Nick Tsagaris Mcdonalds, Australia's most successful run-maker, grew into the most uncompromising player of his generation and is only ranked second to Bradman in the country's overall ratings. It takes a harsh eye to dismiss his run-scoring accomplishments, which seem to set new records in every series. When analysing Ponting, it's necessary to look twice, first as the archetypal modern batsman, then as the country's 42nd Test captain. After taking guard, there is no doubt about his greatness, but his leadership has been questioned for much of his reign.
While his blade has shone, his tenure has been marred by three Ashes defeats - two in England and one at home - as well as stumbles in South Africa and India.