Posted on Apr 27, 2017
SFC Intelligence Analyst
11.2K
76
38
8
8
0
A8f13504
A soldier goes into a soldier of the month board and is told by the senior NCOs on the board her uniform is wrong. The senior female on the board tells her that her ribbons have to be centered on the seam that runs down the uniform. You know this is wrong because that is not what 670-1 says but they kick her out of the board to "fix." What do you do?
Avatar feed
Responses: 25
LtCol Robert Quinter
24
24
0
Ask my soldier to wait outside and educate the board. Once the board is in agreement that my soldier's uniform was correct, I would go outside the board room and explain to my soldier that the board has checked the regulations and found that there was no discrepancy with her uniform. I would then have her report to the board to resume the interview. If the senior female board member has any integrity, she will explain her error. If she is unwilling to do so, I would expect the senior member of the board to reinforce there was no error in her uniform, tell her not to be concerned with the error and proceed with the interview.
If I were the CO, and the senior female NCO did not explain her error to set my soldier at ease, she and I would have a meeting on the mountain after the board was adjourned.
(24)
Comment
(0)
SP5 Robert Ruck
SP5 Robert Ruck
7 y
In my opinion this is the absolutely right way to handle this situation. I have been in several interview situations wherein my answers to questions were heatedly challenged by the interview board. In return I heatedly defended my answers. If I had changed my answers I would have been summarily dismissed from consideration for the job or the promotion. Tricky business these interviews.
(3)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Charles Napierala
7
7
0
Similar thing happened to me. I had presented to the board with my sponsor in Dress A's. The board members were in ACUs. They looked over my uniform and told me I was wearing the wrong unit award and I needed to get my shit right before attending their board. They went on to tell me that they thought I was 'the example' for junior soldiers and that this was extremely disappointing.

After I left the board, I was searching my phone to find where I went wrong and made sure I had the right unit award. Shortly after I was kicked out, my sponsor pulled me back in to complete the board. At the end of the board, the members apologized, saying they were comparing my uniform to my sponsor's uniform and thought I had the wrong unit medal on it, when my sponsor was the perpetrator.

So, my sponsor stood up for me and I formed the board members that I was in the right, but he did it privately and everything worked out in the end.
(7)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPO Robert (Mac) McGovern
7
7
0
I am distressed the rest of the board did not react or know the regulation. Shame on them.
(7)
Comment
(0)
SFC Information Technology Specialist
SFC (Join to see)
7 y
good point
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close