The news today is that illegals, in small numbers, will be allowed to serve. This comes on the heels of reports that the active duty army is laying off 30,000 Soldiers in the next 17 months, and that recruiters will "need to get picky" in their recruits.
Does this rub anyone else the wrong way? I have no problem with using military service as a path to citizenship. However, in the current situation, this seems like a slap in the face not only to those who have served with honor and integrity and will be forced out (or already have been), but also to those who will be passed over for service in the recruiting process.
Illegals, after all, entered the country illegally. I am sure there are several potential recruits who will be passed over due to minor brushes with the law, or for tattoos or something similar. Their past behavior will be punished in that they will be denied service. Service that was once used as a means for someone to straighten up and make something out of themselves.
I understand the argument that some illegals were brought over as children and basically had no clue what was happening. I get that. Still, This is not the time to implement something like this. One day, but not now.
This is not debating the merits of allowing illegals to serve. I have no problem with that. They want to be citizens, they want to bleed with citizens on the battlefield, I commend them and am all for it. This has to do with allowing this as a recruiting tool during a time when we are forcing good men out by the flip of a coin.
What say you?
Does this rub anyone else the wrong way? I have no problem with using military service as a path to citizenship. However, in the current situation, this seems like a slap in the face not only to those who have served with honor and integrity and will be forced out (or already have been), but also to those who will be passed over for service in the recruiting process.
Illegals, after all, entered the country illegally. I am sure there are several potential recruits who will be passed over due to minor brushes with the law, or for tattoos or something similar. Their past behavior will be punished in that they will be denied service. Service that was once used as a means for someone to straighten up and make something out of themselves.
I understand the argument that some illegals were brought over as children and basically had no clue what was happening. I get that. Still, This is not the time to implement something like this. One day, but not now.
This is not debating the merits of allowing illegals to serve. I have no problem with that. They want to be citizens, they want to bleed with citizens on the battlefield, I commend them and am all for it. This has to do with allowing this as a recruiting tool during a time when we are forcing good men out by the flip of a coin.
What say you?
Recruiting
Immigration
Military Industry
Drawdown
Edited 10 y ago
Posted 10 y ago
This is a duplicate discussion and the contents have been merged with the original discussion. Click below to see more on this topic...
*Edit for clarity*
So after reviewing all the below comments and responses, it's apparent that there are a few divergent arguments being had, few if which address the intended message of the OP at all.
Hopefully I can add some clarity. The intended message is this; " we should not be judging people by race, ethnicity, or origin. Individuals should be each assessed on their individual abilities, skills, and merit.".
That's it. Any other message was not intended. I find the practice of judging others for genetic happenstance to be abhorrent.
http://www.militarytimes.com/article/20140925/NEWS05/309250074/DoD-policy-will-allow-some-immigrants-U-S-illegally-serve?sf31602802=1
So after reviewing all the below comments and responses, it's apparent that there are a few divergent arguments being had, few if which address the intended message of the OP at all.
Hopefully I can add some clarity. The intended message is this; " we should not be judging people by race, ethnicity, or origin. Individuals should be each assessed on their individual abilities, skills, and merit.".
That's it. Any other message was not intended. I find the practice of judging others for genetic happenstance to be abhorrent.
http://www.militarytimes.com/article/20140925/NEWS05/309250074/DoD-policy-will-allow-some-immigrants-U-S-illegally-serve?sf31602802=1
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google