Posted on Jul 18, 2018
SPC Healthcare Specialist (Combat Medic)
17.4K
34
18
5
5
0
Between Infantry, artillery, air defense artillery, armor, and engineer, which branch is the best to commission into and why? I had a 300 on the apft and even ran the Bataan Memorial Death March marathon with a 40 pound ruck. I recently had a compound fracture with my left femur and now I'm not sure how a ruck will feel although I am expected to make a full recovery. I plan on switching from guard to active duty when I commission and staying in 20 years. I am open to hearing the pros and cons to these branches and keep in mind I will have a pretty good idea of how my leg has healed by the time I submit which branches I want. Listing the branches in order of rucking the least to rucking the most will also be appreciated.
Posted in these groups: Engineers regimental insignia 12B: Combat Engineer
Edited 6 y ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 13
CPO Steelworker
6
6
0
Engineer then SAPPER, but that's because I worked with them all the time, if you want to bl0ow stuff up and get blown up go Combat Engineer and get a SAPPER tab. Remember first to breach the way..
(6)
Comment
(0)
CSM Command Sergeant Major
CSM (Join to see)
>1 y
I am an old Infantry CSM... My BC is an Engineer w a SAPPER tab as is my XO... I am odd man out... We have interesting debates on this all of the time. Join the INFANTRY and get a real short tab.... Then go to "Q" course if you want to chew nails. Just my .02 since you asked.
(1)
Reply
(0)
CPO Steelworker
CPO (Join to see)
>1 y
CSM (Join to see) - Had a Major that was on my Joint Task Force in Iraq he was on a Short tour, Engineer with real Short tab, but missed the SAPPER by a couple minutes..
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Christopher Hayden
3
3
0
Infantry or bust. Anything else makes you a POG, and that's a very POG thing to do.
(3)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Tony Clifford
2
2
0
It all depends on how you feel about signing for equipment and how much you hate walking. Obviously tankers ruck the least followed by air defense, artillery, engineers, infantry for obvious reasons does the most. Don't take this to mean that you won't be rucking in as a tanker, you absolutely will. As far as equipment you'll be responsible for as a PL, they go in ascending order from infantry to tanker with the exception of engineers, who generally have a bunch of equipment some of which is considered to be significant brigade assets (Volcanoes, MICLIC). Then there's the type of work. Obviously an officer isn't going to really do the vehicle maintenance, but the amount of maintenance required for equipment and the equipment you will have will dictate how much of your units time you'll have for training and the type of training that you will get. Non-mechanized infantry and engineers do less vehicle maintenance than armorn artillery and ada, but that's assuming that you don't get assigned to a mechanized unit. If you do, it will be comparable. Lastly, you should consider the ease of advancement. Fields that are smaller usually have issues with advancing.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
Avatar feed
Which branch in the Army is the best combat arms branch to commission into?
LTC Stephen Conway
2
2
0
A word to the wise, I Lieutenant Colonel that I knew did not make it to Colonel because he had only armor and no other functional area like civil affairs. I knew another armor officer who made full-bird Colonel but he had SSC out of the way. I would suggest you get into some other functional area like civil Affairs as a backup because armor is pretty picky the higher rank you go.
(2)
Comment
(0)
CSM Command Sergeant Major
CSM (Join to see)
>1 y
CABN is an excellent way to see the World.... Some great places... Some not so great. I lost a couple of good friends in a CABN....
(2)
Reply
(0)
LTC Stephen Conway
LTC Stephen Conway
>1 y
I totally empathize with you, sergeant major, I lost my first sergeant when I was a captain in civil affairs. This is one week before he came back home. It was a closed casket ceremony because it was a suicide car bomber with accelerants. Blue Rowe was a young first sergeant but I'm sure he would have made SGM or CSM. I recall him bringing a 7 year old son to drill and my wife met his wife at the 2008 dining out at March Air Force Base.

http://projects.latimes.com/wardead/name/blue-c-rowe/
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Waarng G1 3
1
1
0
I would consider either 11A or 19A as they share a lot similarities. After you finish your first duty station and complete you company XO time you will go to MCCC.

MCCC is for both Infantry and Armor branch Officers. You will also be able to attend the same schools which is highly encouraged to attend.
ARC, RSLC, Ranger, Air Assault, Path Finder, and Airborne.

Additional schools you can go to Infantry: MLC Mortar Leaders Course and Armor: CLC Cavalry Leaders Course.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Mark Halmrast
1
1
0
Rucking least to most.
- all others
- grunts
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Stephen Conway
1
1
0
I am preferential to armor since it was ignored for so long. But now that we know that the President Obama peace dividend is in the toilet, we need to rearm our forces and armor is relevant. It's really sad when you have the Idaho Army National Guard that was once an enhanced Brigade but 116th cab Brigade which I went to to Iraq, is now a mechanized infantry Brigade. That is so messed up. We need to emphasize Armour again so I would say for the good of the cause, go armor!
(1)
Comment
(0)
CSM Command Sergeant Major
CSM (Join to see)
>1 y
My secondary MOS is 11M.... (BFV).. GOOD times during Desert Storm....
The only thing ARMOR is good for is warming the INFANTRY SOLDIERS in the Winter... ;)
Loved standing behind the M1A1 Abrams back in the day... Can I get an AMEN..?
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Robert Hendrickson
0
0
0
Your preference..remember your injury/etc. Be the best in your decision..bless you.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPT Terrence Ryan
0
0
0
Engineers lead the way!
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Squad Leader
0
0
0
You'll ruck a lot as an engineer, it's expected. Blowing stuff up is the reward though. As an officer you'll definitely want to attend Sapper school. There's a lot of other demo classes you can attend too. Being a 12B is considered a combat job too so you'll be allowed to attend several other tab schools
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close