Posted on Mar 19, 2015
SGT James Elphick
6.79K
11
10
4
4
0
Since leaving the military nearly a decade ago I have dedicated myself to pursuing an education and increasing my knowledge and intelligence. I am starting to regret that decision. With the advent of social media, the continued polarization of politics, and what I feel is a severe decline in objectivity I feel like my ability to communicate with my fellow human beings in a civil and reasonable manner is severely hampered. It feels like a self-imposed alienation sometimes.

A case in point is this site. Though I am a huge fan of most of what happens here I get discouraged often. I try to create discussions that require critical thought and serious discussion but they often fail to gain traction. When they do get traction and I start to get responses they are often quickly driven down the list by many of the mindless and/or politically-charged posts that permeate the board. Even worse, I had a decent discussion going about mandatory voting in the US after I read an article that Obama had floated the idea. I intentionally left politics out of it so as to get objective answers. However, though my post had come first, I received this message "RallyPoint has merged your discussion, "Mandatory Voting in the US?", with "Obama suggests "FORCED VOTING" for Americans... how does THAT grab you?", and your original post has been closed." So my post was removed because someone posted the same thing but with a loaded title that infuriated people against the president and was filled with vitriol and disgust as opposed to the decent and objective content that filled my post. I understand that there is a desire and need to keep content together as much as possible but my civil discussion was trumped by a charged one, why? Because it had more responses? Obviously I am upset about this portion but there are other issues in this that I would like to touch on.

I read an interesting article in the Havok Journal the other day about veterans lashing out at each other and others when their opinions do not align. Apparently we are some of the worst offenders, even against our own. I'll post the link in the comments so as not to distract from the intent of this post. At any rate I find it very interesting that we as a nation find it so difficult to communicate and discuss civilly and objectively.

Rant over.
Posted in these groups: 6262122778 997339a086 z Politics2dcac4a3 RallyPoint
Avatar feed
Responses: 6
Sgt Aaron Kennedy, MS
1
1
0
"Apparently we are some of the worst offenders, even against our own."

Not to make excuses, but.. there is a certain amount of willpower it takes to do what we do... and sometimes that presents as "pigheadedness" or more aptly as "two rams going at it."

SGT James Elphick does a great job at presenting interesting topics. But the ones that will create traction, are going to be the ones with polarizing views. And if they have even the hint of religion or politics in them... things tend to devolve from there, even if approached from an apolitical stance.

Unfortunately, what happens is that most people can't separate emotion from logic when it comes to debate. We see what we want to, vice what is really there. I'm as guilty as anyone about this. It takes a lot of practice to break the habit.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Collin McMillion
1
1
0
It has been my pleasure to once again realize, like you, that it makes no difference what you say or what your intent is, there are those out there who want to make issue with it, more for their personal need or desire for argument or to perhaps in some way feed a need to feel some sort of personal satisfaction rather than engage in a meaningful discussion, even if in the end they still disagree, which is their right. If you can't be constructive, please don't be destructive!!!!
(1)
Comment
(0)
SGT James Elphick
SGT James Elphick
9 y
SFC Collin McMillion "If you can't be constructive, please don't be destructive!!!!" Perfect!
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT James Elphick
1
1
0
More good and on topic writing from the Havok Journal
http://www.havokjournal.com/nation/the-dumbing-down-of-america/
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close