How would you react to an E2 who "smart mouths" you in formation?

I had a black Pvt in Korea that every time I told him to do something He would tell me "You just wait till the revolution, you'll get yours.
What really irritates me now is that he is eligible for Veterans benefits.

If it was while I was still a Marine.it would have been the fastest Captain Mast around after charges filed with the CO..

Man if I had done anything like that as a private I would have been smoked to near death and probably would have had details out the ass along with being made and example of which is probably what that turd needed.

KP for a month.

Ok for a month.

Pvt Shitbird, TL, SQ, stand fast. To SQ separately:
Please explain to the TL why this will not be tolerated and how to react next time they see it. Please make sure this fucktard spend a few minutes in the whiskey locker with his team and squad. When he's learned the level of his mistake, make sure he knows how to act. Also, get with your other SQ's and make sure duty SQ for the day is ready to take over at 12 so the rest of us can zonk for the day.

Advised of the consequences of violating a direct order.

What happened to our military that this pos E2 is still breathing. Chapter his ass out.

Simple,
1. I remove the Troop that can't control His Mouth from Formation, and put Him off to the side, possibly giving him something to do which keeps him occupied (push-ups, climbing a rope or a pole or something similar that will work toward getting Him winded and there fore occupy His mouth) while I complete giving assignments to the rest of the Crew.

2. Then I'd dismiss the remainder of the Formation to go about the Tasks they've been assigned, then turn My full attention to the "Loud Mouth". First I'd give him the most difficult and arduous chore I could come up with, in addition the that which I'd already assigned Him. If He objected again, I'd assign Him yet another task, until the objections cease.

3. If the objections don't cease, I'd find yet another form of "Physical Motivation" to occupy Him and His Mouth, until He choses to "Comply" with the Instructions He's been given. When He complies, He is rewarded with nourishment & perhaps a few minutes of rest, relaxation and maybe even some sleep.

Gunny Sgt. Pepper's Statement is also correct, either "The Mouth" complies or He receives a One Way Ticket back to Mommy & Daddy, so they can attempt to Correct what they have created!

Initiate discharge proceedings immediately. Ain’t no body got time for this nonsense. He has obviously been to basic and AIT so he knows the rules. Put him out. Someone is in line waiting to take his place.