Avatar feed
Responses: 14
Cpl Joshua Caldwell
7
7
0
I have a feeling that she will work to end the dept of Edu, and that is a good thing. There is no legit reason for the fed gov to tell the states what to teach and how. Each state has their own dept of Edu and they can make their own decisions. Then we can compare the results from all 50 experiments and attempt to copy the best results
(7)
Comment
(0)
Cpl Joshua Caldwell
Cpl Joshua Caldwell
>1 y
SGT (Join to see) I have cousins in Penn Hills. That is a school that is bankrupt and on its way down. At the same time, they closed Wilkinsburg and that will help those kids a lot. Not that the city schools are good but Wilkinsburg was a drop out factory. Take Imahni (sp?) Christian in that same area, and those kids are thriving in comparison.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SFC PATRIOT Launching Station Enhanced Operator/Maintainer
SFC (Join to see)
>1 y
But PCSing to another state could set my children up for disaster. Federal standards supposedly create the baseline so a second grader in Colorado won't be destroyed with poor public education if I PCS to Oklahoma.

Obviously, on the contrary, the system is extremely broken. So perhaps I live in pipe dreams. But the point of national education is an extremely valid point to ensure America's youth become.better rounded- not just from one state.

Nine times out of ten I side with states and even counties determining their own political fates... despite those beliefs, i believe some things are national issues and should be organized on a national level - like security (the military), customs/immigration, and education.

...removing education from politics would reduce poor local/state leaders with backwards policies from limited my children's education because of political views not prioritizing educarion. I'd like to PCS knowing my children aren't going to a state (where I had no.option to vote) that will hinder them.

Yes, I can supplement poor.quality of education with my job as a parent. I already do.
Yes, the system is obviously flawed right now. Is it flawed enough to eliminate federally organized education. Perhaps a better direction is needed, as opposed to no direction- survival of the fittest schooling
(3)
Reply
(0)
SGT Team Chief
SGT (Join to see)
>1 y
Cpl Joshua Caldwell - I would say that what's happening moneywise at Penn Hills does concern me. The Auditor's report was not flattering to say the least. For background, my daughter spent her 1st and 2nd grade years at Imani Christian Academy and her 3rd and currently 4th grade year at Penn Hills. Both have their pros and cons and I honestly prefer Penn Hills for her partially because she is gifted. The private school simply did not have resources to address that. Not to say it's been perfect. 3rd grade was a nightmare behavior wise even though her grades were good. Penn Hills has more to offer in terms of academic and behavioral support than Imani, which was a major selling point for transferring to Penn Hills. And the elementary school, that has helped put them so far in debt, is impressive especially when you consider the sheer amount of students present.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Cpl Joshua Caldwell
Cpl Joshua Caldwell
>1 y
SGT (Join to see) Brother I am telling you it is time to move. I track real estate markets locally and P Hills is in big trouble, the looming tax hikes will kill property values and chase away investment and home ownership. How do you feel about Verona? I dont know much about the gifted program at Riverview but it has to be better than what I see as the future of Penn Hills.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Brigade Communications Officer (S6)
7
7
0
Edited >1 y ago
I guess home schooling is back on the table for many Americans. This is a tough one to swallow especially because most of the people who wear the uniform can not afford to send our children to private schools. (something she is a strong advocate for). The only drawback i can think of for homeschooling would be a childs ability to build a strong network and exposure to the world, especially in such a globalized world. I sincerely hope her plan is to better equip public schools, pay teachers and convince the "powers that be" that our greatest investment should be in educating our children to ensure they are competitive in the next century. And this should be a right for every child and not like buying a car. (I can afford a chevy tahoe, my boss can afford a tesla)
(7)
Comment
(0)
SGT Anna Kleinschmidt
SGT Anna Kleinschmidt
>1 y
My biggest concern is for special needs children. I am unable to have children due to my service. My husband and I adopted from foster care and our son was a drug and alcohol dependent child leaving him delayed. We have had difficulty in different areas as it is wirh getting teachers to comply with his IEP as we transferred to various duty stations but we have had the law to back us up. I am worried because if she pulls money from underfunded schools, and Sessions has made statements that he feels like children like my son are basically just in the way of other kids. What is going to happen to kids like him? This is breaking my heart.
(3)
Reply
(0)
MAJ Brigade Communications Officer (S6)
MAJ (Join to see)
>1 y
I guess my point is that in a two parent household (the reality for many Americans) where both have a career, the whole idea becomes a little difficult. I don't believe my knowledge and understanding dwarfs a paid and educated professional who is properly equipped, funded and motivated to tech my child. I do agree we need to do something to make public education better across the country.SSG(P) (Join to see) -
(0)
Reply
(0)
MAJ Brigade Communications Officer (S6)
MAJ (Join to see)
>1 y
You bring up interesting points that i actually disagree with directly. I have learned that the "networks" built in the pursuit of education are usually life long and as strong as one formed through military service or clubs like the scouts. I think a child learns the value of networks there.

As far as not everyone needs college, I agree with a Caveat. The world in 2036 would require my plumber to have a different set of skills than was required of my plumber in 1996. I think we keep trying to go back to the Industrial Age model instead of anticipating and planning for the future. Everyone does not need college, but all our kids may need to understand basic programming to be able to compete in the job markets of 2040.

We do agree that the parents need to discipline their own children so at least we agree on something. Lol Cpl Jeff N. -
(0)
Reply
(0)
Cpl Jeff N.
Cpl Jeff N.
>1 y
MAJ (Join to see) - You might be surprised at your ability to teach your child as well as many/most teachers especially in their younger years. one on one vs 25+ to one is a huge differentiator. We talk about classroom size all the time. Home schools offer the smallest of all. A lot of teaching is knowing the material and having a desire to make a difference in the kids life through education. I think you would likely posses those for your own kids.

on the college education. Skills and technology do change but much of that can be addressed through trade schools and training through employers. Think about our automobiles. They technology in them is much more significant than 30+ years ago but the mechanics (now technicians) keep up. They keep up through on going training and practical application, normally at their employer or a trade school.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Cpl Jeff N.
4
4
0
This is the one the dems thought they could stop. No such luck. Full speed ahead.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close