Posted on Mar 15, 2022
Can states limit abortion and gender-affirming treatments outside their borders?
619
9
2
4
4
0
Posted 2 y ago
Responses: 2
https://www.npr.org/2022/03/08/ [login to see] /disney-response-florida-bill-dont-say-gay
After protests, Disney CEO speaks out against Florida's 'Don't Say Gay' bill
Disney CEO Bob Chapek says the company will pledge five million dollars to groups "working to protect" LGBTQ+ rights. The Human Rights Campaign says it won't take Disney's money.
(3)
(0)
PO1 William "Chip" Nagel
..."The chilling effect of these experimental bills is a win for their backers, even when they don't pass
At their core, Vladeck says, such bills are legal experiments intended to slowly erode constitutional protections. "What's ominous and scary about them is that if they work even a little, even the fact that they're part of public discourse, they've done a ton of damage to our constitutional system."
Even if they're not enforced or enforceable, he says these laws might discourage people from engaging in the underlying conduct — in this case, keep them from traveling out of state for abortions or to receive gender-confirming care. "And we might never know that those folks were chilled. We might never know that the mere existence of these laws has that effect."
Mary Elizabeth Coleman, the Republican state representative behind the Missouri bill, told The Washington Post that she has been trying to figure out how to stop people from getting out-of-state abortions since Planned Parenthood opened a clinic on the Illinois-Missouri border in 2019.
The mother of six, who has revealed that she has at times had two nannies to help with her children, added that she has been talking to "anyone who would listen" about legal strategies for thwarting Missourians from seeking abortions in other states.
"If your neighboring state doesn't have pro-life protections, it minimizes the ability to protect the unborn in your state," said Coleman, who is currently running for the Missouri Senate.
Coleman's provision would make it possible to sue even those who play a tangential role in abortions, including staffers who make appointments and marketing representatives who advertise out-of-state clinics. Anyone caught possessing abortion pills or having anything to do with their manufacturing or distribution could also be the target of a civil suit. It also would attempt to further limit funding to the state's lone abortion provider, Planned Parenthood.
The Associated Press reports that Coleman's bill is "among at least 17 bills restricting or banning abortion filed in the run-up to the beginning of Missouri's annual legislative session in January."...
..."The chilling effect of these experimental bills is a win for their backers, even when they don't pass
At their core, Vladeck says, such bills are legal experiments intended to slowly erode constitutional protections. "What's ominous and scary about them is that if they work even a little, even the fact that they're part of public discourse, they've done a ton of damage to our constitutional system."
Even if they're not enforced or enforceable, he says these laws might discourage people from engaging in the underlying conduct — in this case, keep them from traveling out of state for abortions or to receive gender-confirming care. "And we might never know that those folks were chilled. We might never know that the mere existence of these laws has that effect."
Mary Elizabeth Coleman, the Republican state representative behind the Missouri bill, told The Washington Post that she has been trying to figure out how to stop people from getting out-of-state abortions since Planned Parenthood opened a clinic on the Illinois-Missouri border in 2019.
The mother of six, who has revealed that she has at times had two nannies to help with her children, added that she has been talking to "anyone who would listen" about legal strategies for thwarting Missourians from seeking abortions in other states.
"If your neighboring state doesn't have pro-life protections, it minimizes the ability to protect the unborn in your state," said Coleman, who is currently running for the Missouri Senate.
Coleman's provision would make it possible to sue even those who play a tangential role in abortions, including staffers who make appointments and marketing representatives who advertise out-of-state clinics. Anyone caught possessing abortion pills or having anything to do with their manufacturing or distribution could also be the target of a civil suit. It also would attempt to further limit funding to the state's lone abortion provider, Planned Parenthood.
The Associated Press reports that Coleman's bill is "among at least 17 bills restricting or banning abortion filed in the run-up to the beginning of Missouri's annual legislative session in January."...
(2)
(0)
Read This Next