At what rank should Soldiers be exempt from organized PT?

Retired

None -- that determination should be made by the commander and should be based on mission and incentives that are fair and equitable across the board.

Never. Unless you're retired.

UNLESS that soldier has a valid profile or a vital Ops. Mos that prevents them from participation non should be exempt. Lead by example . If you expect your soldiers to participate then you should do so as well.train together fight together.

I don't know about the US Army but in the USMC at every duty station I served at, E-6 and above were pretty much exempt from the daily PT unless it was mandated from above!

Never! I saw people because of their rank, or their connections up the chain who got away without doing organized PT.

As long as you are a soldier, PT is part of the gig!

E-9. Because it’s already made you should rotate to different units to check on PT. All leaders should conduct PT with their soldiers I know due to age they’ll be different levels of fitness but leadership is leadership in all aspects

Apparently Commander-in-Chief!!

Civilian/retired