Posted on Aug 11, 2015
RallyPoint Shared Content
7
7
0
4f2691e2
From: The Daily Beast

It may have been lost in the epic hubbub that followed Megyn Kelly’s questioning of Donald Trump.

But former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee also stirred controversy at Thursday’s Republican candidates’ debate, albeit more quietly, when he told Fox News’s 24 million viewers that the military did not need to adopt society’s changing acceptance toward transgender people.

The military, Huckabee said at the Cleveland debate, “is not a social experiment.”

“The purpose of the military is to kill people and break things,” Huckabee added. “It’s not to transform the culture by trying out some ideas that some people think would make us a different country and more diverse. The purpose is to protect America. I’m not sure how paying for transgender surgery for soldiers, sailors, airmen, Marines makes our country safer.”

Former U.S. Navy SEAL and House congressional candidate Kristin Beck, formerly Christopher Beck, sent a tweet in outrage to Huckabee: “I was the best of the best…I am twice the man that you could ever be!”

In an interview with The Daily Beast, Beck said, “The biggest thing is, Mike Huckabee is running to be the president of the United States, and if you’re going to represent the country, you need to represent everyone.

“Right now he’s being derogatory and disrespectful to a huge part of the nation—with the amount of transgender people in America who have wives and husbands, mothers and fathers, brothers and sisters. People who understand who we are. [Our population] could go as high as 20 to 25 million people…[These are] people he should be serving, and he doesn’t care about us.”

Beck, who rose to prominence for speaking out about transgender issues and was the subject of CNN’s 2014 documentary Lady Valor: The Kristin Beck Story, is a 20-year veteran of the special operations community and recipient of the Bronze Star with valor device and Purple Heart.

She is running against Maryland incumbent Steny Hoyer (D-MD), the No. 2 Democrat in the House.

The comments from the former Arkansas governor also spurred criticism from LGBTQIA advocacy groups the Human Rights Campaign and SPARTA, a transgender military service group that advises policymakers within the Defense Department.

Brynn Tannehill, who is the director of advocacy at SPARTA, told The Daily Beast, “Taking care of our troops, transgender or otherwise, only makes our military stronger…since Governor Huckabee has never served, he should leave these decisions to the experts at the Pentagon.”

Huckabee’s campaign did not respond to a request for comment.

An estimated 15,500 transgender personnel serve in the U.S. armed forces, according to a policy study published in 2014 by the Palm Center.

Huckabee’s viewpoints at the GOP debate are in stark contrast to the Obama administration’s strategy to fully integrate transgender service members.

In July, Defense Secretary Ashton Carter said, “We have transgender soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines—real, patriotic Americans—who I know are being hurt by an outdated, confusing, inconsistent approach that’s contrary to our value of service and individual merit,” according to a statement from the Defense Department.

“He’s taking his religion and his personal beliefs and disenfranchising a large portion of the population. And I just think as a leader, you need to put the people ahead of your own feelings sometimes,” Beck said. “Governor Huckabee has no idea what it means to sacrifice. It’s service and sacrifice over your own person. Others above self—always—and he does not understand that.”

Last month, the Pentagon established a military-civilian working group to examine the implications of lifting the ban on transgender service members serving openly and how that would affect operational readiness.

Carter said the group will operate under the assumption that transgender troops can successfully integrate into the military ranks without trepidation.

The six-month study will focus on how hormones affect transgender service members while serving in a warzone, uniform and housing changes, and how medical care is financed.

Under new DoD rules, transgender-related conditions are no longer a precedent for administrative separation. Instead, individual military branches will have the authority to remove presently serving transgender personal for conditions that interfere with military assignments or performance of duty.

Additionally, transgender applicants are barred from entering military service and not granted waivers for transgender-related conditions—a bureaucratic clause that some critics find ironic. Current policy lists being transgender as a paraphilia, along with bestiality and pedophilia. Homosexuality also fell under this category until 1993 and the Obama administration’s ending of the Defense Department’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy.

Despite the polices still needing amendments, Beck believes the DoD is heading in the right direction—she herself is working with both senior military leadership and policymakers.

“I met with a lot of the Air Force leadership that are a part of this policy work, and they are really taking into consideration our needs as transgender persons and bouncing that off operational readiness and costs,” Beck said.

“The pundits fighting this who are really upset about [transgender service members] are the ones with the biggest issues in their heads, because they’re going straight to fetishes or sex and body parts,” she added. “But what they don’t understand is that this is about my identity, this is who I see when I look in the mirror. It has nothing to do with sex.”

Beck added that there was a misconception about surgery and the 15,500 service members in the military who are transgender.

“[In the military], out of the 15,500 people, maybe half those people are not going through surgery for transgender [reassignment],” Beck said. “You have to understand that we [transgender] are on a large scale from someone who gets all the surgery to someone who’s just transgender non-conforming, and it’s all more of an intellectual pursuit or a spiritual thing where they know, ‘This is who I am, this is my identity, and I don’t need to have physical changes in order to put me in that space of what my identity really is.’

“So when they say 15,500, it’s not going to be 15,500 people putting their hands in the air saying, ‘Yeah, I want surgery’ next week.”

The figure of those opting for surgery, said Beck, would be closer to 5,000 people, “where you have female to male and male to female.”

In February, Defense Department officials said that hormone treatment for gender reassignment had been approved for former Army intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning, formerly Bradley Manning, who was convicted of espionage for sending classified documents to the website WikiLeaks.

The decision to allow Manning to undergo the transition to a woman was approved by Army Col. Erica Nelson at Fort Leavenworth, Kan., after the American Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit in September 2014 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia alleging that Manning was at risk for self-castration and suicide stemming from her depression over not being fully allowed to transition into her gender identity, according to the Associated Press.

The Army’s decision sparked condemnation from some quarters.

Former Florida Republican congressman and retired Army Lt. Col. Allen West’s website said in response to the news, “You’ve heard of ‘white guilt?’ Perhaps it was ‘straight guilt’ that led the Army to take this unprecedented move.”

Manning is serving a 35-year sentence, which she is appealing.

Nevertheless, Beck agrees with the military’s decision to allow Manning to undergo gender reassignment.

“While you are in federal custody or any custody within any prison system, that institution has the responsibility to take care of that person,” Beck said. “So I 100 percent support it, because I think it’s the right thing to do. You have to separate the crime from that person’s human rights when you think about this issue.”

Moreover, Beck applauded Manning’s efforts in “forwarding the thought” for integration of transgender service members in the military, saying, “I think she did a great job…so if we are already [paying for Manning’s hormones and surgery] then we need to look at this entire policy and make sure we take care of people who are serving honorably on active duty. It’s about taking care of people, not hardware. People are more important than tanks and planes, it’s us…your most important asset.”

Still, Beck does not feel Huckabee’s views disqualify him from potentially serving as commander in chief. “You can’t base [his ability to be president] off of one thing,” she said. “It’s like when people look at me and say that I’m transgender and they don’t want me to be in the U.S. Congress based off that, it’s the same thing…it’s just not fair.”

“I would love to sit down with Huckabee and show him I am pretty normal. I might believe in some of the things he believes [in]. We have a lot of the same hopes and dreams for our nation. And if we disagree, that’s OK—disagreements make us better, but in the end, we respect each other in reaching the goal, [which] is prosperity,” Beck said.

“I want my children’s children to have a future and have a good country, which is what I grew up in,” Beck said. “I think we are leaving it worse right now because all we’re doing is fighting with each other.”

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/08/11/transgender-navy-seal-takes-on-huckabee.html
Posted in these groups: 9ed82c1 Transgender6262122778 997339a086 z Politics
Avatar feed
Responses: 19
LCDR Sales & Proposals Manager Gas Turbine Products
13
13
0
I'm probably going to "offend" someone here...but I'm beginning to think that's inevitable in any discussion today.

Ok- So a Navy SEAL, obviously one of our most highly trained and capable warfighters, decides to become a woman. First of all, unless there is evidence to the contrary, I'm fairly confident Beck is no longer on active duty...political gamesmanship or not, I doubt Naval Special Warfare is looking to risk the potential physical "unknowns" in an active SEAL team. If so, I don't see that Huckabee's comments are so controversial. We're talking about the readiness and cost issues associated with catering to personal choice...period.

The moral question aside-I admit that I personally find "trans-gender" inclinations to be tragic, confusing and indicative of larger pain/mal-adjustment...the Armed Forces simply aren't geared to cater to this much individuality.

I'm not a medical doctor, nor any sort of "expert" on the physical effects of the treatments, surgeries, or hormone therapies required to go from one gender to the next...but I imagine it is a costly, lengthy, and at times physically limiting process. No disrespect to Beck; looks like he/she could still bring the pain...but what critical abilities are affected; does having breast augmentation change the accuracy of someone whose spent a lifetime shooting without them? Does the replacement of testosterone with estrogen create adverse physiological changes in someone who has only known life as a male? Perhaps I'm out of line, but if female-by-birth sailors would have to overcome BUDS as women...can we objectively comment on the abilities of a person who qualified as a man, now that they are a woman?
(13)
Comment
(0)
SGM Mikel Dawson
SGM Mikel Dawson
8 y
Hey, he, she, it can be what ever they want to be. I just stated genetically still a guy. Wasn't the old Army slogan, "Be all you can be"
(1)
Reply
(0)
PO3 Richard Alexander
PO3 Richard Alexander
8 y
Things are changing quickly, but, the last I checked, not very many women are SEALs. I'm not even sure that women are allowed in the SEALs, but whether they are or not, much fewer women than men would be able to pass the physical and mental requirements. All of that said, I doubt this guy, who is posing as a woman, is an active-duty SEAL, and I doubt that any woman who poses as a man would pass the course.
From the article:
"Former U.S. Navy SEAL"
So, not active duty.
"and House congressional candidate Kristin Beck, formerly Christopher Beck, sent a tweet in outrage to Huckabee: “I was the best of the best…I am twice the man that you could ever be!”"
So, he's a man, who thinks he's a woman who thinks he's twice the man as Huckabee.
(0)
Reply
(0)
PFC Amthony Murray
PFC Amthony Murray
8 y
LTJG (Join to see) - It is not saying someone is or is not as much of a human. It is simply saying we are different. I disagree with homosexuals but I have a couple close friends who are homosexual. I do not know any transgender but I do not see where they would be any less human. I believe in God and think it is for him to place judgement and punishment if there is to be any. The chromosomes that make us men or women cannot be changed by transgender surgery. So men will always be men, and women will always be women, not matter what they try to do to change it.
(0)
Reply
(0)
LTJG Executive Assistant To The Deputy Commandant
LTJG (Join to see)
8 y
PFC Amthony Murray - Chromosomes do not make us men or women. The definition of a man is not "one who has XY chromosomes" and the same goes for women. Therefore, your assertion that "men will always be men" based upon their chromosomes is false. Otherwise, we would say that an infant with XY chromosomes was already a man, when in reality there is much to be learned before they can be a man. Also, there are females who are assigned female at birth due to having typical female genitals, but when they should reach puberty, nothing happens because they are in reality XY females. Even you would consider them to be female, but they do in fact have XY chromosomes. This does not make them men. The concept of being a man or a woman is entirely a social construct. Without society's labels, men and women would not exist.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Nathan Freeman
7
7
0
There aren't anywhere close to 20 million transgender in the US. Less than 1% can be considered transgender.

Military healthcare is meant to keep us healthy for the fight, not major elective surgery. They will pay for one plastic surgery but a sex change would take you out of the fight for a significant amount of time. Thus, it is counterproductive to readiness. I couldn't even get braces for my teeth as long as there was a pending deployment .
(7)
Comment
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
>1 y
It depends on what surgery is done and the extent of it. MTF GRS is a relatively simple procedure, but FFS is very complex and has a long recovery time. FTM surgeries include mastectomy, which is a difficult recovery, and GRS, which is very complex...

In addition for MTF there are 100s of hours of Electrolysis or Laser hair removal needed, which is very costly. It also is very time and energy consuming.

I don't know what SECDEF will ultimately decide, but my guess is that while openly serving as a transgendered person will be allowed, I am not sure if DOD will pay for the requisite surgeries and other procedures required for transition. This is a pure budgetary issue in a year when DOD healthcare is broke...

In addition, the logistics for those transitioning and those who go to non-binary endstates still need to be worked out.

Nothing is simple about this...
SN J W
SN J W
8 y
100's of hours of electrolysis. Why would someone need this? How is this medically necessary? If you are a man or a woman, in all but very rare circumstances, nature provides certain amounts of hair. If you have changed gender, the hair will follow. No need to charge the general public to give you the amount of hair you think you should have.

Also, LCDR. You obviously lied repeatedly throughout your military career, why should you be considered a trustworthy source now?
(1)
Reply
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
7 y
SN J W - I suggest you read my blog about my transition. If you do, you'll see that I didn't put it all together until 2 years ago. I did not realize my identity myself, so I was not lying to anyone.

Further, before you comment on what procedures transgender people need, perhaps you should do some learning first. Your lack of knowledge is completely apparent.

http://www.RabbahRona.us
SPC Nathan Freeman
SPC Nathan Freeman
7 y
Blogs are not research. Research says that transgender is actually called gender dysphoria and is a mental illness akin to schizophrenia and other disorders not allowed in the military. Research also says that 40% of people with this condition have attempted suicide. With the stresses we deal with already, our suicide rate is already to high. Luckily Gen Mattis and POTUS have already made the right decision to scrap the plan
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Stephen F.
4
4
0
Edited >1 y ago
Truth is stranger than fiction. People can't speak their minds without being chastised.
Transgender was something that was not at the forefront of most people's conscious thoughts a year ago; yet, DoD mandated acceptance of transgender people earlier this year.
Each transgender person is a human being and worthy of respect and dignity; however, when societal mores and values are upended very quickly expect turbulent times for months if not years to come.
(4)
Comment
(0)
LTC Stephen F.
LTC Stephen F.
8 y
Maj Rob Drury - as I have posted in other discussions, I respect my superiors, peers and subordinates as appropriate to rank and duty. By respect I don't mean condone what they stand for, say or do.
A great example is my adult sons who I love and respect. They know they are free to talk to me about anything and I will listen because they are my sons. If I disagree with their point of view or what they plan to do I will tell them. It is up to them to make the decision and live with the consequences.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Maj Rob Drury
Maj Rob Drury
8 y
LTC Stephen F. - But it shouldn't be up to prospective transgenders to make bad decisions at the expense of my tax dollars or military readiness.
(1)
Reply
(0)
LTC Stephen F.
LTC Stephen F.
8 y
Maj Rob Drury - I violently agree with you. I believe people have the ability to choose to do what they want but I feel no obligation to fund it and resent my tax dollars being used for transgender purposes. I am still unconvinced that there is such a thing as a transgender - you are either male of female either; can be neutered - transgender seems to be a variant of neutered human.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Maj Rob Drury
Maj Rob Drury
8 y
LTC Stephen F. - [thumbs up!]
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close