219
219
0
It should come as no surprise to anyone who has spoken with me or read some of the other pieces that I have had the privilege of posting that education is something that I feel extremely passionate about. In fact, I would go so far as to say that education ranks right up there with my passion for writing, service to my country, and love for the Constitution of the United States and everything that it provides. Why exactly would education rank so high up there in things that I value? Simply put, education is the basic foundation for those other things that I have listed. Without a proper education, one is unable to utilize the written word. Without a proper education, one cannot properly serve in any branch of the military or law enforcement (contrary to popular belief). Lastly, and most importantly, without a proper education, one is unable to understand, abide by, and protect the Constitution of the United States; this fact seems ever more evident by the masses of ignorant young people and their radically unhinged and politically motivated leadership.
I previously wrote a piece that really maligned what has so far been my experience at a university. I could go on to elaborate even further about the shortfalls of the college education provided in this country, possibly for eternity, but I would rather take aim at a different aspect of our education system. As previously stated, young people show up ill-prepared for what they should be expected to do once they arrive at college. Why is this? Well, we can point fingers at government regulations (ie “No Child Left Behind”), or ‘teaching to tests’, or funding, and, in all honesty, any one of these could very well be accurately blamed for one negative aspect of our system or another. What about just the people teaching our kids?
We hear all the time about the professors at universities but it is very seldom that we look at the people at the elementary, middle, and high school levels – unless there happens to be a scandal involving sexual misconduct (which is an issue of a whole other kind) – but take a moment to think about these people.
I am going to speak in generalities. Young people these days have little to no discipline, no work ethic, believe that they should receive unearned benefits and or rewards, and seem to have the worst time regulating their emotions (so much so that “trigger warnings” have become common practice in many places). Who can the education system turn to in order to make drastic improvements to these circumstances? Why, the last time that I had an issue with any of these things was prior to my experience in basic training!
Noncommissioned officers, not just drill sergeants, are specially adapted to developing functional and well-adapted youth that are prepared to take on the difficulties associated with the real world. Day in and day out, NCOs across the military are constantly dealing with young men and women ranging in ages starting at 17; who is to say that these professionals could not adapt to perform the same miracles with young people only slightly younger? Counseling, personal and professional development, and teaching (training) are all tools that any NCO worth their salt has at their disposal. In addition, NCOs promote discipline in various ways, understand the need for proper levels of encouragement, and instill values into those under their charge. Are these not the exact qualities that we wish for our young people?
Everyone has heard the saying “those who cannot do teach”. The fact is that this has been the case for far too long. When you have a generation of people who cannot do anything, teaching kids who will in turn not be able to do anything, you end up with a large portion of a generation essentially crippled. We can see this right now. A generation of young adults looking for handouts, free stuff, and government assistance because they have been taught, for ages, by people who could barely do anything for themselves (or at least were so inept that they could do almost nothing of novel value). We have people going into disciplines like “gender studies” in which lies a future of absolutely nothing. Can anyone please tell me exactly what someone with a PhD in gender studies does for society besides teach other people who are going for a degree in that area? Of course you can’t because there is nothing. Perhaps work in some obscure fashion for the ACLU, maybe.
I believe that it is high time that people who can do, and can do many different things, teach those who we expect to do many different things. If we want young people to take up valuable professions, to be pushed towards doing things of value to themselves and society, they must first be provided with the structure that supports them to do so. Noncommissioned officers are often described as being the “backbone” of the military service (or at least in the Army they are). Could these professionals become the kind of “backbone” structure for the education system that we need? I believe so.
I previously wrote a piece that really maligned what has so far been my experience at a university. I could go on to elaborate even further about the shortfalls of the college education provided in this country, possibly for eternity, but I would rather take aim at a different aspect of our education system. As previously stated, young people show up ill-prepared for what they should be expected to do once they arrive at college. Why is this? Well, we can point fingers at government regulations (ie “No Child Left Behind”), or ‘teaching to tests’, or funding, and, in all honesty, any one of these could very well be accurately blamed for one negative aspect of our system or another. What about just the people teaching our kids?
We hear all the time about the professors at universities but it is very seldom that we look at the people at the elementary, middle, and high school levels – unless there happens to be a scandal involving sexual misconduct (which is an issue of a whole other kind) – but take a moment to think about these people.
I am going to speak in generalities. Young people these days have little to no discipline, no work ethic, believe that they should receive unearned benefits and or rewards, and seem to have the worst time regulating their emotions (so much so that “trigger warnings” have become common practice in many places). Who can the education system turn to in order to make drastic improvements to these circumstances? Why, the last time that I had an issue with any of these things was prior to my experience in basic training!
Noncommissioned officers, not just drill sergeants, are specially adapted to developing functional and well-adapted youth that are prepared to take on the difficulties associated with the real world. Day in and day out, NCOs across the military are constantly dealing with young men and women ranging in ages starting at 17; who is to say that these professionals could not adapt to perform the same miracles with young people only slightly younger? Counseling, personal and professional development, and teaching (training) are all tools that any NCO worth their salt has at their disposal. In addition, NCOs promote discipline in various ways, understand the need for proper levels of encouragement, and instill values into those under their charge. Are these not the exact qualities that we wish for our young people?
Everyone has heard the saying “those who cannot do teach”. The fact is that this has been the case for far too long. When you have a generation of people who cannot do anything, teaching kids who will in turn not be able to do anything, you end up with a large portion of a generation essentially crippled. We can see this right now. A generation of young adults looking for handouts, free stuff, and government assistance because they have been taught, for ages, by people who could barely do anything for themselves (or at least were so inept that they could do almost nothing of novel value). We have people going into disciplines like “gender studies” in which lies a future of absolutely nothing. Can anyone please tell me exactly what someone with a PhD in gender studies does for society besides teach other people who are going for a degree in that area? Of course you can’t because there is nothing. Perhaps work in some obscure fashion for the ACLU, maybe.
I believe that it is high time that people who can do, and can do many different things, teach those who we expect to do many different things. If we want young people to take up valuable professions, to be pushed towards doing things of value to themselves and society, they must first be provided with the structure that supports them to do so. Noncommissioned officers are often described as being the “backbone” of the military service (or at least in the Army they are). Could these professionals become the kind of “backbone” structure for the education system that we need? I believe so.
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 69
My take , 90% of NCOs and 50% officers are teachers. But the troop you use for VIPs ,make the best teachers
(2)
(0)
NCO's are teachers... not to be the d@ckhead LT, but maybe when talking about teaching and standards they should find an airman without a No Shave Chit... just saying...
(2)
(0)
SGT Joseph Gunderson
There is nothing that an NCO can really do about that. Perhaps docs and PAs should quit handing them out to people just to make them stop whining. A profile must be adhered to by the leadership though.
(2)
(0)
LT Brad McInnis
SGT Joseph Gunderson - I agree, I am just saying that of all the airmen they could have chosen for the picture, they chose one with a no shave chit..
(3)
(0)
It the teaching environment was more military oriented then it would be possible, if not then not much chance ... I had an opportunity to spend some time at a military academy ,observing giving advice and providing support to cadets as young as 7 on up to high school and compared to public school it was much like night n day , we all see this difference in environment daily since we ourselves have been exposed upon entering military service the discipline of the young and attitude much different...
(2)
(0)
"Everyone has heard the saying 'those who cannot do teach'. The fact is that this has been the case for far too long."
Assumption, stated as fact.
Assumption, stated as fact.
(2)
(0)
SGT Joseph Gunderson
Noted, but the entire piece is "assumption, stated as fact"... It's a personal opinion. Also, it was supposed to be read as if the fact that the saying survives has been going on too long. I could have worded that part better.
(2)
(0)
SGT Joseph Gunderson
Nevermind, I just reread the piece, I stick by what I said in it. Although a general assumption, it is one that I can point to examples for.
(1)
(0)
SSgt Bruce Probert
It is always dangerous to allow those who can't, try to teach what they don't under stand. But you don't often have some one to teach the assault who's done it a hundred times or more. The quickest way to find out where you are deficient in your ability is to try and teach it. The choice of an instructor especially in the martial arts isn't just important, learn it wrong and you are a casualty.
(1)
(0)
Suspended Profile
SGT Joseph Gunderson your description of my generation (particularly those slightly younger than me) is spot-on. Unfortunately, I feel that the biggest issue (potentially) facing American youth is the lack of a strong work ethic. Maybe this is due to life simply becoming easier on average, more “handouts”, a lack of being challenged - whatever the cause, the effect is a generally less intrinsically motivated work force (why have pride in your work if you’ve never really been challenged?), and a sense of “why should I adapt to become a better worker? Let me have my workplace, surroundings, coworkers, etc adapt to ME, so I can be more comfortable”.
Sorry, I’ll get off my soapbox now. Thanks for the share.
Sorry, I’ll get off my soapbox now. Thanks for the share.
I served as a PO2 in the Navy for four years when I recieved a medical discharge, but I have been an educator at the secondary and post-secondary level now for over 30 years. I believe that the Navy taught me some very important lessons that I still use today both in my work and in my personal life. And the most important of those lessons, Honor, Courage, and Committment. These values have become my credo. Character triats that I have always tried to demonstrate to my classes and students. And now that I am an academic advisor, these are traits that I believe I can demonstrate to my advisees as important values for work and life.
(1)
(0)
I hold an Ed.D. and have 34 years of experience as an educator. I joined the Army National Guard as soon as I got my first teaching appointment. My Drill Sergeants had far more influence on my classroom management and instructional style than my graduate professors. They taught me which things are black and white as opposed to grey and they taught me to carry on with dignity and a sense of humor.
(1)
(0)
SGT Joseph Gunderson
I'm presently working my way through an MA I hope to have finished within a year, and I'm planning on going forward to a PhD with an intent to teach. There are too few of us (veterans/SMs) participating in the education of our young people, and I believe it is really starting to show. You admitted it yourself, that your DSs effected you far greater than any professor; we need to bring the same motivation, discipline, and spirit to the classrooms, and that doesn't mean bringing Drills into the classroom, rather, the foundational principles that make those individuals so effective in their mission.
(1)
(0)
MAJ William Smith
Yes. I find that teens are hungry for reality. They know they are getting BS'd, but can't put their fingers on it because they are inexperienced with life. They are at risk of internalizing the BS and spending their lives fragile and "woke."
I don't talk about the Army or drill them. Instead, I base my instruction in reality and have a firm and non-negotiable set of lines that cannot be crossed. They seem to find that attractive rather than off-putting. This is especially true of the male students.
Of course, my subject is chemistry and that is a much easier subject to base in reality than "social studies."
I don't talk about the Army or drill them. Instead, I base my instruction in reality and have a firm and non-negotiable set of lines that cannot be crossed. They seem to find that attractive rather than off-putting. This is especially true of the male students.
Of course, my subject is chemistry and that is a much easier subject to base in reality than "social studies."
(0)
(0)
I totally agree with your assessment. Without trying to sound like a "conspiracy theorist", the dumbing down and pushing the philosophy that people should not be held accountable for their actions/ inaction is "okay" is undermining our society as a whole, the military in particular. Anyone that has a lack of integrity, shows disloyalty to the US (that does not mean those that disagree with politically "correctness", etc.) have no place in our military....PERIOD
(1)
(0)
Read This Next

Teacher
Teaching
NCO Academy
Primary Education
Leadership
