort Drum and he followed me to confront me about not saluting him.

Q: Why didn't you salute me?
A: Why should I?
Q: Do you know what this means (Silver disc on his cover)?
A: A target for some young sniper or other combat arms individual to use to take you out.

He just walked away.
(68)
Comment
(1)
1SG Frank Boynton
1SG Frank Boynton
4 y
When I was in, the answer was NO absolutely not do not ever salute a cadet, they are not commissioned. As a drill sgt we had a bunch of cadets join us one summer out of West Point, doing some training, they were not going through basic, they were basically assisting the drill sgt's and learning. We specifically instructed our trainees that they were not to salute them under any circumstances.
(3)
Reply
(0)
LTC Substitute Teacher
LTC (Join to see)
>1 y
The cadet that Cpl Brown referred to will have a lot of growing up if he is to be a good officer. Hopefully that incident helped him learn his lesson.
(3)
Reply
(0)
MGySgt Jerry Suarez
MGySgt Jerry Suarez
10 mo
That young cadet is gonna be someone's heartache out there
(0)
Reply
(0)
LCDR Frederick Hardy
LCDR Frederick Hardy
7 mo
Ah, Fort Drum......I remember that as Pine Camp, Camp Drum and finally Fort Drum. I grew up in and around Carthage.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar_small
SFC Stephen Carden
49
49
0
Funny this should come up. My company has two cadets visiting right now. Here is how we handle it: I call them sir and ma'am because it is much easier than remembering their names; I do not salute them because they are not commissioned officers and I have not been ordered or "encouraged" to salute them; they do not expect salutes because they know they are not commissioned officers; they keep their mouths shut and their ears and eyes open because they are here to learn and they know it. I actually had the male cadet approach me yesterday and ask me what I expected from a brand new 2LT as a SNCO! He even took notes! I told him I expected them to ask for directions to where they are supposed to be because we don't have LTs in my MOS:-) Seriously, he seemed very interested in how he should behave as a 2LT. Of course, he is prior enlisted, so......
(49)
Comment
(0)
PO3 Purchasing Director
PO3 (Join to see)
>1 y
I need to get my own meme like SFC (Join to see) ! I like it!
(4)
Reply
(0)
PO2 Michael Henry
PO2 Michael Henry
>1 y
Buy that kid a beer when off duty.
(1)
Reply
(0)
MAJ All Source Intelligence
MAJ (Join to see)
>1 y
That's awesome Mark!!
(0)
Reply
(0)
SPC Chris Havel
SPC Chris Havel
>1 y
When stationed at Ft. Stewart. We had a cadet doing his training with us in our motor pool. Our CO. Told us to treat them like a officer. He didn't have a car down there so the CO loans him his bicycle. He told me to watch over the Commanders bike while he went around with BMO. When he got back the bike was hanging from the eclectic crane in the motor pool. We turned off the breaker to it and told him the crane was out of gas. Then had him go to POL to get some mo gas. He was scared shitless. I loved the E-4 mafia!
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar_small
Cancel
close
Seg?add=7750261&t=2