Posted on May 2, 2015
Why do you think most discharge upgrade applications fail?
3.5K
17
9
4
4
0
Posted 9 y ago
Responses: 4
2
2
0
While I did read the article I would still have to say "unclear, badly written statements." I've heard stories that go like this: "I want my discharge upgraded." That's it, no substance.
(2)
(0)
LtCol John Currie
I've seen statements droning on about hunting, fishing and every other conceivable thing EXCEPT for something that might have mattered to the board.
(2)
(0)
1
1
0
I selected "Lack of decisional issues" as I have seen similar packages, in different contexts, many many times. Quite simply, a board won't rule in your favor and overturn the initial decision unless they have an objective reason to do so.
That said, "Overall tone" is a definite runner up. "You guys suck, but give me what I want!" is rarely effective.
And I would like to second your comment about "overwhelming the board with documentation." In certain circumstances, I have used the "thud factor" myself in making arguments. However, never when I am trying to convince someone to overturn an earlier decision. To get someone to overturn a decision, you have to give just enough - well organized - to make it clear that your argument is correct, and nothing extraneous.
That said, "Overall tone" is a definite runner up. "You guys suck, but give me what I want!" is rarely effective.
And I would like to second your comment about "overwhelming the board with documentation." In certain circumstances, I have used the "thud factor" myself in making arguments. However, never when I am trying to convince someone to overturn an earlier decision. To get someone to overturn a decision, you have to give just enough - well organized - to make it clear that your argument is correct, and nothing extraneous.
(1)
(0)
LtCol John Currie
I meant to put a 5th option: All of the above I've seen packages fail for all these reasons...as I'm sure you have. Sounds like you are living the dream at the DRB....good times!
(0)
(0)
0
0
0
So how does one know if their discharge has a good chance of being upgraded?
(0)
(0)
LtCol John Currie
Good question Joe. Every case is different so that is a very difficult question to answer in a general way. Broadly speaking, if an applicant has strong documentation to support their issues before the board..and, if the applicant has outstanding, well documented post-service conduct, they are likely to have a strong case. Much depends on the seriousness of the misconduct, the amount of misconduct and the type of characterization received.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google