Posted on Dec 2, 2022
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
1.18K
17
9
Has anyone had any luck changing their discharge from separation to medical? I separated in September and have 2 significant medical issues that are worsening. The last 2 years of service, these issues weren't taken care of (ignored, told to take ibuprofen, phone apts during COVID, ect). Now I am seeing civilian doctors who have found serious medical conditions. Had these issues been addressed while I was in, chances are, I would have been medically retired. I am now also starting in the reserves and do not think I would be considered fit for duty (I see civilian doctors, so I don't necessarily get put on "Limdu"). Trying to figure out the best options and ways forward. Any help would be appreciated!
Posted in these groups: Ems MedicalMilitary men Discharge
Comments have been disabled
Responses: 5
COL Randall C.
Edited 2 y ago
CPO Sara Chobot, you're not going to like hearing it, but your chances of having it recharacterized are pretty low. However, if you can prove a service connection to your issues, then you'll receive disability entitlements from the Veterans Administration.

Easy one first - contact a Veteran Service Organization (VSO) to assist you in submitting a claim. They can walk you though everything you'll need and assist in putting together your paperwork to send to the VA.

Harder one now - In order to have your discharged changed to a medical retirement, you'll have to prove that situation existed while on active duty and that it was negligence or some other factor for the reason you weren't medically retired. Even then, you'll face a very steep uphill battle.

A number of individuals HAVE been able to change their discharge characterization based on changes in laws, reclassification of medical conditions, etc. A notable examples would be the new guidance that DOD issues in 2017 about the "liberal consideration" in upgrading cases involved PTSD, TBI, other mental health conditions, etc. However, the general guidance (except in these narrow situations) is, "the ADRB may not change your discharge for nondisability reasons to a disability separation or retirement."

This too you can seek help from a VSO, but not all VSOs might be able to give you the same level of assistance involving submissions to a Discharge Review Board. It's perfectly acceptable to use one VSO for VA related stuff and another VSO regarding your discharge, however try to keep them the same just for ease of paperwork.
COL Randall C.
COL Randall C.
2 y
Sorry, glossed over your comment regarding the reserves. I'll have to defer to my Navy brethren to talk about who the applicable office is regarding Navy Reserve medical fitness (for example, in the Army, our Human Resources Command will process profiles and limited duty paperwork, but the servicemember is still responsible for getting the information together from private physicians).
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
2 y
Thank you for all this information! I have already filed with the VA and am being compensated. I just am unsure how to go about the limited duty processes for the reserves, and so far, they haven't been super helpful.
COL Randall C.
COL Randall C.
2 y
CPO Sara Chobot - Doings a quick internet search, I came across BUPERSINST 1001.39F (w/change 1).* I looks like Chapter 2 contains the information regarding physical qualifications for the active component and reserve component.

It also references OPNAVINST 6110.1J which discusses the physical readiness program such as your PHA and how medically unfit (do not meet medical standards of the Physicals Fitness Assessment)

Again, you'll need someone that speaks 'squid' better than I to help with anything further than what these documents might provide.
----------------------------------
* BUPERSINST 1001.39F (w/change 1) - https://www.mynavyhr.navy.mil/Portals/55/Reference/Instructions/BUPERS/1001.39_CH-1.pdf
* OPNAVINST 6110.1J - https://www.netc.navy.mil/Portals/46/NSTC/OTCN/docs/OPNAVINST%206110.1J.pdf
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
2 y
COL Randall C. Thank you so much for the help! I will start doing some digging on these.
SFC Retention Operations Nco
No, it's not, and yes it is. This is exactly why people need to follow up with medical care and medical separation before ETS. Once you ETS the opportunity is gone.

People have had their separations reviewed and changed, but it's not going to happen with you. You can apply to your service's board of corrections to have your separation reviewed and changed. This happened with all the GWOT Soldiers that Madigan separated for Adjustment Disorder during the height of the war. A review found the Pysch was declaring all the PTSD cases as Adjustment Disorder and they were all opened again by the Army Review Board and evaluated for medical separation.

Technically, this is the route you could take with your case. Realistically, any review board will look at your record at the time of separation. If you were not recommended for medical separation, you were considered medically qualified for retention at the time, and your separation was valid. If you were recommended for medical separation and placed in the medical evaluation and chose to separate anyway, you have no legal recourse.

Basically, no review board is going to overturn your separation at the time if you willingly separated. If you were involuntarily separated at the time, you may have a chance.
SFC David Reid, M.S, PHR, SHRM-CP, DTM
I have not had to deal with this!

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close