I think they should try something radically different for this test. Make it pass/fail, like the height/weight standard. If the test truly represents a level of fitness required to successfully perform your job in combat, then either a soldier can physically perform to the standard or they can't. Have different scores required for different MOS, as needed, and you can have a scoring scale for things like unit competitions or whatever. But as far as an effect on a soldiers career, a higher score shouldn't gain a soldier more promotion points, etc. anymore than you get more points for being 10 lbs under the screening weight than if you are one pound under.

This would eliminate units simply training to the test during PT sessions, and allow them to conduct varied and challenging PT instead of just rehearsing the test.

Charles I have no idea how many PT test I have taken over the years. I guess it was better than nothing but I always felt it could be improved. It was never a huge deal in SF for the simple reason we are so physical that it becomes painfully obvious when a guy is not up to the job physically. Hey good luck

Looks interesting sir, exercise is great therapy.