Rp logo flat shadow
Command Post What is this?
Posted on Oct 26, 2017
Martha Raddatz
16.9K
63
47
Comments have been disabled
Responses: 17
SPC Erich Guenther
So question to Martha Raddatz. As a reporter, what is the queue you personally use as feedback that your pushing too hard or too far with the questions? There have been instances in the past on TV where I have seen the reporter not give any space or know when to back off a bit from the questioning.
Martha Raddatz
Martha Raddatz
>1 y
I think the most important thing to do when asking questions is to listen to the answers. And to sense when you are pushing too far. And I think that is what it is--just a sense. And not everyone has it! I am never going to push someone telling me an emotional story too far. I just want to listen and "feel" how far they want to go.
SGT Daniel Vieira
This question is to Ms. Raddatz, how many people from 1st Squadron, 2d ACR did you interview?
SPC Stephen Jester
SPC Stephen Jester
>1 y
From what I understand, as a medic for 3rd squadron, 2 ACR in country at that time, is that our troopers played a significant role is saving the the lives of the soldiers in 1st cav during that battle. Going back for resupply several times just to be sent back out again. All this because the commander of that unit was to proud to listen to the advice of those who have been there already of not going to Sadr Coty and to take great heed if they do. Any thoughts?
SGT Daniel Vieira
SGT Daniel Vieira
>1 y
SSG (Join to see) - Can you explain how it'd be different?
SSG Field Artillery Tactical Data Systems Specialist
SSG (Join to see)
>1 y
First of all 1st CAV didn’t listen to shit we told them. That’s the main reason they got destroyed that day. I don’t even want to watch this show because it will just kiss me off of how inaccurate it is. Not once during the trailers or commercials did I see a mention of 1st Squadron 2 ACR, you know, they guys that had to go rescue their asses out of Sadr City.
SGT Benjamin Hayhurst
SGT Benjamin Hayhurst
>1 y
First of all, the show is showing the elements of your unit that came out and helped us that day.
Second, I find it incresible that you think that we managed to screw up relations in sector in four days. That is how long we had been there. And 2acr was still in control of the area until after the ambush had started. So explain how an uprising that had to have been planned out weeks (or more) in advance was the fault of the incoming unit?
SGT David T.
I am not sure I will be able to watch it. Despite my best efforts to the contrary, I remember the April uprising quite vividly. That was a really bad time to be in Iraq. I hope it is done in good taste and not a glorification of the violence.
SPC Erich Guenther
SPC Erich Guenther
>1 y
National Geographic has pretty high standards in that regard, they would not air anything that glorified war. They have a lot of past experience with bush conflicts while attempting to do animal documentaries. They also did a pretty good job on their special with the Korengal Valley in Afghanistan. They don't really take political sides but rather tell the story through other peoples perspectives.
SGT David T.
SGT David T.
>1 y
SPC Erich Guenther - I like their stuff on animals lol. I just don't watch a lot of stuff about war unless the word star is in front of it lol
SFC Eric Bourquin
SFC Eric Bourquin
>1 y
This is not a glorification of the violence of war. This is about fallen warriors, families and what they endure while being with a service member. I hope you are able to identify with it when it airs.

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close