Posted on Nov 15, 2018
If you are hurt bad enough to be med boarded, why doesn't that qualify as having a medical issue that hinders weight loss?
6.68K
23
22
2
2
0
Why is it that if you are hurt bad enough to be med boarded that it doesn't qualify as a medical issue that would hinder weight loss. What I'm getting at is if you have limitations to what you can do and you take away the amount of exercise you can do limited through pain it's a problem. When you go from exercising constantly and eating to maintain the workout then just suddenly stop 3/4 of what you normally do without seeing nutritionists to help the change your body will almost go into store mode?....or what's your thoughts please
Posted 7 y ago
Responses: 8
This will get more attention if you add the actual question to replace "AR600-9 question?".
(3)
(0)
With lack of exercise the body will store up fat cells, need to watch what you eat, and try to do some exercise.
(3)
(0)
It's a legitimate question. I steadily gained weight the last few years I was in because past injuries were making daily PT difficult. I did what I could to counter the gain by significantly changing my diet but in the end the injuries were winning. By being recommended to a medical board, the Army is recognizing that your ailments could effect your ability to serve, especially if exceeding the height/weight standard is a symptom of the injury.
(2)
(0)
You can and should request a nutrition consult. The question is regarding Body Composition and exercise. While exercise is one contributing factor, it is not the major one. Diet is the primary factor. If you are not able to be as active as before your injury/illness that doesn't prevent you from limiting your caloric intake. It also usually doesn't mean you can't do anything. You have to do what you can and be careful with your caloric intake.
(1)
(0)
I'll be honest, the way you 0brased your question was super confusing. But since you said it's a 600-9 question, here is what I know. Upon being placed I to the Army Body Composition Program, you WILL see a nutritionist, that is not an option. You will also be given a hand out to read about nutrition.
If you have a legitimate medical problem you can not be chaptered while in the program. When entered into to the program you will be counseled by your commander, then is the time to tell them if there is a medical problem that has not been previously resolved and they can involve the PA.
Hope this answered your question.
If you have a legitimate medical problem you can not be chaptered while in the program. When entered into to the program you will be counseled by your commander, then is the time to tell them if there is a medical problem that has not been previously resolved and they can involve the PA.
Hope this answered your question.
(1)
(0)
PV2 (Join to see)
This is the actual portion I'm referring to cause it has cost me 2 promotions that I've worked my butt off for.....I see it as the initial flag was not done correctly so it should be expunged and the promotions should be reinstated to their dates
(0)
(0)
MSG (Join to see)
PV2 (Join to see) nothing you can do about it, it's right next to where you circled. You will be enrolled in the ABCP as required. That requires a flag.
They can't chapter you so release the stress and focus on getting better.
They can't chapter you so release the stress and focus on getting better.
(1)
(0)
PV2 (Join to see)
I know about the chapter and I am doing the best I can to recover I just felt like my hard work was wasted...I can careless about the money..i proved myself to my peers and my leaders I work hard just wanted my shield to prove it I guess ...its all good thanks for the help and your time SFC
(0)
(0)
There is no medical issue that will exempt you from meeting height and weight standards. There are certain medical issues that the provider is allowed to recommend a specific amount of time to be rectified before you are capable of meeting height and weight. For instance, if you have hypothyroidism, you are allowed a certain amount of time until the medication is dialed in to the correct level and you are expected to meet height and weight. In this case, you need the medication in order to make height and weight. If you are injured, you are so capable and physical activity, and reducing caloric intake.
If someone is unable to meet height and weight because of their medical condition, they will be separated under a medical board. The same thing applies if a person is injured so much that they are unable to perform and unable to meet height and weight standards, they will be separated under Medical Board.
Just because someone finds it harder to keep weight off while they are injured, that is not a justification for a medical separation.
If someone is unable to meet height and weight because of their medical condition, they will be separated under a medical board. The same thing applies if a person is injured so much that they are unable to perform and unable to meet height and weight standards, they will be separated under Medical Board.
Just because someone finds it harder to keep weight off while they are injured, that is not a justification for a medical separation.
(0)
(0)
PV2 (Join to see)
There is a little more to my case than I said but I'm trying to get help for my injury and do the best I can I've never been one for excuses and at 33 dont I tend to start thanks for your input SFC
(0)
(0)
SFC (Join to see)
PV2 (Join to see) you didn't ask a question about your case, you asked why an injury doesn't allow for exemption from 600-9. At 33 you should know how to either ask a neutral question about a policy, or ask about how your situation fits into a policy. I gave a neutral answer regarding the policy, I didn't indicate that it had anything to do with you. Conversely, you asked a loaded question under the pretense of being about policy and regulations and responded as if the answer was directed at you. At 33 you should be mature enough not to ask loaded questions or questions that are geared toward getting the answer you want to hear.
(1)
(0)
PV2 (Join to see)
SFC (Join to see) ok there is a misunderstanding I'm not arguing and I want answers not just what I wanna hear and I ask questions to see if others have had insight on certain topics and yes I should have worded it a little differently I apologize for anything came off as an insult if you knew more on what happened maybe you would think differently but I was just thanking you for giving the time to give what you knew as a SFC
(0)
(0)
PV2 (Join to see)
There is more to this than just a salad I will fill you in if you would like to hear
(0)
(0)
Read This Next

Height and Weight
ABCP
Health
Nutrition
AR 600-9
