What Rank Was The Most Challenging But Rewarding?

2022-02-28T16:25:33-05:00

Thanks to all who participated! This sweepstakes event has ended and all prizes have been awarded. Please continue to share your stories and follow the RallySweeps page for the next event! https://rly.pt/RLYSWP

RallySweeps | RallyPoint

RallySweeps

Response by SFC Joe S. Davis Jr., MSM, DSL made Feb 28 at 2022 4:37 PM

2022-02-28T16:37:46-05:00

RallyPoint News Sergeant/E-5 was the most challenging but rewarding, I had to overcome a confidence problem and lead by example as a Sergeant/Professional Noncommissioned Officer, which enhanced my career as a leader.

PO1 William "Chip" Nagel Lt Col Charlie Brown SSG Michael Noll Lt Col John (Jack) Christensen Cpl Vic Burk MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D. SGT Private RallyPoint Member PO2 Marco Monsalve SGT David A. 'Cowboy' Groth ] SSG William Jones SPC Nancy Greene PO1 Tony Holland SGT Mark Anderson LTC Private RallyPoint Member SGT James Murphy Sgt Private RallyPoint Member LTC David Brown 1SG Dan Capri CDR Andrew McMenamin, PhD

Response by PO2 Russell "Russ" Lincoln made Feb 28 at 2022 4:43 PM

2022-02-28T16:43:18-05:00

Petty Officer Third Class, changeling because I had to distance myself and be an NCO instead of just one of the guys. Learned a lot about leadership, self confidence, discipline.

Response by LTC Stephen F. made Feb 28 at 2022 4:46 PM

2022-02-28T16:46:16-05:00

USMA cadet, after serving as an enlisted man was the most challenging and yet rewarding. I listened to upper class men, with no active duty experience, telling me how how things were done in the Army. I did my best to hold my peace and help my less experienced classmates as we struggled together to survive and thrive as cadets.

FYI SFC William Farrell SSG Private RallyPoint Member CPL Ronald Keyes Jr SSG Donald H "Don" Bates SPC Nancy Greene SPC Michael Duricko, Ph.D MAJ Ken Landgren MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D. SPC Woody Bullard SGT Mary G. CPL Douglas Chrysler SSgt Kelly D. PO3 Edward Riddle Sgt Private RallyPoint Member Ken Kraetzer CWO4 Terrence Clark SGT David A. 'Cowboy' Groth CWO3 Dave Alcantara SSgt Brian Brakke

Response by SSG Private RallyPoint Member made Feb 28 at 2022 4:46 PM

2022-02-28T16:46:50-05:00

CPL... I became an NCO at the start of the summer of protest and was also moved to another unit to take the promotion. I was new to the unit, and new to being an NCO and new to the team I was now leading through civil unrest in our own streets. It was hard to connect to my team, in light of the situation we were in. However, in the long run it helped me become a better leader and it helped me mold my team to be more proficient in their skills. Also, it didn't help that I was doing the work, but not getting paid for it for over a year...

Response by MAJ Ken Landgren made Feb 28 at 2022 5:18 PM

2022-02-28T17:18:33-05:00

2LT as an armor platoon leader. I had to be tactically competent quickly in order for the platoon to trust me.

Response by TSgt George Rodriguez made Feb 28 at 2022 5:54 PM

2022-02-28T17:54:36-05:00

USAF Staff Sergeant E/5 NCOIC Pharmacy U-Tapao Thailand 1974-1975. Took in refugees when Viet Nam fell, and the Mayaguez incident taking care of the injured marines that were able to release the American crew that were captured by the Cambodian communists.

Response by SSG Robert Vernon made Feb 28 at 2022 6:08 PM

2022-02-28T18:08:17-05:00

I would have to say my most Challenging but rewarding would be when I was promoted to SP6 , In 1982 I was put before the board just 3 days after being released from a Hospital in Frankfurt Germany due to my appendix rupturing while on Movement Exercises I had to be medi-vac from our location and it nearly cost me my life but I made it , I was informed of the Promotion Board date and at first my CSM wanted to pull me from the list , but I was making at such a quicker pace than expected that he decided to keep me on the list. Long story short , I made my exit from the Hospital and just 3 days later went before the board felt really good about how that went and felt even better when the Promotion List came out showing my Name and my new Rate. I will always remember this and use it as encouragement to others around me.

Response by Cpl Vic Burk made Feb 28 at 2022 6:28 PM

2022-02-28T18:28:52-05:00

Without a doubt it was Private (E-1). Going through boot camp was hell but earning that Eagle-Globe-Anchor and the title United States Marine was the most rewarding thing ever. Graduating from MCRD trumps my graduation from DeVry and East Tennessee State University.

Response by MSG Kevin Elliott made Feb 28 at 2022 6:56 PM

2022-02-28T18:56:16-05:00

For me, I would say Staff Sergeant (SSG)/E-6. First, I had to ask to go to the promotion board, just like I did for Sergeant (SGT)/E-5. I had attended the Basic Non-Commissioned Officer Course (BNCOC) and was the Honor Graduate. I was already serving in a SSG position. But the platoon was so crazy, that I wasn't selected to go to the promotion board the first month I was eligible. I asked the Platoon Sergeant why and he said that he didn't know I was eligible. I told him I was eligible and I wanted to go to the next monthly promotion board. I went to the board, got the recommendation, and then proceeded to wait for 27 months while the points for my Military Occupational Specialty (MOS), 11H, at the time stayed maxed out at 998. I don't remember my exact score, it was over 890, but I maxed awards, PT, Military Education, Commander's Recommendation, and I got 195/200 from the board. One First Sergeant never maxed anybody out on board appearances. The only thing I could improve on was Civilian Education, but that was difficult in the 80s, where you had to go to class or try to test out using Dantes. I had some college, but I kept taking courses when I could.
I kept working in a SSG position and even in a Sergeant First Class (SFC)/E-7 job for about six months. My score increased a little, from the college courses I was able to attend. The points finally dropped and I made my rank. My boss at the time said he would promote me, but he had been my company commander and we never got along. I knew he was leaving in two months, so I told him I would wait and let the incoming S-3, my last company commander, promote me. I had to explain it to the 1SG and Command Sergeant Major (CSM)/E-9, and they were good with it. Once I got promoted, I continued to serve in SSG and SFC positions. I always looked for jobs above my current rank, and kept learning and moving forward. I spent a few years as a SSG, but I feel all of the things I learned at that rank prepared me for SFC and MSG later in my career.

Response by SFC Terry Fortune made Feb 28 at 2022 8:19 PM

2022-02-28T20:19:33-05:00

I would say Sergeant/E5 was the most challenging, but I learn a lot from other NCO's on taking care of troops and leading by example.

Response by SPC Terry Page made Mar 1 at 2022 12:07 AM

2022-03-01T00:07:18-05:00

For me, the most “Challenging But Rewarding” rank was the promotion from PFC to Specialist 4th Class. Actually, it was not the promotion to that rank but rather being picked up as an Instructor at the U.S. Army Signal School at Ft. Monmouth, N.J.

After my rotation from Germany I was assigned to attend a Computer Repair Course (36 weeks) at Ft Monmouth, N.J. Upon my graduation came the promotion to SP4 and being assigned to the school as an Instructor. That assignment I began as an Instructor Trainee followed by attendance and graduation from the Instructor’s Course provided by the Instructional Methods Division. Gaining both classroom and lab experience as a Junior Instructor would lead to assignment as a Senior Instructor for the remainder of my second tour. Marriage and fatherhood would conclude my active military service at the end of my 2nd tour and the beginning of a lifetime career in the private sector computer industry.

The challenge was both technical (nature of the beast) and professional (in a leadership sense). Technical aspects under control, it was a sea-change on the leadership side. The confidence would come with experience and successfully training diverse groups from Senior NCOs to recent recruits fresh from Basic Training. The experience gave me a lifetime career in the IT/MIS profession.

The teaching experience, for me, is truly the most rewarding aspect of my working life. There is a priceless, intangible and lasting reward when you are given the opportunity to give a student the tools they need to succeed. It may be of major or minor consequence to them in their future endeavors, but you will have prepared them to the best of your ability.

Response by MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D. made Mar 1 at 2022 2:57 AM

2022-03-01T02:57:52-05:00

For me, it was being an OCS candidate at Ft. Benning in 1978-79. When I arrived with my family, I was a promotable SSG E-6 with just under nine years of service and approaching a year on the E-7 list. The folks at Housing, expecting me to get promoted before graduation, put my family in SNCO quarters just a quarter of a mile from my barracks: 50th Co., BIOCC (Branch Immaterial Officer Candidate Course) adjacent to the field with the large jump towers and across the parking lot from Infantry Hall.

It wasn't easy having to live in the barracks with my wife and two sons so close, but I gutted it out. I had a Tac who had been an E-6 when he went through OCS and he promised to make my life hell so as to "get the NCOitis out of you or make sure you don't graduate."

He succeeded in his mission. He was so hard on me and my roommates during room inspections that I never had a roommate for more than 15 days. I walked tours every weekend and was restricted to the barracks every weekend until graduation. They made me the cadet 1SG during Weeks 1 and 11--the toughest leadership position you could draw and during the two worst weeks of the course: the first, when nobody really had a clue what was going on, and the eleventh, because it was the first week of Senior Status and candidates went crazy with their newfound privileges.

Despite the large number of demerits I accumulated, I stuck it out and graduated with honors. However, I was still an E-6 on graduation day. Our 1SG sought me out and handed me a set of DA special orders promoting me to E-7 with an effective date of 1 March 1979 and a date of rank of 28 Feb. 1979. Unfortunately, we graduated on 22 Feb. 1979. Oh, well. . . .

ILLUSTRATIONS: (1) Me serving as narrator for our OCS Senior Status Review. (2) My classmates pass in review as I narrate the program. (3) Maj. Gen. William Livsey, Ft. Benning CG, talks to me at our OCS Senior Status Formal. Note that he's staring at my ribbon rack--the largest in my class. (4) A caricature of our OCS cadre from our class book. The 1LT who looks like Frankenstein in the back row was Robert Lawlor, my Tac. He was widely recognized as the toughest Tac in both OCS companies at the time. The short guy in the center was our company CO, CPT Clifton Ripperger. (5) The last illustration is the center spread in our class book. It illustrates "Life in the Land of OCS."

Response by LTC Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 1 at 2022 8:17 AM

2022-03-01T08:17:30-05:00

Transitioning from NCO to 2Lt.

Response by SMSgt Lawrence McCarter made Mar 1 at 2022 9:07 AM

2022-03-01T09:07:36-05:00

I actually was promoted very quickly and made SSgt in 4 years which was unheard of in My career field where promotions weren't good. A supervisor I had at that time also taught Me a lot and set and excellent example. I learned more from that many about leadership and how to manage people than I ever had from any human being ever ! To this very day I think of Him when it come to doing the right thing. That man Samual Dickins, who retired as a MSgt was MY Supervisor at Hanscom AFB, MA when I returned from Vietnam. I had the maximum score on all My promotion exams and all outstanding Enlisted performance reports. Prior to USAF I had also been a Cadet at a Military Academy (Prep school) with an Army ROTC program and a Cadet and also later an Officer in Civil Air Patrol. Confidence didn't seem to be a problem. I got out of the USAF at the 8 year mark even though i was ready to make TSgt well ahead of time. and My Commander, Operations Officer OIC and Base equal Opportunity Officer wanted Me enter Operation Bootstrap where the USAF would send Me to MY two remaining years of college and get a Bachelor's degree, to go to Officer training school. I did get out an receive a BS degree. after an 8 year break I did come back in as a SSgt but lost the time in grade due to the length of My time out. I had to take all the Armed Forces entrance exams, physical etc. again and had no problem with any of that. in the next 14 years i was promoted to TSgt, MSgt and SMSgt a rank I held for over 5 years and turned down CMSgt ((E9) and retired with 22 years service in uniform. There were i few things I wish I had done such as become an officer when i even had that support and encouragement right up our unit chain of command but things worked still out ok anyway.

Response by CSM Darieus ZaGara made Mar 1 at 2022 1:00 PM

2022-03-01T13:00:49-05:00

Command Sergeant Major. The ability to influence others at that level in the accomplishment of all missions is awe inspiring. Whether it be daily Garrison activity, Family support, Daily training and maintenance, squad, section, platoon, company and Battalion it all holds the same sense of responsibility. Being ultimately responsible for preparing an entire Battalion to be combat ready is one that cannot be matched in any environment.

This is not to take away from similar responsibilities at all other levels, below and above. Each is unique in its own right and each leader bares the weight of the organization. One has to live it to understand it.

Thank you all for your awesome service and dedication. God Bless. Let’s help the Ukraine.

Response by SSG Bill McCoy made Mar 1 at 2022 3:55 PM

2022-03-01T15:55:45-05:00

For me, being picked for three job assignments. 1. SWAT training; 2. Boston TDY for the 1976 Bicentenial's Tall Ships; and being picked to be NCOIC of all Patrol and Desk MP functions.
#1 was pure fun and exhileration; #2 was tense because the S. Boston School Bus Strike was ongoing, AND Military Intel noted that a muslim group intended to raid the S. Boston Army Support Activity (SBASA) as it was the largest small arms depot on the East Coast. It was within the harbor, AND that's where the Tall Ships were being docked. The Army only found out about the Tall Ships when they announced the SBASA was where they would dock! The only MP's there were an AWOL Apprehension Team and of the three SWAT/ERT teams sent, I was the NCOIC. All three teams functioned flawlessly and I had my team take the midnight shift, thinking IF there was a raid, it would be then. Fortunately, it never evolved though.
#3 was challenging but highly rewarding in that I was tasked to, "Do what you did as your team's Desk Sergeant, to all of the other teams/shifts." I was given almost carte blanche to model those other teams and shifts to function the same. What made it easy, and possible, were the MP OPNS NCO and OIC and a group of MP Officers who pulled duty as the MP Duty Officer. All of the MP functions (patrol, K-9, MPI, everything) was comprised of two separate MP Companies - the Garrison MP Company (521st) and the Combat MP Company (437th). Frankly, it was a BLAST!

I think what helped me a lot was some "mystique," ... that of being Prior Service and being one of the few Vietnam Vets. Everyone knew that because of my Class A's 1st Marine Div Combat Patch; but what seemed to enhance it was NOT wearing any of my ribbons. At reunions, I've had more than one former subordinate state, "You were the only war Vet who didn't shove it in our face," or similar comments. I never thought of it that way because - frankly, I was "bothered" about Vietnam and how we pulled out and abandoned those people. So, I never wore my "salad dressing," except when ordered to for Command Inspections or Change-of-Command at the BN level or higher. Even at Gen Courts Martial, I never wore them.

Response by MSG Thomas Currie made Mar 1 at 2022 5:09 PM

2022-03-01T17:09:16-05:00

Thinking back I'd have to say that most ranks had their own different challenges. It's hard to say which was "most" challenging, although I suppose I could say that SP4 was the least challenging.

Response by MCPO John Lee made Mar 2 at 2022 5:39 PM

2022-03-02T17:39:04-05:00

Master Chief Petty Officer - MCPO (E9)
My service as a Master Chief on staff duty of Commander Naval Air Force - Atlantic Fleet. I assumed responsibility for Aircraft Carrier Auxiliary Systems. This was challenging because of the broad range of duties for all East Coast Carriers. It was rewarding because in this billet, I was able to influence material changes / training of operators and provide feedback to CNAL and NAVSEA on effectiveness

Response by LCpl Steve Smith made Mar 2 at 2022 5:48 PM

2022-03-02T17:48:07-05:00

LCpl for me, Billet wise. I was Motor T with 3/5, having to be Dispatch (which at the time was a Sgt rank Billet), Driver, Typhoon emergency team dispatch and driver, being apart of the Battalion DeCon team as well as being the one all duty officers called to drive emergency leave Marines and Sailors to the Red Cross and airport (all of this was on the Rock. Being the only Non-Rate able to authorized to drive explosives off base to ranges (I was the only Driver over 21 in Motor T lol). As dispatch having to give run orders to Cpl's and Sgt's. But it was Great, learned a lot about other Grunt MOS's and cross training with them just because I was their driver at the time and there at the range with them, the Long hours everyday lol. A lot of the guys in my MOS probably never got the opportunity or took the opportunity to learn being a driver was the best MOS the Suck could have given me and being with 3/5 was the best unit for me.

Response by Sgt Mike Williams made Mar 2 at 2022 5:48 PM

2022-03-02T17:48:48-05:00

E4, Air Force was the most rewarding for me. Additional responsibility, privileges and respect. That third strip was recognition of study, on the job training and dedication. In addition, I was allowed to train other Airman who came after me. Some of the best years I spent evolving into someone who could stand tall with so many others.

Response by SrA Mark Hodge made Mar 2 at 2022 5:51 PM

2022-03-02T17:51:16-05:00

airman basic because of 5he boot camp training in Texas at 100 degrees.

Response by SrA Mark Hodge made Mar 2 at 2022 5:52 PM

2022-03-02T17:52:24-05:00

It was airman basic because of the 100 degree boot camp training in texas

Response by SSgt Sue Leopold made Mar 2 at 2022 6:00 PM

2022-03-02T18:00:05-05:00

SSgt/E5, because when i was supposed to get it the first time, some one lied about me and took it from me! But i showed her and won it back!

Response by PFC Luke Clark made Mar 2 at 2022 6:15 PM

2022-03-02T18:15:16-05:00

Pv2

Response by Sgt Donald Reese made Mar 2 at 2022 6:19 PM

2022-03-02T18:19:06-05:00

Sargent

Response by SFC Jan Goodman made Mar 2 at 2022 6:22 PM

2022-03-02T18:22:09-05:00

Spec 6 was my most challenging. I was promoted in Vietnam and had to keep our Radar operational and I started getting hollers for help from areas all around us. Lot of problems. Did my best to help all requests some I could handle, some I couldn't made me sad and wish I knew more!!

Response by CPL Marvin Weber made Mar 2 at 2022 6:23 PM

2022-03-02T18:23:04-05:00

Even though I only rose to the rank of corporal, my time inthe service helpedme grow up and become self sufficiant. I was in during the Korean war but spent all my time in Germany. I was a cook and was lucky enough to work with some old timers and learned a lot from them. The last 10 mos of my duty I was given the job of Baker and made all the bread ,cakes and deserts for my company in the 43rd armored division. Iamknow 92 years old and still do cooking and baking at home. I also Take advantage of what the VA has to offer formy meds, glasses . hearing aids. I am amazed at the vets I meet who have never taken advantage of veterans benefits. Perhapsthe va need a better advertising program.

Response by MSgt Bernard Vancil made Mar 2 at 2022 6:31 PM

2022-03-02T18:31:53-05:00

T/Sgt

Response by SMSgt Jimmy Tittsworth made Mar 2 at 2022 6:34 PM

2022-03-02T18:34:33-05:00

The first one after completing basic training. I had never completed anything so when I finished basic and was given my first stripe, oh what a feeling. That motivated me to go on and in my twenty year career completed/accomplished many things. Awards, college degree, promotion to SMgt and travels to lands I never knew existed. And it all started with the first stripe.

Response by PO3 Nathaniel Johnson made Mar 2 at 2022 6:36 PM

2022-03-02T18:36:30-05:00

E3 because it was my first year and I was learning the basics about transition from civilian life to military Accord but it was well worth it because it made me the man I am today

Response by SSG Angela Johnson made Mar 2 at 2022 6:37 PM

2022-03-02T18:37:45-05:00

E-5 Sergeant was the most challenging and rewarding. I had to learn how to be a leader, build confidence in myself as a leader but still was responsible for impacting the lives of soldiers

Response by SGT David Jackson made Mar 2 at 2022 6:39 PM

2022-03-02T18:39:43-05:00

Fort Campbell, Kentucky. Basic Training November 1, 1966, we were introduced to our Platoon Sgt. We held our collective breaths for the other shoe to drop, praying silently that he would never take it off in the presence of friendly forces.
THAT RANK WAS PURE STANK!
As for rewarding, he was sent to Korea, then 'Nam, and we could breathe again! Patience DOES have its own rewards, but my nostrils still hurt.

Response by MSgt Skyhawk Cessna made Mar 2 at 2022 6:42 PM

2022-03-02T18:42:26-05:00

For me it had to be Master Sergeant. I put Master on PFE Only because I had just changed from Loadmaster to Navigation Systems. Shortly after I went to work for the 37th Tactical Fighter Wing at George AFB (now closed) and was dropped into the deep end by being made NCOIC of the Runway Operations Monitor program. I had to recruit, train and schedule over eighty-eight young airmen how to man the mobile towers at the end of the runway to watch for pilots who were attempting to land with the gear up in their F-4s. The rewarding part was the satisfaction of being told by the Wing DO that I was doing an outstanding job and having a couple of my people make saves. They worked two hour shifts, dawn to dusk, in addition to their regular jobs. That was how I spent the last two and a half years of my enlistment.

Response by PO1 Jd Briscoe made Mar 2 at 2022 6:44 PM

2022-03-02T18:44:01-05:00

Electronics Tech First Class Petty Officer E-6. In charge of 26 very intelligent ETs. Like herding cats!

Response by Cpl Ronnell Storie made Mar 2 at 2022 6:51 PM

2022-03-02T18:51:53-05:00

For me it was Corporal. All your friends..privates, pfc's, and lcpl's,, you had to leave behind. Now you are supposed to associate wiith other nco's, most of which you know nothing about.

Response by CPL Jason Blackwood made Mar 2 at 2022 6:57 PM

2022-03-02T18:57:47-05:00

I wasn't enlisted for long. So I guess my last rank was the most difficult.

Response by AB Lori McCurry made Mar 2 at 2022 7:04 PM

2022-03-02T19:04:18-05:00

The lowest. Airman Basic. Lowest rank. See the most. Talk less. Do more. Respect more. Salute more. But learn more…….

Response by SPC Nate Threety made Mar 2 at 2022 7:19 PM

2022-03-02T19:19:39-05:00

I'd say Specialist was the most challenging and rewarding, since I made it twice.

Response by SPC Nicholas Reed made Mar 2 at 2022 8:06 PM

2022-03-02T20:06:14-05:00

E-5

Response by Cpl Bennie Jackson made Mar 2 at 2022 8:17 PM

2022-03-02T20:17:55-05:00

Corporal (E4), was the most rewarding and challenging. When I was promoted to Corporal, I had to act as an NCO and lead as an NCO. Yet I had to continue to have a relationship with my fellow subordinates.

Response by CAPT Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 2 at 2022 8:42 PM

2022-03-02T20:42:06-05:00

Lieutenant (O3) was most challenging. I was responsible for 25 senior enlisted and 800 brand new sailors at Recruit Training Command Orlando. As a Lieutenant, I was senior enough to have a lot of responsibility, but still junior enough to be able to experiment and ask for forgiveness if I got over my skis too far. It was a great paygrade/rank to improve my leadership skills and learn what kind of officer I wanted to be.

Response by CPL Michael Shuey made Mar 2 at 2022 8:43 PM

2022-03-02T20:43:30-05:00

For me the most challanging but rewarding rank was Cpl E-4, which in the Army is a lateral promotion from Spec E-4 and viewed by most as a Joke. As its the exact same rank and pay as any amd every E-4 in the army which any yahoo can get given they have a few brain cells and can maintain at least the minimum Army standard for 2 years, then they atomatically obtain a promotion from E-3 to E-4 which is why the lateral upgrade to Cpl isnt given the respect and authority that other branches Cpl ranks demand. Being a Cpl in the Army is a junior NCO which adds to the asinine chaos which is inherently present with the rank. It is however needed when the individual is in an MOS which is overcrowded and has to many E-5s for that given MOS causing the points needed to obtain a promotion from
E-4 to E-5 to be at Max or so close to Max that getting promoted is only possible if the individual happend to have a college degree of at least an associates already in their resume. As with me I had every possible points at max except the possible points I could have gotten from College Classes. Which continued to cause me to miss points each month
Though my unit needed a competent Team leader for our platoon so the rank was needed I gladly proformed the added responsibilities though nothing else rank wise changed, nore did I ever push the issue with those under me. I definately enjoyed the responsibilities of looking after more than just my own well being and IMO did an exceptional job. I had a Sgt under me as one of my soldiers whom at the time they were in the process of trying to get him demoted as he was definitely not competent enough to preform the role of a Sgt, while as a person he was a decent guy, and actually trying to fill the role. Making me and im sure many other feel bad about his situation. Im certain that was the reason why the company took so long to process his demotion papers as most people felt sorry for him his heart was in it but he wasnt one you would want making decisions over seas and such. I looked after my soldiers above and beyond even giving up my days off to give to my soliders. Had points not of been at an asinine high for so long I may have signed up for a 2nd Term. However after dealing with nearly 10 months of Maxed points I refused all the attempts my NCOs tried to throw my way to get me to stay in. With offering some decent incentives and duty stations the stagnation of rank had trumpted anything they could offer. No forward progress in a timely manor at any position / Job is not something I can allow at any job unless the pay is right.

Response by CWO4 Robert J. Perry MBA made Mar 2 at 2022 8:46 PM

2022-03-02T20:46:30-05:00

I think my hardest was going from enlisted to Warrant Officer

Response by SPC Joseph Merritt made Mar 2 at 2022 8:56 PM

2022-03-02T20:56:25-05:00

SP4 was my most challenging because I was considered the supervisor of the battalion motor pool prescribed load list. I had others that I was in charge of but I ended up doing most of the work. Keeping track of inventory. Direct exchange and ordering of all needed parts for the batallion vehicles and howitzers. I even passed the inspector general's surprize inspection and received the distinguished trooper award for perfect paperwork and inventory. There were many nights I took my books and paperwork to the barracks to finish processing on my own time. I went into the army as loser who couldn't keep a job and came out a winner who found there is nothing you can't do if you put your best foot forward. I thank god for the army. It made a strong and determined man out of me!

Response by Sgt John Buettner made Mar 2 at 2022 9:08 PM

2022-03-02T21:08:07-05:00

Without a doubt, civilian!

Response by 1SG Michael Perdue made Mar 2 at 2022 9:21 PM

2022-03-02T21:21:36-05:00

1SGT Was the most challenging as the responsibility was overwhelming, but the results were very satisfying to show as a deployed unit with 380 soldiers.

Response by Karen Faye made Mar 2 at 2022 9:25 PM

2022-03-02T21:25:46-05:00

The absolute most difficult challenge EVER is being a young Gold Star Wife.!!! But meeting other amazing Gold Star Wives is without a doubt rewarding to see how these wonderful women survive after such tragedies in our lives. My husband’s death day is tomorrow March 3rd. It is now 24 years without him!! He was a United States Marine.

Response by SSgt William Thomas made Mar 2 at 2022 9:27 PM

2022-03-02T21:27:28-05:00

E -1 as it really made me responsible after being a wreckless teen ager. It also made me understand teamwork and what would happen if I didn't follow orders.

Response by PO2 Larry Markowitz made Mar 2 at 2022 9:28 PM

2022-03-02T21:28:31-05:00

US Navy, PO 2. I ended up running the electronic shop. Keeping 13 planes electronic ready and keeping track of 36 guys. My PO 1's and Chiefs were always off doing there things and left me in charge all the time. Got there early and stayed late! My first time having that responsibility thrust upon me. My squadron had just gotten 13 P-3 planes. That was new for all of us. This was in 1967. My Navy time was from 63-67.

Response by SFC Thomas Peacock made Mar 2 at 2022 9:28 PM

2022-03-02T21:28:57-05:00

I would have to say SFC/E-7. I was in the 104th Div. (Tng) as a Drill Instructor. As an E-7 I was the Senior Drill Instructor (SDI) and had up to four Junior DI's I was responsible for, plus 50 - 60 recruits that I had to manage. I started out as an E-5 and didn't have too much paperwork, just troops to train and whatever chores the E-6's and the SDI tasked me with. As an E-6, I considered that position the rocking chair as I had E-5's to boss around, and the SDI was more likely to task the 5's with work than the 6's. Once I made E-7 and became the SDI is when I learned you spend more time behind a desk than you do out in the field with the troops. As previously stated, lots of paperwork, career management for the 5's and 6's below you, training records, guard duty rosters, and so many other records to keep and maintain. There are training ranges you have to coordinate, transportation for the recruits, the different necessities at the ranges like lister bags, chow, medical personnel, and on and on. Despite all the different tasks to be done, when the day is over and the troops have all been successfully trained, fed, and watered, when the training cycle is over and all or most of the recruits have graduated and headed off to their next phase in Army life, and when your Junior DI's have been duly recognized, have been placed on track for schools to advance their careers, and have the time off with their families after the cycle is over, the feeling that you have accomplished all of this despite the long hours and snafus that can and do arise is truly a rewarding experience.

Response by PFC Jaime Vargas made Mar 2 at 2022 9:50 PM

2022-03-02T21:50:03-05:00

Corporal of Marines

Response by SGT Matthew Camp made Mar 2 at 2022 10:01 PM

2022-03-02T22:01:52-05:00

I would have to say CPL(Army). It was the most challenging for obvious reasons, low man on the totem pole, increased responsibility with no extra pay, etc. But I found it to be the most rewarding because most Soldiers never get that rank. I considered it an honor to be put in a position very few ever experience.

Response by MSgt Matthew Stogsdill made Mar 2 at 2022 10:04 PM

2022-03-02T22:04:29-05:00

Transitioning from SrA (E4) to SSgt (E5) was the most challenging for me. I had to go from being colleagues to supervising 25 Other troops. I had to teach my troops the difference that being a good supervisor meant being hard and holding others accountable to the same standards. It cost me a lot of friendships but it was the most rewarding experience because I got to mentor and teach others how to be great police officers in the Air Force. Once my troops understood accountability and dedication relationships we’re stronger than ever after this transition. I know those troops would have my back to this day.

Response by GySgt John W Dugan made Mar 2 at 2022 10:08 PM

2022-03-02T22:08:14-05:00

SSgt. I was one of the few that were promoted but not transferred to another unit upon promotion.

Response by PO3 William Larson made Mar 2 at 2022 10:22 PM

2022-03-02T22:22:26-05:00

E5 (2nd Class), by far over the E6 (1st Class) types I served under, when rated as E4 (3rd Class) AE-3, with VAH-4, and during 2 tours of duty Viet Nam, Tonkin Gulf, c.'67- '68, as Det. Libra, Det 14, aboard USS Bon Homme Richard CVA-31, USS Ticonderoga CVA-14, respectively.

Response by SGT Lisa Wu made Mar 2 at 2022 10:38 PM

2022-03-02T22:38:03-05:00

Definitely becoming an NCO at E5, it is just a point of achievement and something felt different about it. It was like the make it or break it point.

Response by 1LT Richard Imperato made Mar 2 at 2022 10:57 PM

2022-03-02T22:57:43-05:00

The most challenging rank was "Officer Candidate" in OCS. It rewarded me by not only becoming an officer, but by teaching me how to be a man and enhance others around me.

Response by MSG Brandon Lloyd made Mar 2 at 2022 10:59 PM

2022-03-02T22:59:11-05:00

E-5, Sergeant. You are seasoned in many ways but brand new when it comes to taking full responsibility not only for your actions and decisions but you now do it for up to 6-7 lower enlisted troops. You’re their mom, their dad, their mentor, their trained, and btheir bondsman, etc. you have to make sure they are doing the right things in all aspects of Soldiering but also that they are taking care of their families and have everything they need.
Learning how to take the time and lead each Soldier in the way they needed to be led while making sure their is no favoritism happening. Unfortunately they are young. Some catch on quick and some drag things out and get dubbed “leadership challenges. Those are will develop a SGT leadership style.

Th most rewarding moments for me where when i had my medics spread all Over Afghanistan and they were making me proud. But on two different ambush attacks over 2 days 2 of the medics l had
Been Forceable when training them in all scenarios they may face.
It paid off and they were both Awarded silver star medals. Very proud moment for a leader

Response by PO3 Lisa O'Brien made Mar 2 at 2022 11:04 PM

2022-03-02T23:04:29-05:00

I believe the most challenging rank for me was Petty Officer 2nd Class. I was in the medical field (dental corp) in the DC area. The rewarding effects from that advancement taught me to be more disciplined in accepting guidance from my peers priming me for my civilian teaching career.

Response by SSG Robert Waddell made Mar 2 at 2022 11:10 PM

2022-03-02T23:10:41-05:00

Staff Sergeant was my hardest

Response by MSgt Jim Whitney made Mar 2 at 2022 11:12 PM

2022-03-02T23:12:55-05:00

E6 T/sgt. it took 6years

Response by SSgt David Gordon made Mar 2 at 2022 11:14 PM

2022-03-02T23:14:56-05:00

E-5 Sgt. USMC. (Hard because) Found myself with a whole lot of responsibility that my rank didn't always have the juice to get done. (Rewarding because) finding ways around those rank road blocks, mostly legal...kinda, and getting them done.

Response by Maj Edward Bucnis made Mar 2 at 2022 11:28 PM

2022-03-02T23:28:02-05:00

All of them! Always tried to do my best and sometimes others with less seniority were promoted ahead of me, but that was okay. Back in the day when we were recognized as Airman Basic (E-1), 3rd Class (E-2) , 2nd Class (E-3), and 1st Class (E-4), I was filling an TSgt (E-6) slot as an E-3 crew chief in the Nuclear Weapons field. My NCOIC would take me into the NCO club for a "passover" round of drinks when all four of my crew were promoted over me. He told me to never let it get me down; and it hasn't. When I finally made E-4, the base newspaper posted my picture on the front page declaring that miracles do happen (my NCOIC probably had something to do with that). And when I made E-5 years later with over 7 years service, my First Sergeant wanted to know "how that could have happened." Seven more years quickly went by before E-6, but by then I was selected for OTS (and I wondered how that could have happened). Now as a much older reserve officer, I made O-2 and O-3 on time and was told I would never make 0-4. At the 27 career-year mark, I was offered a regular commission, but turned it down stating it should go to someone who would have more time left before retirement. I was told the commission could never be offered again; I signed the declination. The very next year, it was offered again and again I turned it down. One year later I was promoted to O-4 and seven months later I was told to retire (downsized). From my enlisted days in the nuke, administrative, and manpower fields then as an industrial engineering officer in Civil Engineering and finally Associate Professor at AFIT, it had been a blast and I do believe miracle do happen, even to someone like me.

Response by SCPO John Dudas made Mar 2 at 2022 11:37 PM

2022-03-02T23:37:06-05:00

Making Chief in the US Navy while on Submarine Duty. Being responsible for answering the Tradition of "Ask the Chief" and you had better have the answer no matter what. The responsibilities of a Navy Chief go way beyond the rank of E-7, especially on a submarine where there is no outside way to find an answer when you are under the ice cap. It is the best job I have ever had and developed my actions to issues well beyond my Navy Retirement. And YES, I would do it all over again!
John Dudas MMCS(SS) USN RET.

Response by PO2 Mickey Ragan made Mar 2 at 2022 11:40 PM

2022-03-02T23:40:57-05:00

E-5 due to being off coast of Viet Nam in 1972 and duties put on a ship fitter/ hull tech. Damage control and helicopter operations for rearming, refueling at sea. Would not change anything for the world.

Response by CPL Albert Howard made Mar 2 at 2022 11:57 PM

2022-03-02T23:57:54-05:00

E1: Adjusting to Army Life and all of the mental and physical challenges.

Response by Sgt Earl Neconie made Mar 3 at 2022 12:16 AM

2022-03-03T00:16:18-05:00

Without a doubt; Sergeant (E-5) USMC! All of a sudden, your friends become your subordinates and Marines are excited for each other during promotions; it gives them hope and preps them for that next stripe! “Lead By Example” is your new mantra 24/7! These young Marines have a lot to offer and delegating assignments and duty rosters involve trust and confidence that goes both ways! Lot of Marines want to show what they can offer their Sergeant and are eagerly awaiting orders from a confident NCO…Semper Fi

Response by Cpl Cynthia Ryan made Mar 3 at 2022 12:24 AM

2022-03-03T00:24:57-05:00

E-4 - Corporal as I was in a new unit while mine was deployed in the First Gulf War. I knew my score was close but the Gunny that was in charge didn’t like that I was a single mom. So once my unit came back and I was back in my shop my MSgt ran my score and pushed to get my promotion. I was also close to getting out and the Marine who took over my Job failed to include my new rank so while I was on leave I worked to get my back pay and my DD214 corrected. While I never wore my rank I was proud to say I was an E-4 - Corporal.

Response by PO1 Linda M. made Mar 3 at 2022 12:27 AM

2022-03-03T00:27:46-05:00

PO1/E-6 - was the most challenging for me because you were expected to have all the answers to the issues/concerns of higher level leadership but it was also the most rewarding because it meant SHARING the skills and knowledge I had developed in my career with the junior personnel which I was charged to lead. Seeing them succeed and become great leaders who did the same, is my greatest accomplishment.

Response by James Rush made Mar 3 at 2022 12:52 AM

2022-03-03T00:52:55-05:00

Pvt E-2. My platoon sgt during basic was field first. I was trainee platoon leader. He gave me a 22-5 field manual and I did most of the training to my fellow trainee's. Greatly enhanced my self esteem and opened my eyes to the fact I did have something on the ball. In 1966 thru 1968 when I was in there was a great shortage of D.I.

Response by SGT Michael Brand made Mar 3 at 2022 2:24 AM

2022-03-03T02:24:02-05:00

SGT/E-5

Response by PFC Kenneth Burgess made Mar 3 at 2022 2:41 AM

2022-03-03T02:41:51-05:00

Being born and raised in a small town in Iowa was not a preemptive exercise for success in a foreign country, particularly in the 60’s in the America! I was in a Medical detachment in Germany being a Dental Assistant in normal procedures plus emergency room duties about once a week! I learned plethora amounts regarding life, foreign countries, and last but not least, myself. I would recommend volunteering in any of the armed forces in the USA for a enhanced trip regarding life in general.

Response by SSG Michael Shaginaw made Mar 3 at 2022 3:16 AM

2022-03-03T03:16:59-05:00

The most challenging but rewarding rank was being converted from a Spc-5 to Sergeant E-5. There was a lot more responsibility and growth required. I was no longer a technician but took on the responsibility of being a squad leader. This prepared me for the challenges that would come with my promotion to E-6.

Response by TSgt Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 3 at 2022 3:52 AM

2022-03-03T03:52:58-05:00

For me it was Staff Seargent. Transitioning to this rank was challenging because it was the first time I had to draw the line between business and friendship. What I mean is, I had to often lead those whom I was friends with in situations that caused friction with my friendships because of my leadership style, so that I as the leader and we as a team could accomplish our task. The rewarding part came when my, peers and leadership acknowledge my ability to lead by nominating me for awards and giving more opportunities to lead in greater tasks proving that they trust my leadership capabilities.

Response by SN William Culotta made Mar 3 at 2022 4:33 AM

2022-03-03T04:33:44-05:00

Being H. Co Clerk in Chu Lai Vietnam and working in civic action helping the Vietamese people!

BillCulotta

Response by PO2 Larry Fullhart made Mar 3 at 2022 4:52 AM

2022-03-03T04:52:23-05:00

ET2 because at the time there were a lot of ET3's going for E5 and therefore it was difficult to make grade.

Response by SPC Phyllis Christy made Mar 3 at 2022 5:18 AM

2022-03-03T05:18:32-05:00

I think being an E1 in the Army was the most challenging but also the most rewarding. During the time at basic training I was at the bottom of the food chain. I had to learn what my strengths were and what I was capable of. I was pushed to achieve my best and what I learned has stayed with me even today.

Response by LTC Tom Nathe made Mar 3 at 2022 5:29 AM

2022-03-03T05:29:40-05:00

2LT was very challenging because after OCS I was assigned to the same unit where I was a SGT E6. I wasn't sure how the soldiers I served with would react to my recent promotion. Of course there a few who just would not respond to my "orders." However after they saw the new rank didn't go to my head they were OK with me in my new role. WHEW!

Response by SSgt Jose Sanchez made Mar 3 at 2022 7:00 AM

2022-03-03T07:00:32-05:00

Staff Sergeant / E-5 was a challenging time for me as i moved from being a load crew member to a lead with my own load crew. As i took on the new assignment it was difficult at first leading my crew and getting certified. My training as I was moving from a 5 level to a 7 level made my job easier and helped my crew understand what i expected from them and what they could expect from me.

Response by SP5 Stephanie Huff made Mar 3 at 2022 7:21 AM

2022-03-03T07:21:01-05:00

Sgt E5

Response by SP5 Stephanie Huff made Mar 3 at 2022 7:22 AM

2022-03-03T07:22:25-05:00

This rank put you in a role more as supervisor, leadership. I felt at this rank I was able to truly share the training I had been trained for.

Response by SGT Jack Heini made Mar 3 at 2022 7:41 AM

2022-03-03T07:41:08-05:00

SGT. E-5

Response by SGT Jack Heini made Mar 3 at 2022 7:42 AM

2022-03-03T07:42:11-05:00

SGT E-5 Leadership, and Mentoring.

Response by SCPO Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 3 at 2022 7:53 AM

2022-03-03T07:53:56-05:00

All ranks are both challenging and rewarding! It's what you make and do with the situation you are in. Regardless of the position you are in or the command climate, it really boils down to the individuals decision of how they will follow or lead.

Response by SCPO Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 3 at 2022 7:54 AM

2022-03-03T07:54:18-05:00

All of them!

Response by CMSgt Marcus Falleaf made Mar 3 at 2022 7:57 AM

2022-03-03T07:57:47-05:00

E-7 Master Sergeant was both the most challenging and most rewarding because I became a First Sergeant. Attending the school under the tutelage of a friend and mentor who was an instructor made the pressure of success even more intense. Then, to deploy to Saudi Arabia as one of ten selected traditional 1st Sgts increased my desire for movement to the top. I eventually made E-9 CMS, but I'll never forget my experience as a "1st Shirt".

Response by SPC Terry Barker made Mar 3 at 2022 7:58 AM

2022-03-03T07:58:07-05:00

Private was the most challenging rank and maybe the most rewarding. Being a private you are the low man on the totem pole. You must complete all the tasks that higher ranked soldiers don't want to do. You are always at the end of the formation and seem to be overlooked by most officers. It was also the most rewarding rank because you learn so much. You learn the basic soldiering skills needed to survive in military operations. It is also such a great accomplishment and honor when you get your PVT2 rank.

Response by SPC Wendy Dunn made Mar 3 at 2022 8:01 AM

2022-03-03T08:01:27-05:00

PFC I joined as a PFC in 1983 (Female) I found out real quick that a lot of my superiors were intimidated by a female freshly out of college. When I tested to join I got the highest score out of everyone testing at the same time. I had a lot of obstacles to overcome but I persevered and proved that I belonged in THEIR Army.

Response by SCPO Jack Carlsen made Mar 3 at 2022 8:03 AM

2022-03-03T08:03:59-05:00

First Class Petty Officer / E-6. In the US Navy this is the rank where you are challenged to really up your game and take on new responsibilities before being selected to the Chief Petty Officer Ranks. No longer is "moving up" based solely on test scores and evaluations but, your record is now screened annually to see if you have what it takes to become a Chief Petty Officer. Along with your daily responsibilities, you start to really take on the leadership role for your Sailors. Their well being and accomplishing the mission of your shop/work center is your first responsibility. Everything from uniforms to spare parts and everything in between is up to you to check daily. Your Chief, who has been there and done that, watches your every move. To the point of even letting you fail at times to make sure you learn the lesson (Of course he/she has your back when those failures occur if he or she is worth their salt.) Every day is a new adventure, as you become the mentor, enemy, best friend, guidance counselor, shoulder to cry on, father they never had, you name it for your Sailors. It is a lot of long days and at times putting your family second when you are called back to work or to help a junior Sailor fix his car so he can get to work the next day. You learn that it is the people that work for you everyday that make you a success, as long as you take care of them. First Class Petty Officer is where you are challenged at times to take on the work of a Chief Petty Officer, to start cutting your teeth so that you can one day join the ranks of the Chief Petty Officers to make the Navy Run.

Response by SSG Archie Martinez made Mar 3 at 2022 8:04 AM

2022-03-03T08:04:58-05:00

E-4 was my most challenging rank while in the Army because my goal was to become a non-commissioned officer (NCO) but those who didn’t aspire the same felt it would change existing relationships for the worse since I could potentially become their squad or platoon leader. This being said, many in the ranks of E-4 or below chose to distant themselves from me knowing all likelihood of the latter.

Response by SN James Johnson made Mar 3 at 2022 8:28 AM

2022-03-03T08:28:28-05:00

Seaman recruit

Response by 1LT Michael Contos made Mar 3 at 2022 8:31 AM

2022-03-03T08:31:49-05:00

I served as a first lieutenant in the Vietnam War and guided my platoon through enemy fire, friendly fire, and the use of C-4 from a claymore mine to "fire up" the morning coffee in the bush. None of my troops were killed even though five were wounded during one episode some 50 miles outside of Saigon in 1970.

Response by SMSgt Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 3 at 2022 9:10 AM

2022-03-03T09:10:18-05:00

sergeant was the most rewarding and hard, had to go before a board

Response by SGT Tim Tobin made Mar 3 at 2022 9:17 AM

2022-03-03T09:17:53-05:00

I concur with Sfc Joe Davis. Buck Sgt. Was my first exposure to true leadership. I was converted from a Spec 5 to Sgt when I had a change in assignment. The expectations were greater. I liked it! Helped me in civilian life when I became a manager

Response by Sgt James Slomba made Mar 3 at 2022 9:21 AM

2022-03-03T09:21:29-05:00

Definitely the promotion to Sargeant was challenging. Being a leader with bigger expectations and acknowledging that you were always expected to lead by example is a big step in the military. It introduced me to what is required to be an effective leader and manager of people. This also translates into the civilian world job skills.

Response by MGySgt Rod Richards made Mar 3 at 2022 9:21 AM

2022-03-03T09:21:59-05:00

In the Marine Corps it seemed that the enlisted rank expectations were set up to alternate in how much they could suck.
Pvt and PFC - yep, no question, sucked
LCpl – you weren’t the lowest and generally responsible for nothing
Cpl – Now you are an NCO and expected to lead all your drinking buddies
Sgt – NCO, but separated yourself, more experienced, higher regard
SSgt – Awful. Now you have to be a SNCO and do SNCO stuff, but can barely spell SNCO
Gunny – Plenty of responsibility, but plenty of influence and power
MSgt / 1st Sgt – Tired, just tired.
MGySgt / Sgt Maj – Not crap taken from any direction.

Response by MGySgt Rod Richards made Mar 3 at 2022 9:24 AM

2022-03-03T09:24:23-05:00

Response by PO1 Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 3 at 2022 9:41 AM

2022-03-03T09:41:03-05:00

I think being an E-5 (HM2) was the hardest yet easily the most rewarding because those junior to me seemed to trust and connect with their HM2s. My junior staff 99% of the time are making the mission happen - I'm just there to help them grow. Hardest because I was stuck in the middle of being an LPO/middle manager while still being junior myself - a grey area where I relied on my peers for personal and professional connection to care for myself.

Response by SPC Andrew Sanchez made Mar 3 at 2022 9:56 AM

2022-03-03T09:56:25-05:00

E-1 was probably the most challenging because I had to overcome quite a bit in my life. But it was basic training that got me through everything building a team relationship with all of my buddies. When I graduated from basic I did not have a single family member show up and I looked across the field and I saw a band of brothers that was there for me and had my back for life. I will never forget that moment with all those brothers.

Response by Sgt William Tust made Mar 3 at 2022 10:00 AM

2022-03-03T10:00:26-05:00

Buck Sargent, E4 - USAF - during 1966-1970.

Response by Sgt William Tust made Mar 3 at 2022 10:01 AM

2022-03-03T10:01:29-05:00

Buck Sargent - USAF - E4 - GEEIA, electronic installations... fitted my civilian training!

Response by Lt Col Randy George made Mar 3 at 2022 10:12 AM

2022-03-03T10:12:06-05:00

Making Lt Col and being selected for squadron command. This validated my years of dedication and determination to be an Air Force leader.

Response by TSgt Kimberly Stone made Mar 3 at 2022 10:14 AM

2022-03-03T10:14:42-05:00

The most rewarding and challenging rank was as an AF Staff Sergeant (SSgt). When you are a young airman you are a mentor to your fellow airman and help each other out where you can. Once you become an Non Commissioned Officer (NCO) (aka SSgt), then you have more responsibility because you become a supervisor to those you were once working alongside. Now, you work alongside them but the difference is, they work for you as well as alongside you. I miss the comradery and friendships that came alongside bein active duty. No regrets! Proud to be an Airman (Retired!)

Response by 2LT Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 3 at 2022 10:18 AM

2022-03-03T10:18:37-05:00

Quartermaster Second Lieutenant responsible for 44 enlisted soldiers was the most challenging, frustrating, but also the most rewarding. This was just after the Vietnam War and after the last draft call on December 7, 1972, and the expiration of the authority to induct on June 30, 1973. My Platoon Sergeant who was a short timer was was just going through the motions and not any help. Effectively, this Platoon Sergeant was relieved and a lower ranking sergeant performed the duties of Platoon Sergeant. Of the 44 soldiers under my leadership, 42 had not finished high school and 2 had a choice jail or the army. In 2 years, my platoon became the best performing platoon in the company. Our equipment readiness for combat was the highest. My platoon was able to successfully perform the difficult and dangerous hot refueling of Huey and Cobra helicopters. Hot refueling is dangerous because the helicopters never shut down with helicopter blades swirling just feet overhead as highly highly flammable jet fuel is poured into their fuel tanks. One spark from the helicopter's engines or one spark from static electricity generated by the jet fuel racing through the fuel lines would cause an unbelievable explosion killing the pilots and the soldiers refueling the helicopter. Thank God this nightmare explosion never occurred on my watch.

Response by SP5 Jeff Mykel made Mar 3 at 2022 10:28 AM

2022-03-03T10:28:23-05:00

SPECIALEST E5

Response by PO2 Justin Bussard made Mar 3 at 2022 10:28 AM

2022-03-03T10:28:36-05:00

The rank that was the most challenging but rewarding for me was E-5 Petty Officer 2nd class. I had all the responsibilities of an E-6 witch was challenging but also helped me to learn how to manage and lead other sailors.

Response by PO2 Richard Mathis made Mar 3 at 2022 11:10 AM

2022-03-03T11:10:27-05:00

When I attained the Rank of E5 (FTG2), late 1974 while onboard the USS Wainwright CG28, I became the work Center Supervisor, Damage Control PO for 2nd Division, Watch Station Assigning PO, Maintenace PO for the FTG's, and assisted with Morning Quarters, at first it seemed Overwhelming, but later I began to enjoy my newly assigned Task, "Go Navy", my late Father who retired from the Navy Suggested when I made E5 that I learn how to Step on Someone's Shoes and not mess up the Shine.

Response by CPO Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 3 at 2022 11:17 AM

2022-03-03T11:17:53-05:00

The most challenging, yet rewarding paygrade was AE1/E6. I started my Navy career on the fast track making AE2 in 2.5 years. E5 in my opinion was the easiest paygrade, was a supervisor, but not in charge of a entire work center. When I made E6, I started out great, was awarded Sailor of the Year, then went on to win wing SOY. That same year I was on deployment to Misawa Japan and got in trouble on base. I went to mast and 3 days later the Chief results came out and I was on the list. Well, my CO withdrew my advancement, and I was stuck at AE1 for 4 more years. I then transferred squadrons, buckled down and in 2016 was awarded SOY and again wing SOY. I still did not make Chief so I was placed in the line shack where I spent the best tour of my career. Multiple undesignated Sailors of mine wanted to become AE's and still to this day, I get calls and emails from Sailors wanting me to pin them or re-enlist them. Although I was selected to AEC in 2014, I regret nothing because I was able to help more Sailors as AE1 than any other rank. Those Sailors are the reason I was again selected to AEC/E7 in 2018.

Response by Lt Col Tom Cornatzer made Mar 3 at 2022 11:19 AM

2022-03-03T11:19:02-05:00

Looking back after 36 years in the militant I would say that the rank of Maj was the challenging but also the most rewarding. At this point there was so much to accomplish with PME , deployments , on going civilian education, establishing clear leadership for those I want to set the example for. Finding balance in my own family life while at the same time looking to the future for continuing further advancement in rank.

Response by SFC Mike Jerrell made Mar 3 at 2022 11:21 AM

2022-03-03T11:21:37-05:00

Actually, it was Private! I was 17years and 25 days old, Dec 3rd, 1963. President Kennedy had been assassinated, and Viet Nam was a skirmish that everyone was talking about. Private Jerrell, US Army. I'm off to Basic Training at Fort Polk, LA. Into a cattle car, stand at attention, push-ups, pull-ups, Sgt Davidson seemed like he singled me out, yelling and telling me I was still a kid. Well, I grew up fast and will forever be thankful for those first 8 weeks. WOW. Still a private I shipped off to Fort Sill, OK. for cannon cocker school. Again, learning, learning, learning.
I'm now 75 years old, retired from the U.S. Army, spent a tour in Viet Nam, 2 tours in Germany and I will be forever grateful to all that made me the person I am today. Yes, Private was by far the most rewarding. Private to Private first class, what a time.

Response by PVT David Robinson made Mar 3 at 2022 11:26 AM

2022-03-03T11:26:07-05:00

e-1

Response by PO2 Vic Steele made Mar 3 at 2022 11:39 AM

2022-03-03T11:39:40-05:00

THE RANK OF E-5 WAS MY MOST CHALLENGING YET REWARDING BECAUSE I WAS AT A POINT IN MY CAREER THAT I COULD MENTOR AND STILL BE MENTORED. GIVING ADVICE WAS GREAT BUT ALSO REALISING I STILL HAD A LOT TO LEARN. WHAT WAS EVEN MORE REWARDING WAS AT THE POINT WHERE MY ACTIONS WERE INFLUENCIAL TO JOUNIOR MEMBERS AND RANKED PEERS. IT WAS A RANK THAT HELPED ME EVOLVE AS AN ADULT. I WAS GIVENTHE ABILITY TO LEAD BUT I WAS ALSO AT THE STAGE WHERE I HAD THE ABILITY TO INQUIRE AND NOT FEEL LIKE I WAS NOT ADEQUATE FOR NOT KNOWING. I COULD STILL GO "ASK THE CHIEF". BEING AN E-5 HAS TAUGHT ME SO MANY LESSIONS THAT I UTILIZE TO THIS DAY. I HAVE NEVER STOPPED LEARING AND I USED THE ABILITIS TO LEAD TO EXCELIN MY CIVILIAN CAREEER.

Response by CPT Kent Worrall made Mar 3 at 2022 11:53 AM

2022-03-03T11:53:01-05:00

Private E1 was my most challenging and rewarding experience! I was about to be drafted during the Vietnam War, so I enlisted instead. I had heard that you could enlist in order to obtain a desirable position, mine being OCS. Basic was a culture, mental, and physical challenge. I only weighed 117 pounds at the time, having been a distance runner in high school. Being so light, I was almost not accepted into the Army. After being bused to Benning, I really didn't think my first training morning would be buffing floors and cleaning a latrine, but it was. The discipline I was exposed too grew me up quickly. Every morning, our company ran around a very dusty training field. The dust raised by our feet made it hard to breathe and see. I caught URI No. 2. I guess you could call it pneumonia. I was admitted to the base hospital for a week. I returned to my unit upon release and learned that our company was on field exercises. Our staff sergeant informed me that I might be recycled to start basic all over again. He asked me if I could type; I said yes. I became his clerk for a week. He said I could still possibly be recycled. I was allowed to complete the rest of basic, with a decision to still be made about me being recycled. In our final week, we participated in a mile run in fatigues and combat boots. I outran the entire company and was allowed to graduate from basic training. If I had been recycled, I may never have completed OCS, attended flight training or flown helicopters in Vietnam, married my wife, had two children, or have completed any of the additional things I have done in my life. My entire life would have been different. My military experience as a private E1 was my foundation for my becoming a forthright individual in our society!

Response by LTC Bill Starr made Mar 3 at 2022 12:12 PM

2022-03-03T12:12:38-05:00

Although I completed my 23-year career as a Lieutenant Colonel, I believe the most demanding and rewarding rank I held during my career was as a Captain serving as a Company Commander. The position of company commander carries with it the authority and decision making in every facet of the company organization and functions. All things go through the company commander. It was an exhilarating and demanding experience resulting in experience and personal growth that cannot be had anywhere else in the Army. I think the experience caused me to be a better officer and leader going forward.

Response by PO2 Mike Lewis made Mar 3 at 2022 12:36 PM

2022-03-03T12:36:37-05:00

The E-6 rank, on the border of accountability to the enlisted but still requiring approval to make decisions.

Response by 1stSgt Tom McGarry made Mar 3 at 2022 1:19 PM

2022-03-03T13:19:05-05:00

E-6 TSGT. Tasked with senior NCO duties and responsibilities. Duties in between jr NCO and senior NCO.

Response by MSG Angel Kersey made Mar 3 at 2022 1:34 PM

2022-03-03T13:34:23-05:00

Without a doubt, Sergeant E5. The transition from peer to supervisor can be extremely challenging & emotionally isolating. Supervising people who were once your peers who knows you well, hung out with you, & knows all your flaws; but are now your subordinates may sometimes place you in positions that challenges your leadership skills. Earning their respect while simultaneously demonstrating to your own supervisors that you are competent, can build a team, & accomplish missions truly defines your primary leadership skills.

Response by SSgt Donald Hahn made Mar 3 at 2022 1:36 PM

2022-03-03T13:36:19-05:00

Mine was E-4 Senior Airman to Buck Sgt. I have always felt that is where I learned my job and responsibilities as a leader.

Response by Sgt Ivan Boatwright made Mar 3 at 2022 1:37 PM

2022-03-03T13:37:01-05:00

Sargent E-5 was the most rewarding. I served in Vietnam as a combat Marine from June 6, 1965, until April 12, 1968. I was gone for ninety days between deployments. I got it by doing my job and not getting killed. I felt like John Wayne in one of his war movies by making the stripe. Today, I am older and wiser.

Response by CPL Violet Brogdon made Mar 3 at 2022 2:14 PM

2022-03-03T14:14:32-05:00

PFC. lowest of rank in the army. Received little or no respect from the higher ranks. It was a very trying time for me as a women’s Army Corps member. I was so grateful when my boss who was the Chaplains Colonel updated my rank to E4. They gave me respect as the first Women’s Chaplains Assistant.. Even though my bosses were both Colonels I was respected and treated with dignity at the Chapel Center where I worked. Wonderful people I worked with.

Response by SMSgt Terry LLoyd made Mar 3 at 2022 2:30 PM

2022-03-03T14:30:40-05:00

E-8, because I became pretty bullet proof and could challenge and change stupid decisions by field grade officers. Yes, I retired as an E-8, too...

Response by SPC Jamie Williams made Mar 3 at 2022 2:35 PM

2022-03-03T14:35:36-05:00

My Most challenging but rewarding rank would have been my E2 during a family emergency. I was in San Antonio, Texas, attending my first section of courses (91B) for my nursing job (91C). Red Cross called my company, telling me I had to leave because my father was in the hospital on a ventilator, telling me he was about to pass away. I was granted 2 weeks emergency leave and flew home. Seeing my dad like that was horrible. I prayed to God please save my father and put me through hell..
In 2 weeks time, my father was off the ventilator and able to walk me to the elevator when I had to return to Texas.
When I returned to Texas, I had to switch companies to resume my course on schedule. Now that was a nightmare. I didn't know anybody. I was so uncomfortable, it was a lot rougher than my other company. I Had a lot of different obstacles to get through. At the end, it was rewarding because I knew my father recovered from his illness and I was able to complete my 91B course.

Response by Sgt Eury Fernandez made Mar 3 at 2022 2:38 PM

2022-03-03T14:38:20-05:00

Marine E-3 - just the fact that you are getting ready to make the transition from jr enlisted to NCO, the bond of your jr peers, the knowledge gained, and hard work.

Response by SFC Robert Gonzalez made Mar 3 at 2022 2:55 PM

2022-03-03T14:55:23-05:00

US Army Sergeant (E-5) was the most challenging because it was the rank where I learned the most as a leader, greater responsibilities, looking after my troops. The fundamentals that were needed to grow in subsequent senior ranks.

Response by LtCol Bradford Martin made Mar 3 at 2022 2:57 PM

2022-03-03T14:57:54-05:00

Captain/03 was the most important rank for me. My level of responsibility went up dramatically as did expectations for my performance.

Response by Cpl John Kelsey made Mar 3 at 2022 4:33 PM

2022-03-03T16:33:41-05:00

I'd say Corporal definitely! From one day hanging out as buddy's to doing your new job responsibilities that they don't have.
Making them understand not to challenge your authority instead respect it and everything will be fine!

Response by SP6 Ricky Cortez made Mar 3 at 2022 6:01 PM

2022-03-03T18:01:17-05:00

SSG/E6 you can in charge of many things for example platoon SGT section SGT and many more

Response by SGM Mary Ann Lewellyn made Mar 3 at 2022 7:32 PM

2022-03-03T19:32:15-05:00

1SG, Supreme Headquarters, Allied Powers Europe (SHAPE), U.S. Army Element, Mons, Belgium.

Response by CW4 Donald Bricker made Mar 3 at 2022 7:37 PM

2022-03-03T19:37:05-05:00

The promotion I received from E-5 to WO-1. In March of 1983 I was assigned to Ft. Rucker Alabama to attend the U.S. Army rotary wing flight school. It was a course that lasted for the next 10 months, all the while I was a WOC, Warrant Officer Candidate. It was almost like being in a prison from which I even tried to resign from and was counseled not to. I graduated from the course in Feb. of 84, was promoted to WO-1 one day with the awarding of my basic Army flight Wings the following day. I know, it’s just my opinion, but it doesn’t get much more challenging or rewarding than that. And a month after my graduation from Flight School I married the most beautiful young lady born who lived in Michigan while I got trained to fly Huey’s in Southern Alabama. I retired with the rank of CW-4 with the Army’s Pilot’s Master Wings, and for all the heavy lifting at the beginning, deployment’s and additional training it was one of the greatest career’s a person could have. Most of my flight hours were logged in Huey’s with the rest of them logged in Blackhawks. The Army kept gassing em up so I was more than happy to burn it up. But while being retired I miss driving those great birds, I miss the Soldiers I served with even more. I had a great career serving with the greatest soldiers to have ever worn our Nations uniform. It can’t get any better than that.

Response by SGT James Smith made Mar 3 at 2022 8:05 PM

2022-03-03T20:05:06-05:00

SGT E-5

Response by SSG Brian Kerr made Mar 3 at 2022 8:24 PM

2022-03-03T20:24:01-05:00

Definitely Obtaining SSG. :-))

Response by SPC Carlton Phelps made Mar 3 at 2022 8:36 PM

2022-03-03T20:36:24-05:00

For me it was private. I was a mess all through basic training. I thought if I didn't make private the Army was going to kill me out. That would have been very bad for my family. They were all pro-military, or career soldiers.

Response by AN Ron Wright made Mar 3 at 2022 9:23 PM

2022-03-03T21:23:01-05:00

e4 first to the crow newly to the fleet

Response by SGT Linsey Anderson made Mar 3 at 2022 9:29 PM

2022-03-03T21:29:02-05:00

I was in the Army and I think Private E-1/E-2 was the most challenging because I was new to the military and treated like crap. I was straight out of training and felt like I earned a little respect and felt proud. When I reported to my 1st duty station I realized really fast, I was nobody, and I really didn’t know my job at all. Not only that, in training females were treated pretty equal. RUDE AWAKENING! I was a mechanic and the only female in my motor pool. I was treated as such. Even my squad leader would act like it wasn’t even standing in front of him. It was horrible! I learned quickly the advantages to being a private. I was tasked for all the missions, special tasks, and special detail assignments. (I was deployed 2 weeks after I unprocessed at my duty station.) I ended up getting several awards and certificates for all the special task which helped later on in my career.

Response by LT Roger Rice made Mar 3 at 2022 10:40 PM

2022-03-03T22:40:00-05:00

Lt. R. Rice, USN
I graduated from law school in May '68 during the Viet Nam War and joined the Navy. The recruiter gave me a test to join the JAG Corps, but it was extremely hard and I failed it. I then went to boot camp as an E-1 and thereafter became a clerk/typist at Great Lakes NTC as an E-2 making $97.00 per month. All my friends were E-2s and E-3s, but the officers were kind to me also in view of my 20 years of formal education. Then one day as I was filing pages into the BuPers Manual regarding test for the various Navy corps, I realized that the recruiter gave me the test for the Engineering Corps instead of the JAG Corps. I immediately took the JAG Corps test, easily passed it and was promoted to Lt. Thereafter, as a Lt. I was more than respectful of E-2s and E-3s as I had walked in their shoes.

Response by SGM Bill Pickett made Mar 3 at 2022 10:48 PM

2022-03-03T22:48:44-05:00

First Sergesnt

Response by PO2 Joan MacNeill made Mar 4 at 2022 7:10 AM

2022-03-04T07:10:29-05:00

I would pick E5, Second Class Electrician's Mate. It coincided roughly with a new assignment, to a surface ship, an APA. I was immediately appointed lead of our electrical gang. Although we were busy, it was not oppressive. The work was well-defined, the gang was experienced, the job almost ran itself. But for easy-going me, it was still a challenge. Later, a new, higher rated member got the job. But he was a flake, and I still ended up with the responsibility. There were perks, however: no mandatory watches ( I took some to ease the burden on other members of my duty section), probably more respect than I deserved, and thankfully, I was in a perfect rank niche. E6s had to stand quarterdeck watches, had their own mess, which meant I would have been in the company of some obnoxious characters, and did not have the continuing opportunities for professional development that we workers had. When I passed the E6 exam, it was a bit of a relief to learn that I had to extend a month to get the rate. I declined, for good reasons, and all was well. Later, back on a boat (Yippee!), 2nd class was also a decent rate to have. But in the long run, the answer is really: civilian.

Response by PO2 Joan MacNeill made Mar 4 at 2022 7:24 AM

2022-03-04T07:24:37-05:00

I pick E5, Second Class Electrician's Mate. It coincided roughly with a new assignment, to a surface ship, an APA. I was immediately appointed lead of our electrical gang. Although we were busy, it was not oppressive. The Division Officer was outstanding, work was well-defined, the gang was experienced, the job almost ran itself. But for easy-going me, it was still a challenge. Some interesting challenges were more contact with the Os, dealing with leaders of other divisions, and with civilians. Later, a new, higher rated member got the job. But he was a flake, and I still ended up with the responsibility. There were perks, however: no mandatory watches (I took some to ease the burden on other members of my duty section), probably more respect than I deserved, and thankfully, I was in a perfect rank niche. E6s had to stand quarterdeck watches, had their own mess, which meant I would have been a runt in the company of some obnoxious characters, and not have the continuing challenges for professional development that we workers had. I really loved doing the electrical work. When I passed the E6 exam, it was a bit of a relief to learn that I had to extend a month to get the rate. I declined, for good reasons, and all was well. Later, back on a boat (Yippee!), 2nd class was also a decent rate to have. But in the long run, the answer is really: civilian.

Response by Cpl Frank Birkemeier made Mar 4 at 2022 7:41 AM

2022-03-04T07:41:29-05:00

Corporal. Becoming a young leader of the same friends you were led with is confusing at first, but over time teaches you more responsibility and accountability.

Response by CPO Joeseph Gieser made Mar 4 at 2022 9:23 AM

2022-03-04T09:23:02-05:00

Being an Chief in the Navy. Not an E7 but a CHIEF! By far the most rewarding because everyone up and down the chain of command looks to you for answers. Obviously challenging but wow was it fun and rewarding!!!

Response by SSgt Heather Allen made Mar 4 at 2022 9:40 AM

2022-03-04T09:40:43-05:00

Staff Sergeant/E-5 was my most challenging and rewarding. Challenging because many factors went into earning the rank vs just time in service. Rewarding because I was able to lead and teach newer airmen along the way.

Response by SFC Kenneth Schob made Mar 4 at 2022 10:59 AM

2022-03-04T10:59:56-05:00

SFC E-7. At that rank I performed the duties at the Battalion Operations Sergeant for two years which included training, taskings, running the SQT testing, the EIB testing (I'm an Armor SFC in an Inf Div) and ran the TOC in the field among other duties. Then I went to a line Co as a 1SG for six months until an actual 1SG came on board, then I went to PSG. After I left there I went to Recruiting as a field Recruiter for one year and a Recruiting Station Commander for three years. Then back to the main stream of the Army for three more years as PSG, then retired. Those were definitely challenging years.

Response by PO3 Greg Pollak made Mar 4 at 2022 11:31 AM

2022-03-04T11:31:57-05:00

E-4, third class petty. officer. Had to work hard, behave, and do all of my work with the best of my ability.

Response by SGT Mari Smith made Mar 4 at 2022 1:36 PM

2022-03-04T13:36:27-05:00

When I made Sergeant my life completely changed, all of a sudden i was responsible for others others that matter, human life!

Response by Sgt Steve D'Orta made Mar 4 at 2022 5:01 PM

2022-03-04T17:01:52-05:00

corporal E4 was indeed the hardest because the huge change to become a better example and the big increase in responsibility. This was the first time I had people that I was responsible for. Also, the need to reprimand and ensure all our orders and directions were followed. As a Marine corporal you become an NCO which is the lowest level of the command chain, and we all know that Sh-- rolls downhill.

Response by SPC Russell Mathews made Mar 4 at 2022 5:07 PM

2022-03-04T17:07:40-05:00

SP4 US ARMY

Response by Sgt Wai Kuen Leung made Mar 4 at 2022 6:24 PM

2022-03-04T18:24:24-05:00

I was told, you act to be the next rank above. With that said I think sgt is the most challenging and rewarding. you have a team of Marines to be responsible for and you can make recommendation to higher which influence more then lower ranking Marines

Response by 1SG Earl Higginbotham made Mar 5 at 2022 12:38 PM

2022-03-05T12:38:57-05:00

The most amazing challenging rank was first sergeant. It is the responsibility to take care of the troops and at the same time punish them for misbehavior, such as article 15. On the other side there is the helping of soldiers and/or their dependents. I remember helping a family of five get food stamps and better usage a good thing and then on the other hand had to put soldier out of the service because of use of drugs, a bad thing knowing he had four dependents.

Response by SSG Jack Dingus made Mar 6 at 2022 3:13 PM

2022-03-06T15:13:26-05:00

E-5 was the most testing and rewarding

Response by CW3 Regina Spaeth made Mar 6 at 2022 7:40 PM

2022-03-06T19:40:30-05:00

Warrant Officer

Response by CW3 Jim Mannion Jr. made Mar 6 at 2022 8:14 PM

2022-03-06T20:14:20-05:00

Warrent Officer. Learning to be invisible was difficult

Response by SFC Kyle Kosmicki made Mar 7 at 2022 12:50 AM

2022-03-07T00:50:36-05:00

For myself it was E6. I was promoted prior to an overseas deployment, which was challenging enough, coupled with the politics of the mission. Made it that much more rewarding getting back stateside.

Response by Sgt Christian Mendieta made Mar 7 at 2022 11:29 PM

2022-03-07T23:29:47-05:00

Sergeant, as you are in charge of the right amount of servicemembers to feel overwhelmed but when it is working you feel very motivated and empowered.

Response by 1SG Mitchell Smith made Mar 8 at 2022 1:16 PM

2022-03-08T13:16:36-05:00

SFC, I pinned in 7 years and right after pinning off to battle we go as a 'TRUCKMASTER' always first in to every site setup - railhead, sea, aircraft, personnel accountability, manifest ....you name it.

I was glued to the CO. Nothing happened unless I knew about it. In a Transportation company the TRUCKMASTER is considered a Second or maybe the First Sergeant. Ask those who understand. When pushing missions, I made the call on who, what, when where, any why. I have soldier's that's still serving - CSM's now and my Commander is Full Bull retiring soon. Yes, Combat SFC without a doubt.

Response by SPC David S. made Mar 8 at 2022 2:04 PM

2022-03-08T14:04:21-05:00

I would say E1 as this is the first rank that requires a commitment to defend the US from enemies both foreign and domestic. You go from being a civilian to being a professional soldier real quick. Right out of high school to kicking in doors in some foreign country liberating the oppressed quite a responsibility for someone at 17.

Response by SFC Richard Saunders made Mar 8 at 2022 8:45 PM

2022-03-08T20:45:14-05:00

For me it was being on the E-7 promotion list with a sequence number 13 . It took two years to get promoted.

Response by 1st Lt Padre Dave Poedel made Mar 8 at 2022 8:55 PM

2022-03-08T20:55:23-05:00

1LT, because at heart I was still a Paramedic, and my spirit was that of a Pastor, but my job was to be XO of a Reserve Contingency Hospital in the AFRES.

Response by SN William Culotta made Mar 9 at 2022 6:40 AM

2022-03-09T06:40:43-05:00

Actually, staying an PNSN was, after passing all tests for E4-6 because I did not want to stay in the service. I joined the Navy Reserves to avoid going to Vietnam. Pure and simple I was against the Vietnam War and actively protested against it. I always supported our troops but felt the War was a mistake by America for many reasons. To answer the actual question, I was a bit immature and didn't want to be of value and just wanted to serve and leave. But I was assigned to MCB -71 and had to go to Vietnam anyway!!! HA, do not stand next to me in a thunderstorm! I do hope I did not offend anyone, my feelings still remain bitter about that immoral war. In this particular war and a couple others, I quote my favorite Fold Song writer, Phil Ochs, "It is always the old to send us to war and always the young to fall! At 77 I am not happy to have lost 55- 60 thousand of our fellow Americans.

There again, I do hope I did not mean to offend anyone and do respect your service! I will accept any criticisms [login to see] God hates a coward, so to speak!

Be Well & Strive For Happiness
Bill Culotta

Response by Capt LLoyd Spanberger made Mar 9 at 2022 6:18 PM

2022-03-09T18:18:46-05:00

Lieutenant. Little was expected, which allowed me to accomplish a lot with little oversite.

Response by SP5 Tracy Watson made Mar 9 at 2022 7:03 PM

2022-03-09T19:03:22-05:00

E 5

Response by Sgt Ted Kachlic made Mar 9 at 2022 7:28 PM

2022-03-09T19:28:36-05:00

Sgt. E-5, I was responsible for my squad and had enough authority to stick by them. I was raised to take care of one another;I fitted right in. Was very proud to be a Marine and make rank in 2 1/2 years. Semper Fi!

Response by TSgt Barry Nix made Mar 9 at 2022 7:40 PM

2022-03-09T19:40:52-05:00

E-6

Response by SFC Cory Smith made Mar 9 at 2022 7:57 PM

2022-03-09T19:57:20-05:00

Rear-detachment 1SG

Response by MGySgt Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 9 at 2022 8:40 PM

2022-03-09T20:40:20-05:00

Being a Gunnery Sergeant. From the moment I pinned on I was treated differently and with a higher standard. This put a lot of pressure on me but it made me want to do better. I was able to use my rank and the authority it provided to make things better for my Marines and also for the units I was attached to. I was able to use these abilities as I progressed and it gave me a reputation for getting things done which provided me a lot more opportunities and advancement. I am still seeing great things from those days and are still happening today. It is even better when I see Marines I mentored use those skills and doing greater things.

Response by PO3 Kenny King made Mar 9 at 2022 8:45 PM

2022-03-09T20:45:39-05:00

E4 Petty Officer. Didn’t take me long to get there, but the rest of my 4 years to keep it. I lost this rank three times and got reinstated two times.

Response by CSM Elmer Feick Jr. made Mar 9 at 2022 9:10 PM

2022-03-09T21:10:15-05:00

It would have to be working as a 1SG of an Aviation Maintenance Company in the Army National Guard. This was during a time in the mid-nineties where resources were minimal and training opportunities were hard to come by. Our State operating budget for sending Soldiers to schools for MOS qualification almost took an act of Congress it seemed and harder still was OJT MOS qualifications. In light of that, the job required "outside of the box" thinking in many functional areas IE: Personnel, Equipment and Training readiness and my leadership style encouraged my Platoon Sergeants to actively develop solutions to the issues at hand. This way, everyone was part of the team and accepted responsibility and success sharing where after a year on the job, our unit received top ratings on the Commander's Report in all areas. Morale was extremely high when I left the position as a result of changing the mindset that nothing was impossible and that all ideas were welcome in building mission accomplishment and unit cohesion.

Response by Capt Heather Brown made Mar 9 at 2022 9:12 PM

2022-03-09T21:12:27-05:00

Capt. You're expected to do paperwork and sit in an office instead of actually being in ops doing the real work. Sometimes rewarding if you can make useful changes.

Response by SGT William Justice made Mar 9 at 2022 9:20 PM

2022-03-09T21:20:19-05:00

Definitely E-5 for me, once I became an NCO, I was able to watch out and lead the soldiers in my squad, getting my stripes was amazing for me.

Response by PO1 Victoria Cameron made Mar 9 at 2022 9:23 PM

2022-03-09T21:23:34-05:00

E-5 your like the middle man - babysitting those ranked below you and delegated out the you know what from E-6.

Response by SPC Javier Sabi made Mar 9 at 2022 9:25 PM

2022-03-09T21:25:44-05:00

Corporal. Piecing everything together to be a leader

Response by SPC Cecilia Wilson made Mar 9 at 2022 9:39 PM

2022-03-09T21:39:34-05:00

The most challenging but rewarding rank for me was Private, being from a small town and having a single mom that could be meaner than a rabid pitbull (LOL) and so overprotective til I felt like I was on lock down every day so, when I went into the Army I felt like she could tell what I was doing which was running everywhere and shoveling my food down my face without chewing (LOL). Challenging because It was my 1st time being away from home without my guard (good ole mom) and I was afraid, VERY AFRAID but rewarding because I got over that fear and I learned things about myself that I would've never learned had I stayed in protective custody. I learned that I could live on my on, I learned that I was responsible for every decision I made, I leaned that if something didn't go as planned, it would be ok, I also learned that I was an adult (even if mom treated like a child) I was being trained to protect my country and I never felt PROUDER .

Response by MSgt Mark Donaldson made Mar 9 at 2022 9:53 PM

2022-03-09T21:53:51-05:00

Looking back on 24 years as a active duty marine I would say going from sergeant to staff sergeant was the hardest. While a sergeant you are a leader but you can still remain friends with those below you while on base. As a staff sergeant you can’t do that anymore. Being a member of the snco rank you are now a ‘full fledged’ leader of marines and there is no “friendship” with the sgt’s and below now at work. Being a staff noncommissioned officer has a whole new set of rules to follow and execute to complete the mission. I had a lot of fine marine’s below me while I was a sergeant and considered them good friends. To have terminate that friendship while on duty as a new staff sergeant was the hardest thing for me to do.

Response by SSG James Oliver Nathan Jr made Mar 9 at 2022 10:07 PM

2022-03-09T22:07:09-05:00

SSG was the most challenging but Rewarding. And I refused to let someone take it back.

Response by PO1 Jeffery McIntosh made Mar 9 at 2022 10:29 PM

2022-03-09T22:29:04-05:00

E-5 by far, it's like being old enuff to know what your talking about but to young for anyone to listen to you. But then one day no one has the answer and you step up and shine... that feeling stays with you, you realize you can do this, your a man now and there's no turning back. Yea, E-5 thats the rank that separates the enlisted and the lifers.

Response by SPC Barbara Jones made Mar 9 at 2022 10:34 PM

2022-03-09T22:34:01-05:00

Getting my E4 was the most rewarding. It took me the longest time to achieve E4. I was full time and it was time for me to reinlist. I had an 8 month old son.i decided not to reinvest. So the didn't give me E4 even thought I had all the training. I did 2 years in the reserves and received my E4.

Response by SFC Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 9 at 2022 11:51 PM

2022-03-09T23:51:39-05:00

SFC - Tackling the position of Staff NCO was a tough transition. It was the first time that I had to deal with the politics of officers jockeying for rank.

Response by SFC Susan Powell made Mar 10 at 2022 12:05 AM

2022-03-10T00:05:49-05:00

When I was promoted to SSG the lower enlisted in my office crowded around me, congratulated me and "begged" me not to change! Change? I said, I am still the same, but with more responsibilities. The big challenge was staying the same, yet not staying the same, yet making sure all responsibilities of Soldiers and work were done with integrity. I believe lower enlisted Soldiers need to know the jobs so if you or others aren't there, they will fill the void, so there won't be any "hiccup".

Response by SSgt Gerald Borromeo made Mar 10 at 2022 1:12 AM

2022-03-10T01:12:29-05:00

The most challenging rank for me was when I was an E-3/Airman First Class. I had just got to my first duty station (McChord AFB, WA), and I had no idea what to expect from a life in aircraft maintenance. No one was really showing me around the ropes of the job, so I was pretty much just tagging along on jobs and not attempting to ask questions and learn. About a month in, one of the E-5s/Staff Sergeants returned from deployment and is placed on day shift with me. He quickly realized I didn't really know the job nor was anyone taking the time to teach me. So he pretty much made my life miserable the new few months teaching me the ins and outs of the job. He had me in the technical orders every day I worked, and I had to present the information I had learned for each day. Every time I was on shift, he didn't give me much time to relax because he forced me to learn more about our specialty on the aircraft. But thanks to him, I became very proficient at my job. We actually got stationed in Kadena at the same time and worked alongside each other. He became a great mentor and someone I could go to for advice despite what he put me through at first. It was thanks to him that I became good at my job and grew professionally.

Response by CWO2 John Shaner made Mar 10 at 2022 1:16 AM

2022-03-10T01:16:56-05:00

Both Gunnery Sergeant and Chief Warrant Officer were challenging yet rewarding because I was expected to know everything, especially as a CWO. But I have to say that Gunny was probably the best.

Response by CPL Keith Baylor made Mar 10 at 2022 3:17 AM

2022-03-10T03:17:18-05:00

PFC because you are one step up from just taking order, and one step away from being in a leadership position (CPL).

Response by SrA Angela Harrington made Mar 10 at 2022 5:22 AM

2022-03-10T05:22:53-05:00

A1c without a doubt!airmen 1 striper didn't know shit and SrA was a supervisor in between you had to learn everything fast!!

Response by PO1 Mario Suarez made Mar 10 at 2022 6:37 AM

2022-03-10T06:37:02-05:00

To me, E-5 was th emost challenging and most rewarding rank. As an E-5, you are in the middle, where you either sink or float, you go from being a follower to being a leader whpo still has to answer to those ranked above you and you are acountable and responsible for those ranked below you.

Response by MSgt Kenn Wells made Mar 10 at 2022 7:26 AM

2022-03-10T07:26:01-05:00

Master Sergeant/E7 was the hardest for me. It took longer than I expected, so I was glad when I finally made it.

Response by SMSgt Stephan Clanton made Mar 10 at 2022 8:10 AM

2022-03-10T08:10:18-05:00

The most challenging rank, was E-6. Accepting new responsibilities and expanding leadership role. It helped prepare me for senior NCO roles.

Response by SGT Kyle Bramlett made Mar 10 at 2022 8:37 AM

2022-03-10T08:37:13-05:00

Sgt was definitely most challenging. Was thrown into leadership with soldiers under me who were I'll say a little less skilled than most and didn't comprehend simple tasks. Very frustrating when I had to answer for their mishaps.

Response by Cpl Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 10 at 2022 11:06 AM

2022-03-10T11:06:15-05:00

The most challenge rank for me, was being a Corporal/E-4 in the USMC. As soon as I was promoted. I had multiple responsibilities that were handed to me, as well as other Marines to guide. Being a Corporal was making sure you were the back bone of the Marine Corps. Making sure that the ranks above you had full trust in you, as well as making sure the ranks below you had the knowledge, and skills that you obtain through your Marine Corps career. To make you mold your, troops to be better then you once they reach that rank of responsibilities. Being a Corporal was an amazing part of my life, it taught how to be a leader, and how to make sure that even if I failed. That I push forward and never look back.

Response by SGT John Foley made Mar 10 at 2022 11:10 AM

2022-03-10T11:10:11-05:00

Sgt. E-5 was the most challenging to reach but hard work paid off. The most rewarding was the E-5 because it gave me the passes ability to go off base at my leisure and no line at the mess hall.

Response by Capt Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 10 at 2022 11:16 AM

2022-03-10T11:16:03-05:00

2nd Lt. The transition from enlisted to officer was a challenging one, but my personal growth was substantial during this period as I learned how to work effectively with NCOs and Senior NCOs.

Response by Cpl Joseph Betz made Mar 10 at 2022 11:21 AM

2022-03-10T11:21:13-05:00

Lance Corporal E-3 was my most challenging and rewarding. It was challenging when I was assigned to a team of Combat Engineers attached to an infantry battalion in Viet Nam and rewarding as it was the first stairstep in leadership that gave me the confidence to eventually earn a doctorate in Ministry from Fuller Theological Seminary, building Christian leaders.

Response by COL Tom Monahan made Mar 10 at 2022 11:40 AM

2022-03-10T11:40:58-05:00

Full Bird!

Response by COL Tom Monahan made Mar 10 at 2022 11:50 AM

2022-03-10T11:50:59-05:00

Full Bird!

Response by MSgt James Flowers made Mar 10 at 2022 12:27 PM

2022-03-10T12:27:37-05:00

F-5

Response by MSgt James Flowers made Mar 10 at 2022 12:28 PM

2022-03-10T12:28:25-05:00

E-5

Response by SPC Cathy Poe made Mar 10 at 2022 12:58 PM

2022-03-10T12:58:02-05:00

For me it was E-3 coming in the military from a small town with a big personality. I had to adapt to being around so many professionals while polishing my attitude and adapting to so many changes at once. This experience has helped shaped me today and the experience was worth it.

Response by CWO4 Ray Fairman made Mar 10 at 2022 3:17 PM

2022-03-10T15:17:52-05:00

CWO3 because it was the one i went back on active duty with during DS/DS and the responsibilities I assumed wee even greater than the ones i had as a SSgt back in Nam and at a much higher level... But after realizing what was at stake for those depending on my work product. I was able to exceed the expectations of both them and my own initial reluctance to lead at a new level in such a short time and to do so back in a hostile environment.

Response by PO2 Dennis Klinger made Mar 10 at 2022 4:26 PM

2022-03-10T16:26:22-05:00

second class po (E5) the responsibility is upped but not the bennies. It's like middle management elsware.

Response by Lt Col Kathy Bush made Mar 10 at 2022 6:23 PM

2022-03-10T18:23:32-05:00

Officer Candidate School Cadet - last class of AF OCS 1963

Response by SGT Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 10 at 2022 6:36 PM

2022-03-10T18:36:06-05:00

Buck Sargent, getting all your lower enlisted friends to acknowledge that you're now an NCO, that gives orders that they all have to follow.
But they all knew, I know my shit, and that's why I got the only E-5 slot open in battalion, the EIB as a PFC helped too.
"All the way, and then some"

Response by CPT Josh Ewing made Mar 10 at 2022 8:48 PM

2022-03-10T20:48:26-05:00

2LT, A Butter Bar is supposed to lead men, but in reality, they need to listen to their NCOs that know better. They need to learn to lead by listening! It is sometimes very difficult because you are told you must lead, but you don't even know what that means.

Response by Maj Malcolm Miller made Mar 11 at 2022 12:49 PM

2022-03-11T12:49:19-05:00

Buck sgt when I was in the Army.

Response by CPT Julius Luck made Mar 12 at 2022 12:16 AM

2022-03-12T00:16:31-05:00

2 LT was the most challenging and rewarding for me. I got my SSG "rocker" while I was in OCS, and thought about quitting. I stuck with it, though. When I got commissioned, however, I had a hard time getting my head around it. It was not what I'd expected. Especially the response from other NCOs. I eventually managed to handle it.

Response by SSG Brian Carpeneter made Mar 12 at 2022 12:48 AM

2022-03-12T00:48:30-05:00

Corporal. I was a Cpl for 6 years and never had it removed when changing units. 5 was just hard to make in MOS 52D Power Generation Equipment Repair I had 794 out of 798 when I finally got picked up. But as a Cpl I held slots from SGT to SFC. The day I made my buck was a big relief but I still found being anything from a squad leader to a Motor Sergeant as an E-4 was a big part of why I was made a PSG as a SSG over several SFC and not only succeeded at it but excelled at it. Anyone who whines about but what about the pay just doesn't get what being a Non-Commissioned Officer and leadership are about. I had several friends who just didn't get it but they knew that even though it didn't fit them I wore it like a glove. So from a Motor Sergeant for THE MASH unit 43rd SH(MA) to Assistant Motor Sgt of the 1/4 Avn Bn Apache Bn or Squad leader of a Ground Support Team at 183rd Main Bn Cpl was the most challenging and fulfilling rank I held

Response by CDR Steven Thomas made Mar 12 at 2022 1:06 PM

2022-03-12T13:06:25-05:00

I found that the rank of Major was the most rewarding and did not serve enough time in grade. I had been rifted out as senior 03 in the promotion zone right before met and ended up with a "Passed Over" instead of not eligible. This happened four more times prior to selection and date of rank. I was recalled for active duty for desert storm and then deep selected for 05. I was cheated of the most wonderful rank. The Marines consider a major as a senior officer and treated me as such. I would go out on sortie and get immediate response from other units as driving with 9th Motor Transport. Everyone wanted me to go on the sortie run either as Road Master or just an assistant driver. Yes we were that short, but earned the respect of all the marines in the battalion and did not go unnoticed by the skipper, who commented that Majors still needed to be out with the troops.

Response by Lt Col John (Jack) Christensen made Mar 12 at 2022 5:44 PM

2022-03-12T17:44:28-05:00

Probably Captain for me. Up until then I was either in training or just expected to do my job as an aircraft crewmember. Once I became a Captain it was pretty much expected that you would take on additional duties that may or may not have anything to do with being a flier.

Response by CPO Barbara Pixton made Mar 13 at 2022 12:32 PM

2022-03-13T12:32:39-04:00

Becoming a black, female Chief Petty Officer in the Navy was the most challenging but definitely the most rewarding. People said I couldn't do it. Many didn't believe it when I became a CPO. Gate guards would look at my ID to enter a base and ask, "Is this really you?" Begin a CPO is a big deal but being a female CPO is even bigger. Then add my black face to the anchor and 23 years of beautiful gold on my uniform and and I turned heads. When people tell me I can't do something - it makes me more determined!

Response by CPO Ralph Nicolay made Mar 13 at 2022 2:06 PM

2022-03-13T14:06:37-04:00

Making E7 Chief Petty Officer in the USN. It changed the way I looked at personnel and training for the better. Training was the best part of this change in leadership.

Response by SFC Donald York made Mar 13 at 2022 6:12 PM

2022-03-13T18:12:18-04:00

I'd say Private.

Response by TSgt Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 14 at 2022 2:01 AM

2022-03-14T02:01:35-04:00

Straight leg, not tabbed Buck Sgt at the age of 20 in a 75th Inf Reg LRRP company. I proved myself but never was really accepted.

Response by PO2 Glen Kelly made Mar 14 at 2022 9:27 PM

2022-03-14T21:27:21-04:00

I didn't find any rank particularly challenging--or rewarding. I coasted through the years of enlistment, reaching E2 out of boot camp, E3 out of RM-A school, E4 upon transfer from 11th ND HQ to Midway Is., and then E5 in a tad over 2 years total. I was disappointed to find the discipline, and adherence to skill training to be as lax as it was. As example; even though an E5 was required to be proficient receiving and sending radio telegraph code, logging messages, etc., I was not proficient at all. The test I was administered consisted of being asked if "I knew the code." I answered honestly that I did know the code. Not at the level of proficiency required, but I did 'know' it. As a kiddie-cruiser, I returned to the mainland, joined up with my E2 spouse, and have enjoyed 61 years of wedded bliss (if you ask her (^;). I had planned to catch up with my skill set but I only had one day of USNR-R drill and that was at Andrews AFBl. The Navy didn't keep track of me in between separation and discharge (I worked in DCA AUTODIN as a site supervisor). I had planned to go for a full tour but getting married early on put a stop to that plan. Oh well; turned out I was a natural at designing and programming computers to i was too early to become an IT.

Response by PO3 Jessica Desamito made Mar 15 at 2022 9:25 AM

2022-03-15T09:25:17-04:00

For myself I feel that being an E3, and finally getting myself adjusted and then having to start studying and testing for my NCO to make E4 was a trial. Not only was I studying for my test to rank up but I was also studying for other NEC advancements in my rating. And going to college as well. All of that studying was very difficult, while working hard 12 to 24-hour shifts somedays. But also the most rewarding because after all that studying and PFT training I finally made E4.

Response by MSgt Kay A made Mar 15 at 2022 4:09 PM

2022-03-15T16:09:46-04:00

SSgt/E-5 (during sequestration & furloughs) was the most challenging and rewarding. With positions being lost, the work was not scaled back, but placed on the employees left in the unit. Therefore, personnel were pushed to their limit. I served in 3 positions and assisted others in finding answers to issues along with providing pointers on newly assigned duties. I learned I had to choose my battles all while standing up for my people (since the person that would normally do it had not arrived yet —5 month delay). We all learned together and daily PT was mandatory for my flight to keep those stress levels down!

Response by SGT Patrick McCauley made Mar 15 at 2022 5:04 PM

2022-03-15T17:04:31-04:00

PVT. I was the youngest marine on the base. And lowest rank by 3 ranks. I did everything. Everything crappy that is.

Response by MSG James Reynolds made Mar 16 at 2022 8:11 PM

2022-03-16T20:11:22-04:00

Top, Army UAMTF. 2020. We had more issues in a national geographic but none of us got covid but we saw death before us every day.

Response by Cpl Jack Dwenger made Mar 22 at 2022 5:10 PM

2022-03-22T17:10:56-04:00

E-4 USMC to civilian 1974. Ostracized by most, ignored by the rest. Semper Fi DEVIL DOGS.

Response by MSgt George Stengel made Mar 23 at 2022 6:10 PM

2022-03-23T18:10:03-04:00

I would say when I made MSgt. In the Air Force I also acted as a First Sgt. Balancing the needs of the enlisted Corp and the commander's wishes can be a fine line.

Response by 1SG Sparky Sparky made Mar 23 at 2022 6:11 PM

2022-03-23T18:11:08-04:00

To me being a first sergeant what's the most challenging and rewarding rank that I ever held because I was a lot of times I was younger than a lot of my soldiers and I learned a lot from them

Response by MSgt Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 23 at 2022 6:12 PM

2022-03-23T18:12:47-04:00

E6 Tsgt was pretty challenging, as a TSgt you are the bridge between the lower enlisted and the SNCO corps. Not only do you need to lead by example but you also have to set the standards tasked to you by the ranks above. You also have to find that balance of being a good leader while gaining the respect of your subordinates which can be a challenge on its own, troops may not like you or your leadership style but if they respect you they will move mountains with you.

Response by Cpl Jerry Clements made Mar 23 at 2022 6:58 PM

2022-03-23T18:58:32-04:00

E-4 mos was locked lateral move to 1341

Response by PO2 Kenneth Barker made Mar 23 at 2022 8:24 PM

2022-03-23T20:24:38-04:00

I made E-5 in 3.5 years, which is unusual. As leader of two-man sound-powered phone shop aboard USS Constellation (CVA 64), as a "plankowner", I found this quite challenging; to keep 3 guys busy and happy performing our duties. 'Twas a rewarding experience.

Response by SGT Christopher Dupont made Mar 23 at 2022 8:31 PM

2022-03-23T20:31:24-04:00

SGT E-5 or CPL E-4 both required directly supervising soldiers, common NCO duties, counseling, and leadership roles without the recognition that most senior NCO's received. I believe E-5/E-6's are the backbone of the Army. As a CPL you're treated like an NCO when it's convenient then a junior enlisted when that's convenient.

Response by CPL Kory HInes made Mar 23 at 2022 8:40 PM

2022-03-23T20:40:40-04:00

Specialist because it's no secret that we were the backbone of the army. Not wet behind the ears anymore and as knowledgeable as our squad leaders twice as dedicated as our Platoon Sergeants. It was definitely a rank that I was proud I held. When I announced my rank to civilians for some reason they wanted to know more about my specific job. I strutted my stuff into the CSM board. Hooah!!!!!!

Response by SSgt Herbert Townsend made Mar 23 at 2022 8:51 PM

2022-03-23T20:51:06-04:00

Sergeant (E5)I learned a lot, some of the best times served, also a couple of rough assignments.

Response by Cpl Jack Dwenger made Mar 23 at 2022 9:16 PM

2022-03-23T21:16:02-04:00

shit sandwich

Response by CPL Russell Bowie made Mar 23 at 2022 10:29 PM

2022-03-23T22:29:43-04:00

e 1 was the beginning of my military experience and the most difficult because i met people from around the country and i didn t understand the different cultures from the east coast and west coast and especially the mid west. i was from the deep south and undereducated and under informed. i didn t even know who malcolm x was or the black panthers. so i felt like an out sider and was willing to do anything to make an impression and be accepted. one day some fast talking new yorker approached me and convinced me to buy some sleeping pills or red devils as they were called. the next day i was taken from the training field and brought to my locker were the mp found the two pills and put me in jail. i got an article 15 and was recycled. they would not dare send me home and lose a soldier on his way to vietnam. it was very rewarding because it prepared me for what was to come in vietnam. the isolation and wanting to fit in was magnfied in the jungle but i was better prepared to stand on my own two feet and avoided getting involved with some shady characters.

Response by GySgt Glen Silva made Mar 23 at 2022 11:03 PM

2022-03-23T23:03:24-04:00

I would have to say the rank of Sergeant was the most challenging and rewarding. This was the rank you are looked upon with unlimited potential at all times. You are expected to be a master in your MOS and to also continue to be a sponge so that your superiors can continue to sharpen that sword. It’s was tough because you are dangerous now, due to being a very well educated service member, not only of your MOS, but of the bigger picture. In my case I was a Company GySgt(E7 and a Company First Sergeant/E8 all while being a Sergeant. Yes there were Staff Sergeants and a GySgt in the Company but I was either senior to them in service and they looked up to me or they were getting out and didn’t care. I held formations and gave guidance to the Company Commander on a regular basis. The Battalion First Sergeants were not happy but once they understood helped me a great deal I’m getting the 1st Sgt job done to make sure the SgtMaj was out of our hair. Once the restructuring got finished and almost 5 months had passed, it finally got back to normal, but then nobody knew what to do with me because I had done everything at that point. I was kept on to give guidance to the new Company GySgt and was put into H&S Plt in order to make sure the GySgt learned how to do his job. Eventually one of the newer SSgt failed to meet standards in one of the Platoon Sgt roles, I was put into that position and he was put into the H&S platoon as the Company GySgts plt that did all the bit** work. I struggled because after being held at such high positions and learning as much as I did, it was hard for me to slow down and not feel like I was being punished and not promoted. In the end I understood the “why” and was forever grateful for the situations that fell into my lap. It was rewarding in knowing that I could step into those roles and figure them out and perform them well enough to not raise alarm and be able to see the bigger picture. It definitely helped me in the long run of my career. I was combat meritoriously promoted to Staff Sergeant and then combat meritoriously promoted to GySgt. I feel strongly that in doing the positions I rose to and excelling at them demonstrated to not only my peers but my superiors the abilities I possessed were greater than the rank I held. Again this was my point of view of it all. It kept me humble with my peers and younger and it kept me hungry with all of my superiors. It just put me in the best position possible where I had the ear of both up and down the chain of command.
Writing this was hard because I feel the two best ranks for an infantry Marine are Sergeant and Gunnery Sergeant/ E-5 and E-7

Response by CW4 Bob Monroe made Mar 24 at 2022 12:24 AM

2022-03-24T00:24:31-04:00

Let's start with a little background; the US Army 3 Ranger Battalions are run by NCOs. They are NCO driven organizations and you stand a parade rest when speaking to someone who is higher in rank than yourself. You address them by their rank (specialist, SGT, SSG, SFC, 1SG, CSM).

After basic training and AIT, after airborne school and the Ranger indoctrination Program (RIP) I was sent to 1-75th Ranger Battalion. During one of my first few days in the bat, I was coming down the barracks stairs for morning formation. A hardcore voice from behind me asked me why I wasn't wearing any rank on my collar (jungle fatigues). I turned around and addressed the meanest looking SSG I had ever met and he was looking for an excuse to drop a new Ranger for pushups. This SSG was wearing Halo, jumpmaster, combat patch, Ranger tab, EIB, all the markings of one tough SOB. I swallowed hard and responded that I was wearing the rank I was currently at; E-1 (no rank to wear).

The SSG pulled close to me and punched me in the arm saying, "it's about damn time we see someone coming up through the ranks like I did, with nothing. I came in as an E-1 and I keep seeing these new kids wearing all kinds of rank right out of RIP." He smiled at me fully knowing I was crapping my pants expecting something entirely different from this bad ass.

When I pinned on E-2 a few months later, he was one of the first people to congratulate me.

CW4 Bob Monroe (retired)

Response by SFC Eugene Bruce made Mar 24 at 2022 7:17 AM

2022-03-24T07:17:19-04:00

My final rank of SFC in the Army, leader of my squad and entrusted with multiple responsibilities by my platoon leader. Brought out the best in me and the respect of my fellow soldiers. Truly rewarding and I would do it all over again!

Response by COL Bill Gibson made Mar 24 at 2022 9:17 AM

2022-03-24T09:17:11-04:00

Colonel was the most challenging and rewarding rank in my almost 37 years of Army active duty service. Rewarding in the sense that I had the privilege to lead a team of over 1,200 talented Soldiers and Civilians as their Brigade Commander in Korea. Challenging because it was my responsibility to ensure the readiness of a heavy brigade combat set (APS-4) that accounted for half of the Army’s ground combat power on the Korean peninsula. When I first assumed command, that prepositioned set was in a poor state of readiness. I was faced with a mandate from Congress to raise it to 100% operational readiness in 8 months. Needless to say, I had regular visits from GAO and Congressional delegations to monitor our progress while evaluating all the Lean and Six Sigma projects and reorganization that my battalion commander and his team were implementing to get us to that milestone. We beat the deadline by a week. GAO did not know at first how to write a positive report on my teams’s remarkable achievement in such a short period of time working around the clock for 8 months (most GAO reports are ugly and highly critical). So much so that it took the Secretary of the Army to pay us a visit and see for himself what GAO had just reported. The Secretary called our efforts the Army model for Business Transformation. Now the challenge was to sustain that readiness on a consistent basis if ever needed to fight tonight and win. Definitely the most challenging assignment of my career, and the most rewarding. One Team!

Response by 1SG Carrie Rossow made Mar 24 at 2022 10:50 AM

2022-03-24T10:50:54-04:00

By far the most challenging but rewarding rank was SSG. You have to bridge the gap between the junior enlisted who are varying levels of motivation and the senior enlisted who are very task orientated. The job to staying connected with mentoring those below you, as well as your duties to get the job done and done right can sometimes be conflicting, and if we are to be honest, was mentally exhausting at the end of some days. But the reward comes in when your squad or platoon completes a mission, soldiers step up to levels you envisioned they could and sometimes beyond, and the company as a whole succeeds with not only completing the overall mission or readiness, but building a congruent group that LOVES what they do.

Response by CMSgt Elbert E. Clayton made Mar 24 at 2022 11:17 AM

2022-03-24T11:17:05-04:00

The most challenging rank I held was also the longest time period rank held. That was Airman Second Class (A2C), Enlisted rank (E-3). I dropped out of the eleventh grade in October 1955. I took an enlistment physical, along with four buddies on October 23, 1955 (my birthday) and enlisted five days later in the United States Air Force (USAF) on October 28, 1955. That same day we departed St. Lousi, Missouri on the "Texas Eagle" train for San Antonio, Texas with First Class Accommodations. When we arrived that same evening and were bussed to Lackland AFB pure hell began for our Basic Flight Training. Out of the next three weeks our flight was given 18 days of Kitchen Police (KP) duties. At the start of the Third Week, our Technical Instructors (TIs) were both arrested, confined and courts-martialed for selling our Flight multiple times for KP in exchange for favors or cash with other units. What can I say, we were mostly young, school dropouts, and some juvenile offenders given a second chance by lenient Juvenile Court Judges? We had thought what we were doing was normal. Our new Technical Instructor was all "Right Stuff" and taught us in two weeks all we should have learned in the first five total weeks. We did not win Fifth Week Drill Competition, but we came really close. After boot camp, and Base Operations School Training at Keesler AFB, Mississippi (another story for another time) I was selected for assignment to Haneda AB, Japan. I arrived about May 1956, enjoyed Japan for two years, attained the rank of A2C and departed about May 1958 for McGuire AFB, New Jersey. This is where I was challenged the most and longest in this rank. In the two years I was assigned as Permanent Party at McGuire AFB, I was sent Temporary Duty (TDY) to Thule AB. Greenland for three months, and Altus AFB, Oklahoma for 6 weeks Advanced Technical School Training (After which I got married on a seven day leave July 31, 1959). As an A2C, with more than 2 years' experience, I was assigned "Dispatcher" duties in Fleet Service (The dirtiest job in the military). Fleet Service has the overall duty of cleaning aircraft, including the Latrines. As a dispatcher I had all ranks assigned under me up to Staff Sergeants (E-5s). I enjoyed the authority given and probably exploited it. But it kept me off the dirty job and mostly clean. During this time some circumstances arose (another story for another time) that necessitated I take a "Short" discharge and I reenlisted for Six (6) years and a $750.00 reenlistment bonus. At the end of two years, I was officially transferred Permanent Change of Station (PCS) to Goose Bay AB, Greenland. I served there from late in 1959 to January 1960. My new wife had developed Tuberculosis and had a Lung removed. I was sent home on a Humanitarian Reassignment to Scott AFB, Illinois. Shortly after I reported for duty, my new Squadron Commander asked why I had been an A2C for nearly four years. I didn't know myself and was really dumb in the ways of the world then. He researched my records and discovered I had not had an Airman's Performance Report (APR) since early 1956, nearly four years, due to multiple PCS and TDY back-to-back assignments which allowed the Supervisors over me to escape the 90-day rule and not have to write an Airman's Performance Report (APR). This Commander, a Major, directed my supervisor to write me an immediate APR, and every 90 days reassign me to a new position and title and write another APR. After six months I had 3 new APRs and a promotion to Airman First Class (E-4). I took advantage of this challenging time and progressed in a timely fashion from that time forward to Chief Master Sergeant (CMSgt, E-9). I also returned the Commander's favor and made sure I always wrote timely APRs for persons assigned under my supervision.

Response by 1SG Paul McInnish made Mar 24 at 2022 11:47 PM

2022-03-24T23:47:52-04:00

When I was moved into the #1 EM slot (!SG - First Sergeant, E-8) & my lovely sweet wife took ALL my uniforms to Alterations (with a copy of my orders being promoted to 'TOP'). I had my first formation the next day/morning (257 soldiers in our unit) and I had a knot in my 'gut' as big as a basketball! BUT, it went well as my experience as a DI, Field 1SG (E-7), paid off! My new company commander wanted me to stop by his office and when I walked in, he laughed so hard he almost cried... I asked: "sir, what the hell is so funny... watching me sweat in front of ALL our soldiers..." he said, "Paul, I bet we could ring out 10 to 15 gallons of sweat in your BDU's! So that evening, he and his wife took me and my wife out for a really decent dinner! Of course, he HAD to tell the story to his wife and my wife! He finally admitted that the same thing happened to him when he got promoted to Captain & the 3 star in the parade field bleachers was watching him sweat.

Response by SGT Robert Whirles made Mar 25 at 2022 10:42 AM

2022-03-25T10:42:04-04:00

Sgt E5 was my most difficult rank but at the same time it was the most rewarding for me. As an E5 in the maintenance field i had to teach soldiers of all ranks and MOS the proper way to help maintain their vehicles. It did not matter what rank they were, Private to Major.

Response by LT Private RallyPoint Member made Mar 25 at 2022 5:32 PM

2022-03-25T17:32:54-04:00

Being an E6 was the most challenging and rewarding. Everyone junior and senior is expecting you to be a technical/tactical expert as well as being an experienced leader. Trial by fire!

Response by SFC Terry Bockes made Mar 26 at 2022 5:27 PM

2022-03-26T17:27:22-04:00

SPC4 you were close to E5 but still had responsibilities to lead those below you. Plus I called it Command SP4, because of the eagle in the middle of the rank.

Response by Col Robert Lucania made Mar 27 at 2022 11:01 AM

2022-03-27T11:01:31-04:00

Colonel, was able to influence more high level positive organizational change.

Response by PO3 John Wright made Mar 27 at 2022 2:53 PM

2022-03-27T14:53:05-04:00

Day two of Navy boot camp. Was given the title (RLPO) Recruit Leading Petty Officer. We had 80 recruits and was incharge of 70. Sent to marching party because of recruits fouling up under my leadership. The next four hours changed my position as a leader from that day forward. The reward was my company becoming one of the best to graduate in June 1991 in San Diego, CA. Anyone who knows what marching party consists of would understand, if you ever needed get right in your life, Naval boot camp marching party will do the job. Hahahahaha Hahahahaha

Response by LT T.R. Reid made Mar 29 at 2022 4:18 PM

2022-03-29T16:18:10-04:00

I was an ensign --lowest of the low among Navy officers--and assigned to Naval Reactors, the offices of VAdm. Hyman Rickover, commander of the Navy's nuclear fleet. Rickover was a notoriously tough boss; among much else, he believed that merit was more important that rank. So he never used titles; whether you were a Seaman Deuce or an Admiral, Rickover called you by your last name. And he treated all ranks the same.
One day Rickover called me into his office, in his characteristic fashion--"Doggone it, Reid, get your ass in here!" Standing in front of his desk was a 30-year Navy veteran, a former submarine CO-- a Rear Admiral named Greer. Of course this was fairly terrifying for a newly-minted ensign, to be in the presence of two Admirals. Rickover didn't care about any of that. He and Greer had been arguing about something, and Rickover knew that I would take his side of the dispute. So as I stood there trembling in the presence of all that brass, Rickover shouted at me: "Reid, tell Greer why he's full of crap!."

Response by SSG Ken Thurman made Apr 3 at 2022 6:41 PM

2022-04-03T18:41:34-04:00

SSgt E-6 at the age of 19(!). Made blood stripe rocker weeks before DEROS back to the states(highly doubtful at times) in July`69 to finish out last year of enlistment. Extremely challenging motivating grunts in HEAVY combat, most of whom were draftees. "Black Power" & anti-war demos, particularity in my home state of CA, were at their height. Frankly, couldn't blame either movement. Martin Luther King & Robert Kennedy had both been assassinated within months of deployment. Officer & lifer fraggings had just started.
We had taken huge losses after being surrounded by 000's of NVA who poured over Cambodia in attempt to capture a provincial capitol... An Loc being one our battalion was tasked to protect. Intense contact in the rubber plantations & multiple ambushes. In 3 months we went from mech platoon TO&E strength of 44 (10/squad+driver for APC) when i reported to 14 the day i got out of field. Word had it the replacements we supposed be getting, were "disappearing" from copter pads in rear after learning they'd been assigned to 2/2 Inf.
To the credit of good officers (& us surviving NCO's)* all the way up to battalion commander we did our duties & drove the ____'s back across the border with huge losses! We went thru 3 CO's + 3 Lt's in our platoon! With few exceptions, our citizen soldiers fought tough & did their jobs. Few knew my age since nearly all were older than i = not an issue in the field. However, did run into alot of flak when arrived Ft Riley & was immediately made a platoon sgt in charge of career NCO's, newbie officers, & of course, it was full of pissed off draftees & brothers.

But that was a whole 'nother set of challenges, missions accomplished, & rewards. But i survived to turn 20(!).

* OK, OK, and you "air jocks" & arty.

Response by RallyPoint News made Apr 4 at 2022 11:05 AM

2022-04-04T11:05:33-04:00

Congratulations to Cpl Vic Burk, MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D., CAPT Private RallyPoint Member, MSgt Matthew Stogsdill, and SSG Archie Martinez. You've all won a $100 Amazon gift card! An e-gift card will be sent to the email address associated with your RallyPoint account.

Thanks to all who participated and shared!

Response by SGT David A. 'Cowboy' Groth made Apr 5 at 2022 6:35 AM

2022-04-05T06:35:24-04:00

When I made SGT/E5, had more responsibilities, but it was well worth the headaches @RallyPoint News

Response by SSG Kevin Gatlin made Apr 5 at 2022 11:57 AM

2022-04-05T11:57:11-04:00

SSG in the position of Platoon Sergeant

Response by 1SG Ernest Stull made Apr 27 at 2022 7:31 AM

2022-04-27T07:31:36-04:00

Sgt - E5 on the day I was promoted June 1, 1977, I was made Platoon Sgt of some of the most inglorious bastards whoever walked this earth. Their performance was the worst in Garrison, but we were always number one in the field.

Response by CPT Greg Alford, PhD made May 28 at 2022 8:26 PM

2022-05-28T20:26:49-04:00

1st LT. wasn’t a shave tail anymore, but wasn’t really considered “command” grade till I had railroad tracks. However, LOTS of responsibility and ALL the headaches!

Response by PO1 Romualdo Ramirez made Jun 15 at 2022 10:15 PM

2022-06-15T22:15:31-04:00

DC1 cause I went from working on the deck plates to working in an office. I did learn one thing though, I hate paper work.

Response by SrA Carmen Lockett made Aug 5 at 2023 9:27 PM

2023-08-05T21:27:41-04:00

Sgt.

Response by SrA Carmen Lockett made Aug 5 at 2023 9:29 PM

2023-08-05T21:29:59-04:00

I loved every part of military life. I loved being away from home