Toxic Threads, Should they be removed?

SSG G,

I am referring to the thread on "Veterans or Soldiers targeting our President", and the vile banter back and forth by the PO1 and the SGT who have turned the original discussion post into their personal vendettas towards each other and their views, once it gets to that level it is time to step back and if necessary remove the thread, but the SPC who originally when he posted the question was a PFC has not only let the thread go in the direction it has, he has at times encouraged the visceral banter between the two, it has been taken completely out of the original concept and purpose of the discussion that was why I forwarded the info to the admin for further review, now it is up to them to validate whether further actions need to be taken in reference to the issue.

I do think we need to have a better professionalism on the site even though many are veterans and retirees, we are all held to a higher expectation as former service members as well, and attacking another SM or veteran because you don't see eye to eye on politics or views is not showing that professionalism or maturity.

I personally don't support or believe in most of what the current POTUS has done or conceived during his administration, but I respond respectfully to the office, the old saying of I musts respect the office/rank even if I don't respect the person. Being retired I have a little more latitude with my personal views and feelings, but I also still have the core values and home taught values to be respectful even if I disagree with someone.

I have had to bring to the attention of a few junior and senior NCOs to myself that they are riding that fine line that is all about perception to the holder of disrespect and they may want to rethink their verbiage and reactive comments to one another.

Yeah SSG Baber you did and you were correct and also with the idea that some huge problem might underlie their rooms condition.    As you alluded to,  an attempted suicide.   Let's face it,  there is no where to go where you have totally privacy and many just go off base and stay there until they go to work.

SPC Buck,

By your actions of the down vote to the comment that mentioned your name, you just validated my statement about the maturity level, instead of looking into the issue and problem mentioned and there is a very severe one within your thread content, never stated your thread question was the issue, but the context of some of the replies, you decided to act emotionally and responded the same.

You have not even paid attention to anything that anyone has said in regards to the topic question at hand, disagreeing and communication are well worked methods utilized by mature, educated people without being retaliatory against the other individual.

Perfect example, SFC Gates and myself have different views on this present topical discussion, but we have not attacked each other verbally or down voted one another because of our disagreeing views, we have both stated our opinions and feelings appropriately and articulated our divers thoughts on the subject and we still can communicate and participate in other discussions positively with no issues, we can even have virtual beer together to have a healthy discussion on topics not covered in the forum.

We are both old school Soldiers who don't always agree with the powers that be or the direction that it may be leading us, but we followed our orders and ensured the safety and security of our Soldiers 1st and foremost while accomplishing the mission, and while I think we both followed somewhat the same path near retirement, our outspokenness probably prevented us from being far more advanced in our ranks as we would have liked, it is also what made us the great NCOs we were to our leadership we had at the time of our retirements, and we both also knew when and how to talk and comment on topics tactfully and respectfully whether in or out of uniform. Being that we both have a lot more latitude to be more open with our opinions and voices, we also still have the maturity and knowledge of being tactful and respectful to those we are either addressing about a subject or responding to an individual such as yourself or someone we may not see eye to eye, and we maintain the professional manner that it should have within a professional network environment as this.

You could take some great lessons from both this thread and the thread that you started and encouraged as well, it just depends on what and which lessons you wish to learn and garner that shows what level you are at or can attain. I hope you have and enjoyable week and wish you much luck in your future.

SFC M.

Not trying to be disrespectful or bust your bubble, double check or utilize the edit button from time to time.  Standers should standards at least twice above, c'mon now we are seniors setting the standards for our junior Soldiers to emulate.  But on another note I do agree with what you were trying to convey.