Senior Rater Bullet Comments; what is best for promotion boards?

2014-05-25T02:51:47-04:00

What are some examples of Senior bullet comments that sticks out to board memebers?

Response by LTC Jason Strickland made May 25 at 2014 9:52 AM

2014-05-25T09:52:06-04:00

Kevin,
Senior Rater bullet comments that stick out to board members are those that are tangible, not overly glorious, specific, quantifiable, and measurable. If you have those types of characteristics, then they'll adequately portray what you're trying to communicate as you evaluate an individual.

Response by SGM Private RallyPoint Member made Jun 21 at 2014 9:09 PM

2014-06-21T21:09:30-04:00

I was ask my SR to numerate where I stand against my peers..example would be 1 of 5 1SGs I senior rate..

Response by SSG Robert Burns made Jun 21 at 2014 9:21 PM

2014-06-21T21:21:49-04:00

o Ranked #x out of x (rank) on Rally Point influence score

o Went from 5 thumbs down to 15 thumbs up in one rating period

o Salutes 2Lt's

Hope that helps.

Response by MAJ Private RallyPoint Member made Jun 23 at 2014 6:41 AM

2014-06-23T06:41:25-04:00

If you're in zone, having the phrase "promote now" is always nice. Beyond that, like LTC Strickland said above, I like to have tangibles. In both the rater and senior rater section I like to stress things like "manages $50M in research funding" or "was responsible for a 5-fold increase, from $5,000 to $25,000" in this or that. I want to show deliverables, not vauge comments like "outstanding soldier" since just about everyone gets that.

Response by SGM Luther Thomas made Jun 23 at 2014 6:56 AM

2014-06-23T06:56:20-04:00

The most important thing board members want to know from the senior rater is what does the senior rater want the board to do, "promote now, promote with peers, do not promote...ect) This is a promotion board and senior raters need to spell it out for the board.

Then the senior rater needs to speak to the Soldiers potential for positions of increase responsibly.

Finally the senior rater should speak to the Soldier's future.

I offer the following:

o promote to MSG ahead of peers

o assigned to positions of increased responsibility

o possesses unlimited potential: future Command Sergeant Major

Response by SFC Private RallyPoint Member made Nov 12 at 2015 11:04 PM

2015-11-12T23:04:06-05:00

Promote Now
Send to SLC Now
Ranked first out of # of SFC's that has worked for me in my 20 years of service
Assign as a (next higher position) will excel in positions of greater responsibility.

Whassup with you Frat?

Response by 1LT Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 18 at 2016 2:24 PM

2016-03-18T14:24:44-04:00

Seeing as how the Army has converted to EES and the new NCOER (and OER), Senior Rater comments are no longer in bullet format. They are to be written as a narrative (Complete sentences, no more than 5 lines) I suggest delving into DA PAM 623-3 or going to the HRC EES website and watching the PowerPoint tutorials for more instruction on the guidelines for completing the new NCOER.
However, similar to the "old" NCOERs, Senior Rater comments are quantifiable, ie: Ranks x of x, Top X% of all SGT/SSG/SFCs I have ever worked with, etc.