Posted on Mar 19, 2014
SFC Nick Freitas
2.38K
8
3
5
5
0
In an admittedly petulant manner I once slipped in this statement on a daily SITREP...<div><br></div><div>"We seem to be the only army in history that comes from a federated constitutional republic, with a relatively free market economic system that deposes &nbsp;dictatorships and immediately sets up parliamentary democracies with highly regulated, often centrally planned economies. Perhaps Iraq would benefit from a model closer to the United States with a weaker federal government and more authority over local issues handled at the provincial level"</div><div><br></div><div>Now please understand...I was an 18F, I wasn't exactly briefing the president, but I did get the obligatory, "keep your comments to matters that fall into your purview Freitas" from my Detachment Commander...only after he forwarded it to the Battalion before checking it.&nbsp;</div><div><br></div><div>In the end no harm no foul, our Battalion CDR was a great commander who appreciated bluntness from his NCO's and liked us to think outside of the box, although again...daily SITREP not the best place to wax intellectual...then again, I really thought the detachment commander would read it like he always did, give me the eye roll, and take it out. It was a bit of a game we played, to keep him honest...guess he forgot to play that day.</div><div><br></div><div>Having said all that, I stand by the statement. I do believe that in many environments, especially ones where there is significant distrust between rather large sectors of the population, allowing for greater local governance over those issues which affect day to day life, and limiting the federal governments role to national security, international relations, some infrastructure, etc. can alleviate social tensions.&nbsp;</div><div><br></div><div>In addition, policies such as privatizing the oil industry in Iraq and giving each citizen a share of the oil wealth in the form of stock as a condition of sale would assist in preventing control of oil wealth by the central government as a tool with which to punish enemies and reward friends, while at the same time making the protection of the refineries, pipelines, etc. a common concern, rather than a target for those entities which feel disenfranchised.</div><div><br></div><div>Just some thoughts this morning over coffee...</div><div><br></div><div>For my British compatriots...no offense...I was going for an edgy title.</div>
Posted in these groups: Multinational force iraq emblem  mnf i   1 5 IraqImages %283%29 Government1024px smiley.svg HumorEconomy logo Economy
Edited 10 y ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 3
CW2 Joseph Evans
1
1
0
I love the overall air of your comments and the subtle truth it provides as well. While most of the 18As and Field Grade combat arms I've had the pleasure of working with over the years generally had a better grasp of the situation than many of their S-2s or Branch Intel peers.

I think your assessment of stronger government at a lower level would have worked wonders in both Iraq and Afghanistan. The tribal organizations in Afghanistan lend well towards this and the matter of the "Kurdistan" and some of the other areas with distinct tribal and/or minority affiliations would have done better with a weaker center and a more empowered local government. It also doesn't help that the "British model" would stick in the craw of countries that have had to deal with an excess of British Colonialism over the years.

The "privatization" of resources methodology you suggest would also work with the mineral resources that are being harvested in Afghanistan. The recent discovery of Lithium worth in excess of $1 Trillion as well as the iron, magnetite, iron, uranium resources would make the country an incredible world player if we would stop dipping our hands into the pot.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Program Manager
1
1
0
The SITREP is not the best place for this bit of truth but Rally Point is.


(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Robert Burns
1
1
0
I must say this is the first posts that confused me. &nbsp;I feel inferior.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close