Should military members, retirees, or civilians supporting the military lose their pay if the government shuts down?

They won't lose their pay ultimately. I guess the better question is should soldiers and Federal government employees be forced to wait to get paid down the road? I say no! Creditors don't care about a government shut down. They want to get paid on time! It could effect your credit score or credit card rate permanently! Wake up Congress!!!!

Government shut down is a political term. The government doesn't run out of money on 1 October...they still collect income taxes, social security taxes and businesses still pay their quarterly taxes. Not to mention, only non-essential personnel are told to stay home. Essential people still come to work. Honestly...we could save a lot of money if we just cut non-essential people anyway. The government will still sun on 1 October regardless of what happens, they will collect taxes, they will still have TSA, so on and so on. Some of the "painful" stuff that shuts down only shuts down to make it hurt, not because it can't be supported. So to answer your question...no, they should not lose their pay.

To a certain extent we have to, or what is the point in a shut down? Do I think we "should?" absolutely not, but I don't agree with a shutdown in any capacity anyways.

Continuing resolutions and shutdowns typically end up costing more money in the long run than they save immediately. They are a political stunt/requirement, not a real solution to anything.