Posted on Feb 21, 2020
How do we create more appealing (but also true) stories of the military for the masses?
3.56K
24
21
5
5
0
I was recently reading a great post by SFC James J. Palmer IV aka "JP4" regarding ways and reasons people dislike the military and I commented on his thread. At the end of my comment, I asked this question. He gave me the idea to start a new discussion, and I ran with it. There are many reasons people do not like the military. Some are people that have served and had bad experiences; others are people that have never served but have an idea in their head. The media often does not help, as they tend to sell negative stories, as negative stories get the most views. So, how do we shift the focus to the positive?
Posted 6 y ago
Responses: 6
IN my opinion and from my experience the greatest thing we can do is to treat our Soldiers with dignity and respect. Let's help them set themselves up for success. All of us at one point or another leave the military, whether its after our first enlistment or after a retirement or anywhere in between. If we teach, train, and mentor, and allow Soldiers ample time within preset rules and regulations to prepare themselves for life after the Military, Soldiers will be the best Advertisement we can get. When they get out and back into our communities they will be the first ones to explain to those around them what a great experience they had serving our great country. This is not fool proof, there are Soldier that have no business ever serving, and those we wont be able to reach. But for those other 99% that serve honorably, treat with dignity and respect and our image will be a lot better than it is. Just an old recent retiree's observation.
(4)
(0)
MSG (Join to see)
LTC (Join to see) - hahahaha, and why i retired even though eligible for SGM and had no desire to deal with it anymore.
(0)
(0)
LTC (Join to see)
MSG (Join to see) I'm not countimg down the days to retirement but my retirement date is 23MAR2022
(0)
(0)
(1)
(0)
LTC (Join to see)
MSG (Join to see) I ETSed almost exactly 2 years ago with 17 years active service and it was fantastic, best decision ive made in my career. Unfortunately i didn't get all the way out and they pulled me back in. This month i hit sanctuary though, so i have that going for me.
(0)
(0)
Get to know the journalists; earn their respect and give them good stories. CPT Wayne Price
(2)
(0)
I feel that Americans find value and pride in their nations ability to be a standard of good in the world. Telling stories of how we are assisting other nations rebuilding efforts, fighting alongside and supporting smaller states against terrorism, and leading humanitarian efforts would go a long way to help negative perceptions people may have.
(1)
(0)
LTJG Stephanie Thompson
SSG Carlos Madden yes! I agree...I think that even those on active duty don't hear these stories enough, much less the population at large. Thank you for sharing!
(1)
(0)
you might have to start your own blog, or write a book or screenplay of your own. A lie gets around the world before the truth gets his pants on, sadly - and people prefer the negative stories. Dirty laundry sells. Feel good stuff is forgotten fast, like the taste of a cookie, it doesn't last in memory. You just think of the calories and the guilt afterward.
(1)
(0)
LTJG Stephanie Thompson
PO1 M. Chandler you may be right, and you have my mental wheels turning, in any case. That seems to be the way of it...if I want the stories to get out there, I may have to tell them myself. Thank you for responding!
(1)
(0)
(1)
(0)
LTJG Stephanie Thompson Great post! We can contact new stations/reporters with newsworthy stories for them to report on that cast the military/veteran community in a good light. There are many such instances that go unreported and this needs to change.
(1)
(0)
What makes a story "appealing"? Is it being able to identify with the leading characters, plot, and resolution? In that sense, maybe we can't adequately relate our stories to those who have no context to fully understand them. Perhaps it's about educating those without that context. If so, then we should avoid diluting the facts, romanticizing the experience, or downplaying the consequences. Then again, it's possible that what we're really getting at here, is that not all stories are, or ever can be "positive'...and maybe that's acceptable as well.
(0)
(0)
LTJG Stephanie Thompson
Fair enough, LCDR Joshua Gillespie . I agree that not all stories can or will be positive. Not all stories are feel good stories, nor should they be. Perhaps I should offer clarity regarding my take on "appealing stories" in this instance. I am referring to the media generally sharing negative stories as news stories, rather than considering positive stories about the military to be as newsworthy. As you mentioned, perhaps "we can't adequately relate our stories to those who have no context to fully understand them," but this is just as applicable to negative news/stories as it is to positive news/stories. Just because the masses may not fully understand the context of the positives we experience does not mean we ought not to still share them. The general feel for the military for those who haven't served may improve, even if just to a greater curiosity on their part, if/when we share the good things that we do, rather than just the not-so-good things.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next

Stories
