Posted on May 26, 2015
SFC Joseph James
23.9K
210
142
17
17
0
897472506
I tried to see a therapist at the VA a few years ago and I hated it. I couldn't open up if i wanted to. How do you talk to a person who has no idea what Combat Veterans go through? I know the value of talking about your issues but I just don't know how to with a civilian therapist. Let's not make this just about me, lets open a discussion for the Pros/Cons of therapy. I sure will listen to everyone's advice here on this subject. What do you all think about it?
Posted in these groups: 78568930 PTSDTherapy logo Therapy
Edited 9 y ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 66
MAJ Keira Brennan
9
9
0
Edited 9 y ago
SFC James. I am not a clinician but I do work in the mental health field as an addiction technician. I think that any competent clinician can help combat veterans sort through things and help develop a path of healing. Thinking that a clinician can't be helpful because 'they weren't in combat' SOUNDS like it makes sense but actuality it doesn't. Its like my clients telling me because I never did meth or heroin that 'I can't understand...' Pain and trauma, both physical (IED, TIC, Mortars) and emotional/psychological are all very deep wounds that are REAL and processed in the brain. There are some very dedicated people out there who can help. Clinicians such as those that work with severe victims of abuse/rape, trauma survivors of all kinds, and those of us who saw combat. I'd suggest someone who is integrated into the biological(med), psychological, and social model (healthy living). Best of luck for all seeking to heal.
And for P01 Hooks who said "They who have never been in a combat zone..." Last time I checked my DD214 I had a Bronze Star and two campaign medals.
(9)
Comment
(0)
SrA Sarah Smith
SrA Sarah Smith
9 y
The only reason it still matters after being out for 7 years is because one the reasons the VA has given me when they denied my PTSD claim is that there isn't a campaign medal in my records to prove that I was in a combat situation. Okay well, y'all diagnosed me with it right after I got out, so......oh, y'all don't have enough evidence to approve my claim? O-kayyyy lol. I will just keep bothering them until someone gets tired of hearing me. ;)
(2)
Reply
(0)
Cpl Lisa Wolford
Cpl Lisa Wolford
9 y
SrA Sarah Smith, contact your local VSO (Veteran Service Organizations) they all have folks that help people file an accurate claim. Some are better than others. Best of luck
(0)
Reply
(0)
MAJ Keira Brennan
MAJ Keira Brennan
9 y
My feelings exactly. A vso can help
(0)
Reply
(0)
SrA Sarah Smith
SrA Sarah Smith
9 y
I've used both the State VA reps and the DAV for claims, and I'm still in the same place with both. I'm not sure where to go next.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Special Operations Response Team (Sort)
9
9
0
Edited 9 y ago
Remember a few things about mental health therapy
1. You are there to gain SELF insight guided by a mental health professional
2. It doesnt matter if you like them, they are not your friend
3. It does not matter if they like you, they are not your friend. They should have professional empathy but their job is not to be warm and fuzzy but... see #1
4. Understand a good counselor helps you find the answers within yourself.
5. This takes time. There is no pill nor magic involved.
(9)
Comment
(0)
SPC Combat Engineer
SPC (Join to see)
9 y
Well said, Sir.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SPC Anne Miller
SPC Anne Miller
9 y
I find support groups good.
NAMI peer to peer
I also attend ACA group twice a week.
Also, good videos on YouTube.
One of my favorites Binuralbeats.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Mark Merino
7
7
0
Great question and valid points SFC Joseph James. This is what is so FRUSTRATING with me not being able to land a job counseling veterans and service members. Not to pat myself on the back, but been there done that. When I was is the hospital and 18.5 years of service was circling the toilet I BEGGED to talk to someone I could trust and who had been in my shoes. There was no one. I spent years going to school from a hospital bed, typing with one or two fingers from whatever hand was able to work to finish my degree because I didn't want anyone else to feel as powerless as I did. I've gone through the bureaucratic wringer from start to finish, lost the career, home, marriage, chronic pain, 4 month PTSD residential program, divorce, VA disability appeals, borderline homelessness, poverty, alcoholism, jail (DUI). I am not running for Mr Morality, or the Presidency, or Husband of the Year, but I can reachthose who have chronic trust issues with therapists. In Alaska, I worked in the Army's PTSD clinic and talk about a true calling. It was the best job and the perfect fit. After 4 months, I had to return to the lower 48 for divorce proceedings that lasted more than 3 years. I was given glowing recommendations and even offered my job back with DA, but couldn't leave my children behind. All I hear from USAjobs is not qualified. 500 applicationsand counting. I'm coming unglued, hence my RallyPoint overuse. I digress.
As far as counseling goes, it is never one size fits all. After listing my laundry list of unscrupulous deeds and history, can you imagine an ivy leaguer wanting to be anywhere near me when his marriage falls apart, lost millions in the stock market and his mistress left him? Even service members with combat related PTS need to feel comfortable with their counselor and I could be the worst thing for them. Some need one on one, some work better in groups, some obsess about religious affiliation, some want to only work with civilians and don't trust any green suiters. It is a lot like used car shopping. It's rare to find your dream car by going to the first lot you come across when you are dead set on the car you are looking for. I'm not Dr Philand only have a masters. I just want to ease the minds of those who are facing as much uncertainty as I did and assure them that it isn't the end of the world. For those unhappy with their current therapy, please try someone else instead of assuming that everyone has the same approaches and experiences. We we it to ourselves to be happy. That takes patience. Sometimes lots of patience.
(7)
Comment
(0)
SFC Mark Merino
SFC Mark Merino
9 y
SGT Richard H. Psychology and privacy are terms that go hand in hand. The problem is that volunteers can't have their feet held to the fire if they o anything unethical (betray confidences, violate informed onsent, mandatory reporting, etc) so it is hard to even find volunteer positions. I have gone as far as to ask the OEF/OIF clinics if I could facilitate groups and that was a nogo. If I screwed up, the VA could be held liable. I continue to standby to standby.........
If I had any business sense, this would be a no-brainer.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SFC Mark Merino
SFC Mark Merino
9 y
MAJ Matthew Arnold I am very sorry about your friend. When I was getting help in CA, the Vietnam vets made up the majority of the population and were much better sources of inspiration for my recovery than the counselors. They told me something that will stick with me forever. "We have 50 years experience of what NOT to do when it comes to living with PTS(D)." Vietnam veteran Respect!
(0)
Reply
(0)
SFC Mark Merino
SFC Mark Merino
9 y
The VA won't pay for anything past the masters level. I'm ineligible for student loans. I've peaked.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Cpl Lisa Wolford
Cpl Lisa Wolford
9 y
There are peer to peer veteran programs in some non government programs. The At Ease program in Nebraska provides peer to peer support counseling. They help veterans and their families deal with PTSD, no drugs. No connection to the VA or the government so if someone is still active duty it doesn't impact their career. I have been on the board since it started in 2008. Truly one of the best organizations I know. They have a software program that they are developing that if the studies and evidence are correct, over time the symptoms of PTSD will go away. There is hope on the horizon. And yes I know probably most of you aren't in Nebraska but everything and everyone starts somewhere.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close