Posted on Feb 8, 2014
SGT Squad Leader
26.4K
202
122
10
10
0
Why do I see more and more brand new Soldiers coming to the unit with an ungrateful attitude, talking shit to NCOs, disrespecting fellow Soldiers?  
Posted in these groups: Images 20 NCOsBasic training New Soldiers
Avatar feed
Responses: 42
Capt Mark Strobl
1
1
0
The process of molding a heap of civilian clay into something the Department of Defense can call a basic soldier/airman/sailor/Marine starts at those yellow footprints at the receiving depot. Graduation from boot camp is really the start of the process --the molding continues well beyond that pass & review. Are they instilled with the same values, traditions, and discipline that forge the volumes of sea-stories defining "how rough it was?" Probably not. This isn't a review of the quality of work that their DI's did. Rather, it's a statement of how our society has migrated in their own views of success, integrity, and all the intangibles required of a good citizen (and how these values are reflected in "today's Army"). How would these kids measure up to those who have passed before? Well, I submit that I'm just as proud to call myself a veteran because of, not only those with whom I have served, but because these kids are continuing to carry our colors. This "next generation" is going to be different... just as we were defined by those who preceded us.

Good question, SFC (Join to see)!
(1)
Comment
(0)
SFC Platoon Sergeant
SFC (Join to see)
10 y
I really love your response Capt Mark Strobl.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Maurice P.
1
1
0
Edited 11 y ago
BECAUSE THE ARMY DOESNT FROM THE VERY 1ST SECOND THAT HE SEE'S A DRILL SERGEANT
PUT HIM IN A SHELL SHOCKED STATE LIKE THE MARINE CORPS DOES...................................
HE ISNT SCREAMED AT OR HIT OR HARASSED HE IS A GENTLER KINDER KIND OF PERSON WHO KNOWS NO COLLECTIVE OR SELF DISCIPLINE................SO WHEN HE SEE'S AN N.C.O HE THINKS HE'S AS GOOD AS HIM AND BETTER THAN HIS PEERS..........ARMY START KICKIN ASS TAKING NAMES AND FORGETTING POLITICAL CORRECTNESS.............................
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Shannon Howe
1
1
0

1. This topic, to me, is a dead horse and has been over-beaten and over-kicked for years. (I used to be on AKO forums and it came up ALL. THE. TIME. Just saying.) Honestly, each older generation likes to blame the newer one for being "softer/weaker" and loves to reminisce about the "good ole days." The same thing happens in the civilian sector.

 

2. Just like with personal relationships, in professional relationships, people will only do what you allow them to. Thus, if Soldiers are disrespecting their leadership, it is because it is being/has been tolerated by someone, somewhere. Many will blame this on the fact that "smoking" Soldiers is no longer acceptable, and perhaps in some cases, it is. I personally blame it on leaders that either don't care enough, or are too lazy, or not creative enough, to come up with appropriate and effective corrective training. Screaming at a PVT to "push until I'm tired" is easy and doesn't take a whole lot of thought or effort. It also isn't a guaranteed "fix" for every situation...each Soldier is different and as leaders we have to be creative and flexible enough to adjust fire in our leadership styles. Also, we have to be able to think outside the box enough to know that many times, bad behavior is a sign that something is wrong in the Soldier's personal life. We must be able to set aside our frustration long enough to take a time-out, sit down and ask the Soldier, "what's going on with you? This behavior is not like you..." Again, each Soldier and situation is different, so adjust accordingly.

(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Operations Supervisor
1
1
0
I do not tolerate it. Never have, and never will. I was brought up from a private to SGT from 1984 to 1990. I was taught by NCO's who took pride in being such. They were not about to let me, nor any other lower enlisted, be disrespectful. When I was promoted to SPEC-4 (we still had some SPEC-5s hanging around) I was told that I was 'an NCO in training'. I was to conduct myself as such, and execute the authority given to me by Uncle Sam. They coached and mentored me into becoming a leader who would coach, mentor and counsel. After a 19 year break in service, I can say from first hand experience, there has been a slight decline in our NCO corps. We need to keep each other honest, and make sure we are enforcing standards uniformly, within our command structure. My soldiers call me 'old' and 'old school' (always in a respectful manner). They know what I expect, and know that the little green whistle will come out for some quick and decisive corrective action should they exhibit conduct unbecoming a soldier in our beloved army. As a reservist, it seems like "Ground Hogs Day" at times. Usually after our PT formation, which is something they had to get used to, they're in the groove. The best advice I've ever had was to "Live by the four C's Miozzi. Courage, Competence, Candor and Commitment. You'll never go wrong." 'Competence is my watchword'. Carry on.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPT Mike M.
1
1
0

Escallation of force.

 

On the spot correction

corrective training

counseling

higher counseling

Co grade Art. 15

FG Art. 15

 

It's a long process but if some people are too thick headed to learn, then there are ways of removing them from service without them ever doing anything drastic.  It falls under patterns of misconduct but you've got to get a solid paper trail to show that every effort was made to retrain the individual.

(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG (ret) William Martin
3
1
2
Edited 12 y ago
Smoke them into submission. Wow, I got a thumbs down.  Let the butt hurt start time now.
(3)
Comment
(2)
1SG Alan Bailey
1SG Alan Bailey
12 y
Always remember; punishment has to fit the crime.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SFC UH-60 Helicopter Repairer
SFC (Join to see)
12 y
there is a lack of respect but there is also a lack of Leaders earning respect
(1)
Reply
(1)
SFC 1st Sergeant
SFC (Join to see)
12 y
SSG Martin, I'm with you! 

There is nothing wrong with a good smoking from time to time. It builds character. I was smoked ruthlessly, by NCO and evil E-4s…it made me stronger. 

I'm going to upset some people here, but….

The problem I'm seeing is too many NCO's leaders are treating  there jr. EM's like equals. Those Joes's have to earn my respect as well. Some 19 year old PV2 fresh out OSUT is not the equal of a SPC with a deployment under his belt. Darn sure not the equal of Tabbed, SGT with multiple deployments and years of experience. 

That 19 year old PFC... I don't care if hurt his feeling or his self-esteem. I will make him into disciplined soldier who will do his job under fire, who will not fail his comrades, who will complete his mission even if he is the lone survivor. 

Where are the most disciplined soldiers in the Army?  The Ranger Regiment & the Airborne units. These guys are cutting edge, tip of the spear and they do not tolerate nonsense from some cherry Private with a sense of entitlement. Their NCO's are physically, mentally tough who maintain high standards.

We are still a Army at war, we need to maintain that attitude. Because while DoD is preparing for garrison our enemies are getting ready for war. Molly-coddling these jr. Enlisted is not doing them a favor, it sets them up for failure, it means somebody is going home in a body-bag. 



(1)
Reply
(0)
SSG (ret) William Martin
SSG (ret) William Martin
12 y
SFC Attardi, I am a very effective leader.  I believe you over analyzed my statement as it is more of a figure of speech.  Every soldier is different thus not one soldier may respond to the same leadership I apply to another soldier.  As I get to know a soldier on a personal and professional level I will learn what works and what does not work.  I have yet to PT a soldier into submission because of inboardination but if I needed to, I would not hesistate to a have a soldier(s) to do a few low impact exercises in cadence.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Recruiter
1
1
0
Simply because their leadership allows it. Soldiers are a direct reflection of their leadership.  Don't be one of the Soldiers that is quick to throw the NCO Corp under the bus as the only ones who set standards and make corrections.  You as a Specialist will have great influence over the way the lower ranking Soldiers in your unit act and present themselves.  Soldiers need to police each other up and correct one another there may not always be an NCO around. Leading Soldiers doesn't start the day you pin on stripes.
(1)
Comment
(0)
SSG Cannon Crew Member
SSG (Join to see)
12 y
.. as much as I agree, the only and I stress only thing I do not like that about the whole "direct reflection" statement. Is that sometimes you are given a Soldier who has either no desire to do right, or their previous leadership have all failed them. You can only do so much for someone who wont help themselves... But I had a particular Soldier like that when I arrived in Korea. One of our PSG's tried to pull that "direct reflection" b.s. but before he could complete the sentence I finished it saying (direct reflection) "of the leadership before me"... It wasn't my fault the guy was how he was, but I worked with him and helped him get squared away until he ETS'd.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SrA Michael Waldo
1
1
0
This is essentially the same question as "Why are kids becoming so unruly and ignorant." Each generation is shaped by the generation proceeding it. I was raised by my grandfather for the most part. He was a combat vet of WWII with tours in the pacific, and the eldest of 16 children, from a rural area of West Virginia that probably still doesn't have a name. He taught me to appreciate everything I had, make use of everything (He was the original "MacGyver"), do what your elders tell you to do unless you have a suggestion as to a better way of doing it (and it had better be feasible), learn everything you can about any and everything (knowledge is free and is the greatest weapon one can have in their arsenal, never take that for granted), and treat others the way you want to be treated (99% of the time you won't get the respect in return that you give, but it shouldn't thwart you from being a decent human being). This didn't pan out well for me growing up in Orlando, FL where I was surrounded with nothing but over indulgent, ignorant, spoiled brats. But I would rather be an outcast for being courteous and respectful than join the masses of undeserving sociopaths. 

The current generation of NCO's are usually around my age group with different upbringings. Apathy and a rude demeanor is just becoming the norm among the populous. My buddies always tell me how shitty their troops are and how too can't fathom how kids could get even more out of control. You can place blame on their upbringing, their influences, or both. Either way, even if the next generation was to become polar opposites in demeanor, my generation will condescend them for being "weenys" for showing empathy, compassion, and respecting their elders and peers. The only option is to lead by example. NCO's aren't supposed to keep a boot in the ass of all the lower ranks; the E-4's are supposed to keep order among the E-3's and so on and so forth. It's the duty of the E-4 nowadays to take the brunt of a verbal assault and knife hand from the NCO's. In return, you should accept the responsibility for the ineptitude of your peers and if you're not a jackass or a shit bag; the lower ranks will take notice that you man up and take your lashings in stride; while remaining composed, disciplined, and rife with integrity. And those capable of thinking critically will follow the leader. The shit bags will probably get promoted meritoriously for something they didn't do, but....fuck 'em haha.
(1)
Comment
(0)
SGT Squad Leader
SGT (Join to see)
12 y
Hey now I'm from the 407 AKA Orlando and I turn out to be just fine haha, but ye I understand what you said.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Senior Warrior Liaison
1
1
0

hmmmm,


 


This comes up quite often. So i have a question for you SPC, what do you do to encourage your peers to act appropriately?


 


As an NCO i do encounter those soldiers who are, for a lack of a better word, a hassle to deal with. However, saying that, those i've trained and earned respect with (the good respect) often jump into the misunderstood soldier before i even need to. Could i go back to the pre 9/11 way of thinking and start "corrective training" and making life awfully painful for everybody. Sure, but the army now teaches critical thinking and developing different ways to address issues. Maybe you could look at these soldiers as a leadership challenge for when you become part of the backbone.


 

(1)
Comment
(0)
SGT Squad Leader
SGT (Join to see)
12 y
I usually sit down and have a long talk with the Soldiers and trying to understand their background and go from there. I'm a big fan of communication but sometimes I don't might corrective training.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Cryptologic Linguist
1
1
0
In addition to NCOs in general allowing it to happen, I also believe a lot of it is due in part to the current IET environment. While I can't speak for basic training, having reclassed recently I can definitely speak about AIT. Out of shape, lazy, incompetant AIT PSGs who would rather new soldiers like them than make adhere to any sort of standard. I've said it before but I'll say it again. The current IET atmosphere needs a complete re-haul. 
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close