Should a Soldier be put on reconditioning pt for looking overweight, knowing the reg?

"Should a Soldier be put on reconditioning pt for looking overweight, knowing the reg?"
Those are completely different things..
Your commander can observe you look overweight and direct you be tape tested to see if your in compliance. If you are, no action taken, if you are not, you should be entered into the Army's Overweight program

Soldiers recovering from injury, illness or other medical conditions will be in reconditioning program...

Soldiers who fail the APFT or other unit physical readiness goals will continue participation in regular PRT sessions with the unit.

ARMY WEIGHT CONTROL PROGRAM

AR 350-1 specifies that the AWCP will be kept separate and distinct from other special conditioning programs. Soldiers who fail to meet AR 600-9 standards will be enrolled in the AWCP and continue participation in regular unit PRT sessions. They should also participate in additional low impact, caloric expenditure activities.

Looking overweight and being overweight are not always the same thing. I knew several Soldiers that looked overweight but passed tape every time. As long as they passed tape, I never pushed the issue. I know you can add to the standard, but in doing so in this instance you run the risk of alienating that Soldier and losing their respect (as a leader not your rank and position). Many would view such a move as being singled out for no reason since they met the standard.

Everyone looks different, I remember in boot camp there was a fellow recruit who looked fat and even the tape test said he was overweight but medical tested him and found he had a lower body fat percentage than any of us. You work that guy out more he's going to "look" even more overweight.