Posted on Feb 26, 2016
Are groups like the American Legion and VFW too Right Wing Conservative for the new generation of Veterans?
29.5K
258
199
10
10
0
Given the societal change in this country that has been integrated into the Armed Forces, do younger veterans share the same views and attitudes of the traditional veterans clubs?
Are you uncomfortable participating when everyone else is considerably older and have different views? Should religion and politics be a focal point for Veterans Organizations?
Are you uncomfortable participating when everyone else is considerably older and have different views? Should religion and politics be a focal point for Veterans Organizations?
Edited 10 y ago
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 64
Last year I became a member of the VFW in Arkansas. Most of the members are Vietnam Vets some are racist and some are not, most in the leadership role are Democrats. I sit in each meeting and can't wait for each meeting to end. At my local group the night is started off with dinner then we move to the back room. Once we get to the back room the meeting is treated like a ceremony. I have stood in way too many change of command formations and various other ceremonies the military has to spend my free time doing it instead of spending it with my family. Most of the meeting is spent talking about old business, new business, Bingo, Burial Detail and other things I would rather not take part in during my free time. One gentleman in charge of the Burial Detail asked if I had a uniform yet and I replied in the negative. He wanted to make a big deal about getting me one until I made it clear I did not want one. He almost seemed offended so I explained; "I took off the uniform in 2011 and am in no rush to jump into another." I would love to go and talk with Schools, but not as a representative of any organization. When you are a part of an Organization they want you to push a certain message instead of saying what needs to be said.
I suspect the newer Veterans are looking for something different. I am not sure what that is yet. Maybe a Social Club for Combat Veterans. A place where there is no formality or agenda aside from spending time with other Veterans who need to get away or hang out. The problem is the Foreign Legion is a bar where any Veteran can come and drink and the VFW allows anyone who has deployed to come on in and wants you to work bingo nights. The best times I have had with other Vets was hanging out playing poker and having a few beers and then going for a hunt the next day.
I suspect the newer Veterans are looking for something different. I am not sure what that is yet. Maybe a Social Club for Combat Veterans. A place where there is no formality or agenda aside from spending time with other Veterans who need to get away or hang out. The problem is the Foreign Legion is a bar where any Veteran can come and drink and the VFW allows anyone who has deployed to come on in and wants you to work bingo nights. The best times I have had with other Vets was hanging out playing poker and having a few beers and then going for a hunt the next day.
(0)
(0)
LTC Martin Metz
The desire to listen to new members and an openness to new ideas will stake out which organizations stay relevant.
(1)
(0)
SPC Keelan Southerland
Thank you for your willingness to listen LTC Metz. I have a question for you. Last month I brought some new business to the post commander about my old CO in Iraq. He has 100 different companies who are looking to hire Vets, mainly in the NW USA, but not exclusively. However, when I brought this information to the post commander he blew me off because all of the guys were retired or too old to relocate. It is good solid information that can be spread through out the State if a Vet is looking for a Job. Should I pass the information along in that fashion or keep it to myself and talk with folks on RP who can use the information?
(0)
(0)
SFC J Fullerton
SPC Keelan Southerland - The American Legion does have a tremendous amount of resources on the National and state levels for veterans job services. I suggest checking out the AL website, there are links for veterans employment. They also sponsor job fairs in various locations nationally. A lot of great information can be found there. Unfortunately, many 'posts' are unaware that these services even exist and have no idea how to promote them to those who would benefit. The agenda at the post level often centers around paying bills and planning the next pancake breakfast.
(0)
(0)
If veterans organizations like VFW & AL are to far Right Wing then I'd have to thow Rally Point in with it also. All are a group of brothers in arms dedicated and believe in the values of God Country and Freedom.
(0)
(0)
LTC Martin Metz
We have had to deal with real world situations that tend to make us more respectful of our comrades no matter the religious or political view.
(0)
(0)
I really caught your topic and it is a damned good one. After reading a few replies and analyzing that information, I think this is a complicated question. I thought at first it was simple to answer, but its not. I think the biggest issue is the age difference. For so many years membership declined. I have not decided to join one simply due to personal reasons and while looking at one of them, I couldnt quite decide if they were for me or not. But what is troublesome is the quote below stating how young people get their news from the internet and such.... well we all know,, dont believe what you read on the internet.. and if you are in Intel, you learned to check your sources. The bashing of Fox news is just a simple sign those people are drinking from the same cup of biased news as they say that Fox news is reporting. Those kids are a problem and will remain a problem regardless if they are veterans or not. I last served with teenage kids and in their 20's during the OIF and I fear for our country ever since. They had no core values, they didnt care, they wanted the glory of being in the military without the work to say they earned it. I heard this from other guys my age returning from Iraq. We didnt go so i know i saw a worst attitude. Some of those kids, wisened up over there, I heard. None of mine stateside really did. But back to resolving the issue. These kids have the same rights to assemble and form as we do. Perhaps they dont want the camaraderie,, just the disability check. That wouldnt surprise me, since a lot of those that are more liberal have issues with the military. Most of mine were liberal and hated that i was so authoritative. When I point out to them that Obama is, I get, 'he has to do something to fix it'... but fix what? My point is to 'lets figure out a logical way to do this and do it systematically' is always met with 'no, we need it now'. (this is mostly about Obamacare) There is a huuuuuge difference of opinion between left and right at all ages and what is stupid is, its about the 20% of things we dont agree on. We blame them for that, they blame us for that,,, when are we going to look at ourselves and how we vote and the crooked crony's we reelect into congress. Something has to bring us together again.. veterans as well as citizens. The answer may be the same, it may be different but this boils down to separation of ideology if you ask me. I think we need more parties.. mostly 'sub parties' of each to specifically identify with certain cultural differences in our society. I talked to a strong union pipefitter and we had a great talk. I proposed to him a party of strong constitutional beliefs and strong labor beliefs. although I am white collar now, I believe I and we HAVE to work for our needs/wants. So does he. He also believes in having guns. However, he hated the thought of having an AR. I asked him why and he went to the 'automatic' issue and magazine size. I was stunned. I told him mine doesnt have automatic features and with training I can reload with many 10 round clips with very little delay between the reloads to acoomplish the same mass murder since NO ONE ON SITE IS PROVIDING RETURNING FIRE. he thinks guns should not be on school anywhere and he has kids.. I am still stunned. moving on... I have never heard the N word used in any Hall but that doesnt mean it doesnt happen. I have tried really hard to avoid that myself, simply out of the fact I'm tired of hearing how it reverts to slavery and I had nothing to do with it. To me, its like calling me a cracker or redneck,, big deal, laugh it off. its just a word. Anyway, i know I am kind of rambling but the discussion needs to be opened and it has to be fair and both sides have valid points and issues that need to be taken into consideration. I think the core of us that are 'righties' from the military, stems from protecting the Constitution herself. To us its simple, it fulfills every human's needs and rights, with modifications sometimes, but thats the beauty of it, its not perfect, they knew it wasnt and it should be modified as needed to protect rights. We see the left as picking and choosing which parts to believe in and we see the righties as mostly defending it, just making a kazillion dollars while doing so. Am I right?
(0)
(0)
SFC J Fullerton
Thanks for the input. Sorry it took 4 months to reply. Good insight, I agree there is a generation gap. But there is a lot more to it than just politics.
(0)
(0)
I really caught your topic and it is a damned good one. After reading a few replies and analyzing that information, I think this is a complicated question. I thought at first it was simple to answer, but its not. I think the biggest issue is the age difference. For so many years membership declined. I have not decided to join one simply due to personal reasons and while looking at one of them, I couldnt quite decide if they were for me or not. But what is troublesome is the quote below stating how young people get their news from the internet and such.... well we all know,, dont believe what you read on the internet.. and if you are in Intel, you learned to check your sources. The bashing of Fox news is just a simple sign those people are drinking from the same cup of biased news as they say that Fox news is reporting. Those kids are a problem and will remain a problem regardless if they are veterans or not. I last served with teenage kids and in their 20's during the OIF and I fear for our country ever since. They had no core values, they didnt care, they wanted the glory of being in the military without the work to say they earned it. I heard this from other guys my age returning from Iraq. We didnt go so i know i saw a worst attitude. Some of those kids, wisened up over there, I heard. None of mine stateside really did. But back to resolving the issue. These kids have the same rights to assemble and form as we do. Perhaps they dont want the camaraderie,, just the disability check. That wouldnt surprise me, since a lot of those that are more liberal have issues with the military. Most of mine were liberal and hated that i was so authoritative. When I point out to them that Obama is, I get, 'he has to do something to fix it'... but fix what? My point is to 'lets figure out a logical way to do this and do it systematically' is always met with 'no, we need it now'. (this is mostly about Obamacare) There is a huuuuuge difference of opinion between left and right at all ages and what is stupid is, its about the 20% of things we dont agree on. We blame them for that, they blame us for that,,, when are we going to look at ourselves and how we vote and the crooked crony's we reelect into congress. Something has to bring us together again.. veterans as well as citizens. The answer may be the same, it may be different but this boils down to separation of ideology if you ask me. I think we need more parties.. mostly 'sub parties' of each to specifically identify with certain cultural differences in our society. I talked to a strong union pipefitter and we had a great talk. I proposed to him a party of strong constitutional beliefs and strong labor beliefs. although I am white collar now, I believe I and we HAVE to work for our needs/wants. So does he. He also believes in having guns. However, he hated the thought of having an AR. I asked him why and he went to the 'automatic' issue and magazine size. I was stunned. I told him mine doesnt have automatic features and with training I can reload with many 10 round clips with very little delay between the reloads to acoomplish the same mass murder since NO ONE ON SITE IS PROVIDING RETURNING FIRE. he thinks guns should not be on school anywhere and he has kids.. I am still stunned. moving on... I have never heard the N word used in any Hall but that doesnt mean it doesnt happen. I have tried really hard to avoid that myself, simply out of the fact I'm tired of hearing how it reverts to slavery and I had nothing to do with it. To me, its like calling me a cracker or redneck,, big deal, laugh it off. its just a word. Anyway, i know I am kind of rambling but the discussion needs to be opened and it has to be fair and both sides have valid points and issues that need to be taken into consideration. I think the core of us that are 'righties' from the military, stems from protecting the Constitution herself. To us its simple, it fulfills every human's needs and rights, with modifications sometimes, but thats the beauty of it, its not perfect, they knew it wasnt and it should be modified as needed to protect rights. We see the left as picking and choosing which parts to believe in and we see the righties as mostly defending it, just making a kazillion dollars while doing so. Am I right?
(0)
(0)
LTC Martin Metz
I think the military tends to encourage more conservative outlooks because we are dealing with life and death scenarios that tend to keep us more realistic in how we look at people, family, and issues. We are also introduced to values and principles that help shape things. What we do with that from there still embraces a diverse involvement with political parties and veteran organizations.
(0)
(0)
SGT James George
i would say that first point is correct since the old ways of 'be the leader, do as the leader' holds true. so, if you are young and impressionable and your leader(s) are reflecting their political beliefs, which they do, but they arent supposed to.. we are all human its going to happen.. those beliefs become ingrained inthe young soldier. I know it did me... the training I received had values and principles that encouraged individual strength, which is a strong contributor to being a firm Rightie.. i'd agree with that, but so many of the kids nowadays do not buy that coolaid. I'd say their upbringing is a big part of who they are and when it contradicts the militarizied individual strength we teach, it can still remain. its definetly something to consider.. I do have one big question for those in more recent than myself.. if citizens rose up, marched on all the capitals, by the millions even, left or right, or both,, WOULD the members of the military let it take its course, or would they follow any orders from CIC to push them back or even fire upon them? I want to believe they'd let us be. but part of me says the other... I think the leaders are still predominantly conservative and would understand this needs to happen.. but if they DID follow orders to push citizens back, would they troops do it? thats their families, neighbors.. fighting for what is right..... just a thought, interested in other veterans thoughts.
(0)
(0)
SPC Keelan Southerland
SGT George I think the fire on citizens or push them back is a topic all on its own. I am sure it would garner the best responses from quality people.
You are right on point when you stated; "values and principles that encouraged individual strength, which is a strong contributor to being a firm Rightie." I have noticed that if a guy went in not having a political affiliation and they were a good soldier they had your outcome. However, if the opposite was the case they were pushed the other direction or even worse militant. I did notice a great deal of folks who were democrats became hard dems after serving. Just an observation.
You are right on point when you stated; "values and principles that encouraged individual strength, which is a strong contributor to being a firm Rightie." I have noticed that if a guy went in not having a political affiliation and they were a good soldier they had your outcome. However, if the opposite was the case they were pushed the other direction or even worse militant. I did notice a great deal of folks who were democrats became hard dems after serving. Just an observation.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next

