Posted on Jul 26, 2025
Do you believe our politicians should be pushing for upgrades to awards?
5.59K
72
41
14
14
0
Sen. Charles E. Schumer, a Democratic Senator from New York, is renewing his push in suggesting U.S. Staff Sgt. Michael Ollis, a Staten Island hero, receive the Medal of Honor.
Do you feel it appropriate for politicians to get involved in military awards? Seems like it puts the awards system into one involving politicians rather than merit... His initial award has already been reviewed and upgraded (in 2019) to the Distinguished Service Cross.
Do you feel it appropriate for politicians to get involved in military awards? Seems like it puts the awards system into one involving politicians rather than merit... His initial award has already been reviewed and upgraded (in 2019) to the Distinguished Service Cross.
Posted in these groups: 
Awards
Medal of Honor
Awards Medal of Honor
Edited 5 mo ago
Posted 5 mo ago
Responses: 11
9
9
0
I don't have a problem with it, but my asking for a review of an award better be held with just as much weight.
(9)
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
LTC Trent Klug -
And If She had To Qualify For That Position,
When The Result Were In, We'd Qualify Her Under The Clause Of Insanity.
And If She had To Qualify For That Position,
When The Result Were In, We'd Qualify Her Under The Clause Of Insanity.
(2)
(0)
SFC Robert Walton
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney - Yes i agree however if i were the one to choose said qualification's we would have problems Getting representatives.
They would be American Born, have a complete education in Constitutional Law, And have Served In the United States Military Active Status for 10 Years or more, and last but not least Never had an Income of more the $35,000 a year in there whole life No investments in Stocks and bonds.
They would be American Born, have a complete education in Constitutional Law, And have Served In the United States Military Active Status for 10 Years or more, and last but not least Never had an Income of more the $35,000 a year in there whole life No investments in Stocks and bonds.
(1)
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
LTC Trent Klug -
CORONEL -- I Had To Look-Up The Senator As I Wasn't At All Familiar With Her Name And I Was Rather Surprised To Prove My Own Case: -- "Having A College Degree Doesn't Necessarily Mean "They're Actually Educated"---
--- --en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazie_Hirono-----
She graduated from Kaimuki High School, which had a predominantly Japanese American student body at the time. Hirono then enrolled at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa, graduating Phi Beta Kappa with a Bachelor of Arts in psychology in 1970. [8] .
~~ And A "BATCHELORS" Of Arts In Psychology? -- That's Almost Impossible To Fail. ~~
CORONEL -- I Had To Look-Up The Senator As I Wasn't At All Familiar With Her Name And I Was Rather Surprised To Prove My Own Case: -- "Having A College Degree Doesn't Necessarily Mean "They're Actually Educated"---
--- --en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mazie_Hirono-----
She graduated from Kaimuki High School, which had a predominantly Japanese American student body at the time. Hirono then enrolled at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa, graduating Phi Beta Kappa with a Bachelor of Arts in psychology in 1970. [8] .
~~ And A "BATCHELORS" Of Arts In Psychology? -- That's Almost Impossible To Fail. ~~
(0)
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
SFC Robert Walton -
WHOA - Even The Pope Would Have A Tough Time Becoming Our President - Even If He Were A Natural Born US Citizen.-- LMBO - And Mother Theresa Would have To Stand In Line & Pick A Number- - I Wish Colin Powell Had Run - "L" I'd Vote For HIM - 3 - 5 Times
WHOA - Even The Pope Would Have A Tough Time Becoming Our President - Even If He Were A Natural Born US Citizen.-- LMBO - And Mother Theresa Would have To Stand In Line & Pick A Number- - I Wish Colin Powell Had Run - "L" I'd Vote For HIM - 3 - 5 Times
(0)
(0)
7
7
0
SGT Mark Stone
1SG(P) Dean Mcbride (MPER) (SPHR) - Uhh...helping your constituents' for whatever reasonable request they make is what any elected representative is *supposed* to do. (Note that I said constituents, not voters. An elected official at any level is supposed to serve everyone in his or her constituency, not just the ones who voted for him or her.)
(0)
(0)
SGT Mark Stone
1SG(P) Dean Mcbride (MPER) (SPHR) - " I doubt that Sen, Schunmer would be fighting to get an award upgrade for a cowboy in Montana!"
1) I don't know anything about the person in question. Is Schumer really fighting for the upgrade--ie, really putting the weight of his office behind it, or is he just asking them to take another look? And if he is putting the weight of his office behind it, is there some argument that the award was unreasonably denied?
2) I'm sure he wouldn't be fighting for someone in another state, except in an extraordinary situation where a whole bunch of Senators thought the award was unreasonably denied. His job description is to serve as a representative of the people in his state, not the people from other states.
1) I don't know anything about the person in question. Is Schumer really fighting for the upgrade--ie, really putting the weight of his office behind it, or is he just asking them to take another look? And if he is putting the weight of his office behind it, is there some argument that the award was unreasonably denied?
2) I'm sure he wouldn't be fighting for someone in another state, except in an extraordinary situation where a whole bunch of Senators thought the award was unreasonably denied. His job description is to serve as a representative of the people in his state, not the people from other states.
(0)
(0)
SFC Robert Walton
Maj Kim Patterson I agree but with exceptions. No politician (with The exception) Of the President of the United States, (COC) Should have influences On Military awards and Benefit's.
(1)
(0)
3
3
0
Politicians Have Been Pushing For Awards For Their Constituents, Since The Founding Of The Military.
Some Were Justified Some Not, During The Civil War There Were So Many Medals Of Honor That Were Awarded For Political Reasons , That Year’s Later A lot Of Them Were Down Graded Or Taken Away .
The Subject Of Awards Has Been Beaten To Death On This Forum So Many Times.
Anyone Who Deserves An Award For An Outstanding Achievement Or An Act Of Valor Should Be Awarded The Highest Award Possible
If A Politician Choses To Advocate For A Constituent To Be Awarded Any Medal , They Have To Do An Investigation Into The Actions Of The Individual During The Incident.
Some Were Justified Some Not, During The Civil War There Were So Many Medals Of Honor That Were Awarded For Political Reasons , That Year’s Later A lot Of Them Were Down Graded Or Taken Away .
The Subject Of Awards Has Been Beaten To Death On This Forum So Many Times.
Anyone Who Deserves An Award For An Outstanding Achievement Or An Act Of Valor Should Be Awarded The Highest Award Possible
If A Politician Choses To Advocate For A Constituent To Be Awarded Any Medal , They Have To Do An Investigation Into The Actions Of The Individual During The Incident.
(3)
(0)
SPC James Neidig
MAJ Ronnie Reams
Yea Right ! The Government Agents Are A Joke, They Collect A Paycheck And Don’t Do Anything About The Conditions On The Reservation.
The Tribal Police Are So Stretched Out They Can’t Be Everywhere.
Like All Police Departments They Are Overworked And Under Paid !
The Alcohol Is Purchased In The Bars In The City Of Hardin And The Drugs Come From Out Of Billings. Both Cities Are Very Close To The Reservation.
When I Was There One Of My Friends Neighbors Was High On PCP Laced Marijuana And It Took Five Police Officers To Take Him Into Custody.
Yea Right ! The Government Agents Are A Joke, They Collect A Paycheck And Don’t Do Anything About The Conditions On The Reservation.
The Tribal Police Are So Stretched Out They Can’t Be Everywhere.
Like All Police Departments They Are Overworked And Under Paid !
The Alcohol Is Purchased In The Bars In The City Of Hardin And The Drugs Come From Out Of Billings. Both Cities Are Very Close To The Reservation.
When I Was There One Of My Friends Neighbors Was High On PCP Laced Marijuana And It Took Five Police Officers To Take Him Into Custody.
(2)
(0)
1SG(P) Dean Mcbride (MPER) (SPHR)
SPC James Neidig SPC James Pretty hard to police 2.2 million acres with a population of 7,900! The rate of Reservations crime is much higher than that of the average US city. Crow Agency ranks in the 4th percentile for safety, meaning it is safer than 4% of cities but less safe than 96%. This analysis applies only to Crow Agency's official city boundaries.
(1)
(0)
SPC James Neidig
1SG(P) Dean Mcbride (MPER) (SPHR)
Most Of The Crimes I Have Heard About On Most Reservations Is Drug And Alcohol Related.
Spousal Abuse While Intoxicated Is A Very Common Occurrence.
Theft Is Also A Common Crime To Support Their Habit.
DUI Is Also A Common Problem .
The Tribal Police Are Doing The Best They Can Do With The Resources They Have And As You Posted It Is A Very Large Reservation With A lot Of Isolated Homes That In Most Cases Are Miles Away From Any Other Home.
Most Of The Crimes I Have Heard About On Most Reservations Is Drug And Alcohol Related.
Spousal Abuse While Intoxicated Is A Very Common Occurrence.
Theft Is Also A Common Crime To Support Their Habit.
DUI Is Also A Common Problem .
The Tribal Police Are Doing The Best They Can Do With The Resources They Have And As You Posted It Is A Very Large Reservation With A lot Of Isolated Homes That In Most Cases Are Miles Away From Any Other Home.
(2)
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
SPC James Neidig -
I've Only Lived In Michigan - Arizona -California, And Here In Nevada, Which Have Reservations--But What You Say Has a Lot Of Validity -- "..Crimes I Have Heard About On Most Reservations Is Drug And Alcohol Related".
I'm NOT Sure The Reasons, But I HAVE Noticed, Few Have Occupations Outside Of Possibly The Reservations - In Which Case I'd GUESS -- "Frigging Bored With Not Much Else To Do."
I've Only Lived In Michigan - Arizona -California, And Here In Nevada, Which Have Reservations--But What You Say Has a Lot Of Validity -- "..Crimes I Have Heard About On Most Reservations Is Drug And Alcohol Related".
I'm NOT Sure The Reasons, But I HAVE Noticed, Few Have Occupations Outside Of Possibly The Reservations - In Which Case I'd GUESS -- "Frigging Bored With Not Much Else To Do."
(0)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google