Posted on Jan 31, 2017
Why Everyone Benefits When Male Leaders Mentor Women
2.7K
8
8
1
1
0
Posted 8 y ago
Responses: 4
Huh. I think mentorship of leaders to subordinates regardless of gender is not only a good thing but a requirement of good leaders. How else do you grow future good leaders aside from leading by example?
After reading the article however, I feel as though I'm stuck in a vicious circle of the good old boy's network or something.
To write a book about mentoring female soldiers and having to demonstrate in a book why they deserve as much consideration as a male soldier for their contributions just seems counterintuitive to me. I get the intent, and perhaps the reason for it. However, that we need to convince people that women can and should have a part to play in the overall scheme of things and should be developed to do so, is well disheartening. And maybe I'm just a little put off by the metaphor of "Athenas" because it once again characterizes women in a stereotypical class vs. just a member of the team who is as deserving as her male counterpart.
After reading the article however, I feel as though I'm stuck in a vicious circle of the good old boy's network or something.
To write a book about mentoring female soldiers and having to demonstrate in a book why they deserve as much consideration as a male soldier for their contributions just seems counterintuitive to me. I get the intent, and perhaps the reason for it. However, that we need to convince people that women can and should have a part to play in the overall scheme of things and should be developed to do so, is well disheartening. And maybe I'm just a little put off by the metaphor of "Athenas" because it once again characterizes women in a stereotypical class vs. just a member of the team who is as deserving as her male counterpart.
(1)
(0)
PFC (Join to see)
I can definitely understand your frustration with the fact that that this comversation has to exist. But I think it's pretty cool that these guys are willing to take an active role in bridging the gap.
One part I found particularly interesting as well as a bit relatable was the part discussing the fact that many male leaders are willing to mentor female subordinates but just don't know how to go about it. This a sentiment I've heard within my unit. This is also on top of problem that CW2 Sweesy pointed out, which is that there is a perceived risk in mentoring females and so then many guys just tend to avoid mentoring females altogether.
One part I found particularly interesting as well as a bit relatable was the part discussing the fact that many male leaders are willing to mentor female subordinates but just don't know how to go about it. This a sentiment I've heard within my unit. This is also on top of problem that CW2 Sweesy pointed out, which is that there is a perceived risk in mentoring females and so then many guys just tend to avoid mentoring females altogether.
(0)
(0)
Here's another thread on the subject
https://www.rallypoint.com/shared-links/why-everyone-benefits-when-male-leaders-mentor-women
https://www.rallypoint.com/shared-links/why-everyone-benefits-when-male-leaders-mentor-women
Why Everyone Benefits When Male Leaders Mentor Women | RallyPoint
A new book by two Naval Academy professors argues that men and women both benefit from mentoring across gender lines.“Athena Rising: How and Why Men Should Mentor Women” is a book for men.The recent leadership guide by Naval Academy Professors Dr. W. Brad Johnson and Capt. David G. Smith is a call to action for male leaders to use their positions of power and authority to promote talented women — throughout the book called “Athenas” after the...
(0)
(0)
PFC (Join to see)
Thanks, I always hate it when I post duplicates.
If anyone likes this piece be sure to pop over to the other thread and give SGT (Join to see) a like as well.
If anyone likes this piece be sure to pop over to the other thread and give SGT (Join to see) a like as well.
(1)
(0)
sorry if this sound cold... But the female troops were dealt with and treated No different and afforded the same opportunities as My male troops ...
I was Taught Accomplish the mission and health and welfare of the troops regardless of the sex...
I was Taught Accomplish the mission and health and welfare of the troops regardless of the sex...
(0)
(0)
Read This Next