Posted on May 28, 2014
In light of the recent scandals, what are your thoughts on military health care?
3.99K
17
19
3
3
0
In light of the recent VA scandal and now the tragedies at Womack Army Medical Center, what are your thoughts on the care you receive no matter what component or if you are a vet?
Army Ousts Commander of Hospital After Deaths: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/28/us/army-ousts-commander-of-hospital-after-deaths.html
http://www.armytimes.com/article/20140528/BENEFITS06/305280060/Fort-Bragg-hospital-chief-relieved-command
VA investigators: Delayed care is everywhere: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/05/28/va-wait-times-veterans-shinseki-inspector-general/9671241/
Army Ousts Commander of Hospital After Deaths: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/28/us/army-ousts-commander-of-hospital-after-deaths.html
http://www.armytimes.com/article/20140528/BENEFITS06/305280060/Fort-Bragg-hospital-chief-relieved-command
VA investigators: Delayed care is everywhere: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/05/28/va-wait-times-veterans-shinseki-inspector-general/9671241/
Edited >1 y ago
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 9
Although I'm not a lawyer and I've never played one on TV, I think that "relief of command" would probably the first step to any future punishment, pending a thorough investigation. My thoughts and prayers go out to those who died and their families.
It sounds as though proper infection control procedures were not used at WAMC. It could be a widespread problem, Army wide, but it could also be a localized problem as well.
It sounds as though proper infection control procedures were not used at WAMC. It could be a widespread problem, Army wide, but it could also be a localized problem as well.
(2)
(0)
SSG Genaro Negrete
I would imagine being relieved of command at that point in his career is pretty much an end to his time in the military. I find it difficult to believe any centralized selection board would pick him up for any assignment.
stranger things have happened.
stranger things have happened.
(1)
(0)
Here at Ft. Bragg, I have quite a few issues with our health care. If I go into the clinic with, oh, let's say a pain in my neck, here is the probable scenario: First, I see my assigned provider, usually a PA, who will send me for an x-ray, look at the x-ray to confirm she doesn't know what she is looking at, and refer me to a specialty clinic. I will call the referral line and leave a message because nobody ever answers. They will not call me back. I will probably call two or three more times over the course of a week without a call back until I get frustrated and file an ICE complaint on them (true story, I actually had to do it before), whereupon they will finally call me and give me an appointment to the proper clinic in a surly tone of voice. I will wait 3-6 weeks for my appointment and when I show up, I will be told that they want to do an MRI before they attempt to diagnose me. I will wait for 3-4 weeks for an open MRI appointment, which is usually at 3am or 9pm on a Saturday night. I will then have to wait 72 hours to call the specialty clinic back to make another appointment, which I will have to schedule for 3-6 weeks from then. I will finally make it back to my specialty clinic where the doctor will look at the MRI and say, "what was the problem again?" He or she will then refer me to physical therapy for 6 months and "if it still bothers you in 6 months, come back to see me." I will go to physical therapy for 6 months, return to the specialty clinic, and find that my doctor has PCSed, and I have to start from square one with the new specialist. By then, whatever was wrong with my neck will have either healed itself, or I will have become used to the pain and it won't hurt anymore (this actually happened to me when I walked around for two years with three torn tendons in my left ankle).
My wife refused to go to the doctor because it meant she would miss work a minimum of three times for even the smallest issue. The doctors throw medication at you without really taking the time to figure out what is causing the problem. It is impossible to get a same day appointment on most days, so if you don't plan ahead before you come down with the flu, you end up having to work all day without quarters or meds, which makes whatever illness you have last longer. I could go on and on, but you get the idea. I don't care that Womack is the busiest medical facility in the Army. If you know that, then hire more staff. Oh, and build a parking garage for Pete's sake!
My wife refused to go to the doctor because it meant she would miss work a minimum of three times for even the smallest issue. The doctors throw medication at you without really taking the time to figure out what is causing the problem. It is impossible to get a same day appointment on most days, so if you don't plan ahead before you come down with the flu, you end up having to work all day without quarters or meds, which makes whatever illness you have last longer. I could go on and on, but you get the idea. I don't care that Womack is the busiest medical facility in the Army. If you know that, then hire more staff. Oh, and build a parking garage for Pete's sake!
(2)
(0)
CPT (Join to see)
This is pretty much the scenario here at Madigan as well. Not to mention that you will have to go through the "try ibuprofen" approach before anything. You have to return a second time to get the ball rolling on the rest of the hilarity metioned above. You did an EXCELLENT JOB of describing the health care system to a T. Well done!
I despise the Army's approach to quarters and time off for illness. If a Soldier comes to me throwing up, I send them home with the expectation that they will go to sick call the next morning or that same day if possible. The last thing I want to do is keep a joe at work to feel miserable and to infect everyone else. Sheer stupidity.
I despise the Army's approach to quarters and time off for illness. If a Soldier comes to me throwing up, I send them home with the expectation that they will go to sick call the next morning or that same day if possible. The last thing I want to do is keep a joe at work to feel miserable and to infect everyone else. Sheer stupidity.
(0)
(0)
SFC Stephen Carden
Thanks for the comment. Think I have gone through the wringer with Womack a few times? Update: my daughter suffered a concussion about three weeks ago. The ER doc told us to take her to the concussion clinic at Womack and put in the referral. We tried three times that week to get the referral office to call us back. They just called back today, almost three weeks after the initial injury and long enough that she is asymptomatic already.
(0)
(0)
I have many opinions on the military health care system. As a former NCOIC of a physical therapy clinic I understand some of the struggles. We had times where it would be 3-4 weeks for a Soldier to be seen by a provider. We even had providers that would come in early, see patients during lunch and stay late to help decrease the wait. Because the officers over the department and the hospital didn't like Soldiers waiting to have appointments booked. We would request to hire another Physical therapist and be denied because of budget cuts. So the staff that worked there was being over worked on a daily basis. You can only be overworked for so long until patient care starts to decrease. This is a fact in any profession that after so long you get tired and start cutting corners. Hospitals need to be able to hire the staff needed to support the patient population they provide care for. Until this happens we will continue to see the same problems over and over.
As a patient in the military health care system I have seen both good care and bad care. It's sad that some providers don't care. Unfortunately unless something as serious as death happens it's difficult to terminate their employment.
As a patient in the military health care system I have seen both good care and bad care. It's sad that some providers don't care. Unfortunately unless something as serious as death happens it's difficult to terminate their employment.
(1)
(0)
CW4 (Join to see)
SFC Hoppe, You are exactly right about over working the staff and cutting corners. Right now I think this problem is only getting worse with the budget cuts and hiring freezes at some locations. I do think however that the national attention these stories are getting will help to slow the drawdown of medical employees and may even help to increase the force and create more jobs. We have already seen this with VA jobs being posted like crazy since the media caught wind of how bad everything is.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next