Posted on Apr 22, 2015
How does our government's obligation to Veterans compare to our government's capability to meet that obligation?
9.83K
14
15
5
5
0
We speak a lot about the Department of Veterans Affairs, and its failures (Health & Pension).
I pose this question.
"Does the US Government actually possess the capability to take care of Veterans 'As promised,' or are we setting them (us) up for failure?"
If we are setting 'us' up for failure, because it is an unreasonable expectation, do we need to adjust our expectations?
I pose this question.
"Does the US Government actually possess the capability to take care of Veterans 'As promised,' or are we setting them (us) up for failure?"
If we are setting 'us' up for failure, because it is an unreasonable expectation, do we need to adjust our expectations?
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)
Leadership
Retirement
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 9
5
5
0
I would say Sgt Aaron Kennedy, MS that they shouldn't promise what they cannot deliver. If it is a system issue, fix the system. If the system cannot be fixed, rebuild it from the ground up. If the means to fullfill the promise don't exist, don't make the promise.
(5)
(0)
Sgt Aaron Kennedy, MS
PO3 Steven Sherrill I generally agree.. however we as a country encouraged enlistment since the days of the Continental Congress. The Current Dept of VA is 84 years old.
This isn't a case of making promises they can't deliver. It's a case of our great great great great grandfathers making a promise they couldn't deliver because they didn't have enough data at the time.
They were ill prepared for the reality of the situation. Not just now, but then.
I've quoted it before, but the first director of the modern VA (Forbes) was literally choked in the Oval Office by the President for incompetence.
I reiterate. Are we setting this organization up for failure? As leaders of men, would we find this situation acceptable if we were doing this to a Troop vice an Agency?
This isn't a case of making promises they can't deliver. It's a case of our great great great great grandfathers making a promise they couldn't deliver because they didn't have enough data at the time.
They were ill prepared for the reality of the situation. Not just now, but then.
I've quoted it before, but the first director of the modern VA (Forbes) was literally choked in the Oval Office by the President for incompetence.
I reiterate. Are we setting this organization up for failure? As leaders of men, would we find this situation acceptable if we were doing this to a Troop vice an Agency?
(0)
(0)
3
3
0
Wow! This is a really great question!
I think one of the biggest problems with the system is that a large majority of the VA leaderships has never served. They don’t know what it’s like to be a SM or a Veteran. And they will never know what it’s like to use the VA for their CARE or have to rely on them for benefits. They may be making progress but for me... any veteran who commits suicide is one to many... it’s NOT a reason to celebrate over saving one... I want to save them all. I don’t want to remove 500 vets from the streets, I want them all to have shelter and a bed. They jump for joy over the backlog being down to 150,000, but to me, that 150,000 vets that are still waiting, and probably struggling for a little extra to help their family every month. So for me progress isn't enough. I want success. I want MORE. And I think we are setting us up for failure in that sense. because in every data released it about the improved numbers... not about the ones still behind.
I think one of the biggest problems with the system is that a large majority of the VA leaderships has never served. They don’t know what it’s like to be a SM or a Veteran. And they will never know what it’s like to use the VA for their CARE or have to rely on them for benefits. They may be making progress but for me... any veteran who commits suicide is one to many... it’s NOT a reason to celebrate over saving one... I want to save them all. I don’t want to remove 500 vets from the streets, I want them all to have shelter and a bed. They jump for joy over the backlog being down to 150,000, but to me, that 150,000 vets that are still waiting, and probably struggling for a little extra to help their family every month. So for me progress isn't enough. I want success. I want MORE. And I think we are setting us up for failure in that sense. because in every data released it about the improved numbers... not about the ones still behind.
(3)
(0)
Sgt Aaron Kennedy, MS
In essence, the status reports show how the VA is still failing, vice how it is is successful.
(0)
(0)
(0)
(0)
SSG (Join to see)
I don't believe you need to have served, in order to have empathy for those who have... I believe it's more a matter of competent managers being stolen by a private sector with much higher levels of compensation while marginally and incompetent managers are left running the organization. A civilian hospital CEO is making on average well over 500K a year, I doubt the person managing a VA hospital makes half that... if their good at what they do, why wouldn't they go and double or triple their paycheck?
(0)
(0)
SSgt Richard Kensinger
As a clinical psychologist, and based on my clinical research and experience, it is important to competently understand military and combat culture. at our local VAC in altoona, PA, very few front-line clinicians have military experience, let alone, combat experience. And when i counseled combat vets and medics, the fact that i served as a medic during Vietnam, afforded me instant credibility beyond my clinical skills.
Rich
Rich
(0)
(0)
0
0
0
It ultimately comes down to money. There are roughly 20,000,000 Veterans with varying degrees of need and worthiness. Not every Veteran needs or deserves a 100 percent disability rating or lifetime health care. At some point the government has to decide how much it is going to spend on Veterans and who will get how much.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google