Posted on Mar 27, 2019
MIDN 4/C (Pre-Commission)
5.62K
18
13
1
1
0
I am currently a 4/C Midshipman in Naval ROTC and I am seeking some advice. I am thinking of dropping the program so that I can switch majors and schools and so that I can hone in on my training more. With regards to my current unit, it seems to be sucking all of my motivation out of me and I am not doing as well as I know I can. I have some wild aspirations that I want to bring into reality but I do not think I can get that done at my unit. So, with that, it would be awesome to hear what some of you have to say in regards to OCS vs. NROTC. Am I limiting my options by dropping NROTC? Is there a hidden benefit to NROTC that I am not seeing? And is there a difference once you get to the fleet between the two commission routes?
Avatar feed
Responses: 6
MAJ Byron Oyler
3
3
0
OCS is much shorter and generally much tougher. Somethings you need to consider right now is is your unit crap or are you not cut out to be a military officer? I do not know you or your program and those are just things to consider.
(3)
Comment
(0)
MIDN 4/C (Pre-Commission)
MIDN 4/C (Join to see)
5 y
Thanks for the response sir! I think I am bored with the program if anything. I know that is a bold statement to make but it is probably the most accurate for my situation
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Retention Operations Nco
3
3
0
While I'm not Navy, I think I can answer the obvious part of your question.
What's the benefit of ROTC? Getting your college paid for, which is why people go into ROTC, also why people enlist for a GI Bill.
OCS generally is a program for service members who already possess a degree.
I don't see how you would benefit by dropping your scholarship in order to apply for a commissioning program with a boat load of student debt. Your current route will already lead you into a commission and pay for your college.
(3)
Comment
(0)
MIDN 4/C (Pre-Commission)
MIDN 4/C (Join to see)
5 y
Thank you for responding! In my current situation I have the scholarship but I still have to pay for room and board which is about the same cost as transferring to a larger ( and arguably better) university near my house. I would just commute then, so the financial side I have covered either way.
(0)
Reply
(0)
MAJ Javier Rivera
MAJ Javier Rivera
5 y
MIDN 4/C (Join to see) your scholarship is a school or NROTC? If is the later you are under contract. If not then hope for the new school to give you another scholarship.
(0)
Reply
(0)
MIDN 4/C (Pre-Commission)
MIDN 4/C (Join to see)
5 y
The scholarship is through NROTC sir. I may have been confused at what you meant by contract but as of now I do not have a financial/service commitment to fufill if I were to drop. I sign this August.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
LCDR Joshua Gillespie
3
3
0
Mr. Nelson,

Major Rivera pointed out one of the greatest immediate concerns-are you under contract? I assume you're in your first year (4/C), so the impacts financially, academically, and esoterically will vary compared to if you were about to graduate.

Beyond that, I'd like to offer my advice, for what it's worth. If your aspirations still include the Navy, you don't want to "quit" anything...ever. If you're attending NROTC under scholarship, you had to commit some time and effort, not to mention beat out some stiff competition to be afforded the opportunity...leaving the program, even for apparently "noble" reasons will definitely send the wrong message to those you may interact with later in your career. The single best thing you can do to positively impact your future service assignment is to do your absolute BEST in the pipeline you're currently in.

As to how the "Fleet" views your commissioning source, allow me to politely deprive you of some misconceptions. First, all new ensigns share the same first two jobs... learn and qualify. You won't be of much use to your Sailors, your ship, or the service until you do. I don't know what your current aims are, or what aspects of the program are de-motivating to you, but depending on your service assignment, you're looking at up to one-two years beyond graduation before you really even "join" the Fleet. At that point, you'll be judged more by your performance and personality than where you earned your commission. Whether your SWO-bound, or heading to BUD/S, you'll be joining your year group on the even plane of accepting a new challenge.

True-once you've been around a while, there are "differences", but honestly, I've seen fellow USNA grads get RIF'd, while their ROTC/OCS peers were doing the heavy lifting.

As regards training, I can't comment too specifically without knowing what your goals actually are. NROTC, OCS, and even the Academy all have the same basic mission-produce junior officers for the Navy and Marine Corps. A Midshipman at USNA may have access to some programs you don't, and an OCS candidate officer may possess a background that will more positively influence their chosen career path later on...it's all relative. One thing I'm pretty certain you can't do better by switching to any of the three is, "hone in on more training". That's up to you my friend, and nothing's standing in your way but your own determination, drive, and ability.
(3)
Comment
(0)
MIDN 4/C (Pre-Commission)
MIDN 4/C (Join to see)
5 y
Thank you sir. I appreciate the response.
(0)
Reply
(0)
LCDR Joshua Gillespie
LCDR Joshua Gillespie
5 y
Reading your below response adds some detail. If you're taking ROTC as an elective, and not under contract, than I certainly don't expect you can hurt things by applying to make it "count". One thing is certain, getting a commission is difficult...and that's a good thing. I think you can apply for a two-three year scholarship to complete your degree, and earn a commission...can't be 100% certain, but I'm sure your unit's officer can tell you. You may stand a better chance at that route, as opposed to starting all over. If you can get a slot at OCS after earning your degree...good stuff. If your aiming at Nuke Power, you're brain is your asset, so whatever you do, make sure you're showing exceptional performance in pursuit of a highly technical degree. Best wishes, and good luck!
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close