Posted on Feb 26, 2016
Did the Telegraph significantly influence the course of the US Civil War?
6.31K
57
27
11
11
0
I submit that the telegraph significantly influenced the course of the war. Early on President Lincoln seemed to grasp the importance and capability of the telegraph to both communicate with his leaders in the field and to get updates from them.
"What became of our forces which held the bridge till twenty minutes ago...?"
http://civilwarstudies.org/articles/Vol_8/situation-room.shtm
"What became of our forces which held the bridge till twenty minutes ago...?"
http://civilwarstudies.org/articles/Vol_8/situation-room.shtm
Edited >1 y ago
Posted 9 y ago
Responses: 15
There is an argument among those of us who study the evolution of Operational Art of where it began. It generally splits into two camps with a third minor one. The first two are the 1) American Civil War proponents, and 2) the Napoleonic Wars proponents. First, understand that prior to either of these, the concept was for two massed armies to meet on a battlefield and conduct one large fight (or not depending on parlay) to decide the victor. This is GROSS oversimplification. With the Civil War, both sides still looked for this elusive grand battle which would signal the end of the opposition. From McClellan's failed siege of Richmond to 2nd Manassas and Gettysburg there was this feeling that one battle could end it all if only one side could destroy that army en-mass. The evolution of single battle wars to multiple, simultaneous and sequential battles (Jackson's Shenandoah Campaign is a good example), or what we now call operations heralded the era of Operational Art. This could not have been accomplished without a small number of technological inventions. First, the telegraph allowed a commander to be far removed from battle and communicate with multiple subordinate generals. Unlike the past where a king or a prince had to command all his units in a line of sight with flags and music, the commander could be far removed and command multiple armies. This allowed the control of multiple formations across as much space as you could run a telegraph wire and keep it from getting cut. These usually ran along another invention which changed the nature of movement at the time: the railroad. The railroad enabled a commander to deploy forces rapidly along multiple avenues of approach to converge on a single point where the battle was to take place (external lines of communication). It also allowed for movements of troops laterally...quickly. Changing the way commanders thought about the velocity of war. A third invention is the rifle and the repeating rifle. At the beginning of the war, nearly all Confederate troops carried their own smooth bore muskets into battle. These were highly inaccurate weapons unless you were within 100 yards, and even then had to be fired en-mass to gain effect. The introduction of the rifled barrel and the minie-ball changed the way infantrymen could be used on the battlefield. Neither side used this last one well because the doctrine of employing a Division/Corps/Army on the field was ingrained from the use of the musket for so long. The telegraph was a huge part of the advent of Operational Art and changed the way we could conduct warfare, but it was only one of a handful of inventions which were spawned by warfare at the time. I didn't even get into cannon upgrades at the time.
(4)
(0)
COL (Join to see)
I figured it would be to the big-guns on the ships. I guess it could have been used against the rebel Army of Northern Virginia if they were foolish enough to pursue McClellan into the cover of his guns when he retreated from Richmond, but we'll never know.
(2)
(0)
COL (Join to see)
Also...to state something absurdly obvious...I assume there was some poor sap who had to float up in these things with a telegraph wire inside of them.
(2)
(0)
MSgt Darren VanDerwilt
Yep! From what I've read, it took just over three hours to deploy one of these observation balloons. Very time consuming for a situation that would likely be developing quickly. However, when dealing with static emplacements could be quite effective.
(1)
(0)
COL (Join to see)
Quickly is a relative term. You certainly wouldn't have used them in the "field" in the civil war, but to gain observation around major cities and emplacements, probably a novel use of a new technology.
(1)
(0)
Absolutely. Theres a few great scenes in the movie "Lincoln" that capture the use of the telegraph.
(4)
(0)
Read This Next