Posted on Aug 17, 2016
How detrimental is the ridiculous amount of web-based training to the new generation of "Soldier"?
10.1K
18
22
5
5
0
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 11
A Soldier would have an Associates by the time they hit PFC if all those online certs were worth credits...
(3)
(0)
Web based training isn't ideal, however it is inexpensive and much better than nothing at all. It should also be pointed out that not all web based training is equal, some of the training is "game based" and requires thoughtful interaction with the program.
(2)
(0)
CW2 (Join to see)
I believe that a Soldiers' future is an investment. Spending less money elsewhere, such as the billions of dollars we are pissing away in Africa, would open more funds to be allocated to the maturation of our military. I keep hearing that it is a different color of money but that does not concern me. Someone needs to undoubtedly audit where all of our tax dollars are going. Many , if not all of us, will not be pleased. Thanks for your comments Battle!
(0)
(0)
Lt Col John (Jack) Christensen
Disagree with concept that we are pissing away dollars in Africa. In the 80s I had just arrived at HQUSCENTCOM, actually still living in TLF, when we evacuated a group of Jews from Sudan (Sudan in our AOR then). Operation cost millions but it was a vital humanitarian mission. Lots of criticism about why money given to CENTCOM to conduct mission. Point is that back then CENTCOM was considered a back water command and we shouldn't be wasting money on them; guess who gets funding at the blink of an eye today? Same rational applies to Africa, you never know where the next hot spot will be and every dollar spent in a particular AOR is well spent in the long run.
(1)
(0)
SSG (Join to see)
We could abandon the region to competing Chinese and Russian interests, I'm not certain that would be wise though...
(0)
(0)
My impression and experience is that the military trains its personnel via a mixture of live, virtual, and simulated settings and chooses those mechanisms according to multiple factors e.g., what is the quickest and most verifiable way to train SAPR so that you can assure Congress that everyone has been exposed to its definition of Sexual harassment and the same best practices for shutting it down? If commanders and other leaders want to give that training personally there is nothing preventing them from doing so... other than training days and locations, proper certifications and expertise, and 100% synchronous availability of the training audience. In my opinion the option to deliver this material in a familiar, asynchronous, emotionally compelling , consistent and precise virtual module makes a lot of sense when you compare it to the cost of alternatives. It's not like service members will stop complaining about this if they get it from a live person in their chain of command giving the training. There is the same opportunity for service members to sit through and ignore or to get differing levels of training in a live setting. I don't mean to entirely dismiss your argument here. Maybe there is a bettter balance to be struck or an innovation to be explored. Like if you get the training live you can go two years between certifications. Or if you watch a documentary and write an OPED on an issue like why the problems of suicide and sexual harassment are still plaguing our profession then you can opt out of the next several courses. Maybe we should produce "after school specials" and put them on Netflix so that personnel are as entertained as they are educated. Anyway thanks for raising the issue. It's clear that there is something wrong here with the way this is coming across to the training audience. So something needs to change.
(1)
(0)
CW2 (Join to see)
I am loving the Netflix idea Sir! Maybe we should embed them into Call of Duty or Grand Theft Auto? Thank you for your views on the subject. It is always nice to see our Senior Leadership involved in the concerns of our ranks.
(0)
(0)
Lt Col John (Jack) Christensen
Spot on Col Thibodeaux. I was only in the formative years of computer based training, as it was called then, while in the military. It was obvious that there are pluses and minuses to this method of training even then but the one thing it guaranteed was standardization of training. The live person in the chain of command you mention doesn't guarantee this which is why I think so much training in both military and civilian worlds has gone to web/computer based training.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next