Posted on Jan 17, 2017

President Obama commutes Chelsea (Bradley) Manning's sentence. What precedent does this set?

LTC (Join to see)

80.1K

417

209

Posted in these groups: Handcuffs 2249048b

Punishment Original

Crime

Justice

Barack Obama

Edited >1 y ago

Posted >1 y ago

Follow this discussion

Responses: 90

LTC Kevin B.

Posted >1 y ago

I'm not overly bothered by this. From what I've been able to quickly find on the web, there have only been a handful of similar leak cases, and most of the sentences are only a few years. His/her sentence was already an extreme outlier (35 years), and it still will be an outlier after the commutation (7 years). It's not like Manning was pardoned.

(24)

Comment

(0)

show previous comments

Sgt Joseph Baker

>1 y

Sgt Jamie Grippin - I think you are mixing him up with Edward Snowden. This guy did it because he was unhappy with the Army.

(0)

Sgt Joseph Baker

>1 y

SGT Alfredo Alcazar - I just loved how the LGBT champions turned his conviction into one of their causes. The guy wasn't put in prison for being gay, it was for engaging in espionage.

(3)

(0)

SGT Alfredo Alcazar

>1 y

Sgt Joseph Baker - You are absolutely right and I agree with you. Anyway as long as he/she get a dishonorable discharge it's ok if Barack commute his/her sentence.

(0)

MAJ Seth Goldstein

7 y

I could not agree more.

(0)

MSG (Join to see)

Posted >1 y ago

To be released in 5 months? OH FFS!!!! Sparky better have a damn plane ticket to a hole in the wall third world country and be taken right to the airport.....because there is no place in this country he will be safe. As soon as some crazy civilian and/or veteran finds out where he lives.....not going to be pretty.

(20)

Comment

(0)

show previous comments

SGT Alfredo Alcazar

>1 y

I agree if someone find out where he lives he'll be dead meat.

(2)

(0)

CPL Arthur White

7 y

Confused? It is also defined as mental illness. What did its kind do before medical technology allowed gender reassignment ? They just lived as they were ! Ridiculous !

(0)

SCPO Don Baker

7 y

SPC Johnny Velazquez, PhD - And a good one it is, Spc.

(0)

PVT Mark Brown

7 y

He does not deserve the freedom to enjoy a life as a citizen of the United States of America. If it were in my power and he did indeed go free I would see to it that he was exiled for life in Iraq of Afghanistan.

(0)