11
11
0
This is a subjective question. Nobody can anticipate every circumstance and condition. So this discussion is about whats best for you.... Vote below and tell us why?
Shooting (Sport)
Crime
Self Defense
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 89
3
3
0
Anything smaller than a 9mm isn't going to be sufficent for self-defense. If you really want a pea-shooter, the psychological factor may be your best bet to stop the bad guys. Something is better than nothing. Big gun = big purse. Guys need to find better hiding places.
(3)
(0)
SPC Randy Torgerson
SSG Paul Headlee - That is pretty cool... I'm going to look into this even further. Thanks.
(1)
(0)
SSG Paul Headlee
SPC Randy Torgerson YW. I kind of wanted a Wildey Survivor in .475 Wildey for a few years but their owners were reporting lots of cracked slides or frames, I forget which. Went with a .480 Ruger instead. 400 grain lead slug at 1275 fps, no problem. It could probably go 1325 or better but I don't beat up guns as a rule.
(1)
(0)
SSG Paul Headlee
SPC Randy Torgerson there's the .45 Winchester Magnum as well. Not sure if anyone currently chambers that one.
(0)
(0)
2
2
0
I read this somewhere once in a magazine, "The .45ACP puts very big holes in very bad people."
I tend to agree with that. Springfield XD 4", cant beat 13 rnds of 45.
I tend to agree with that. Springfield XD 4", cant beat 13 rnds of 45.
(2)
(0)
2
2
0
Robbery Victim Takes Shotgun From Robber in New Orleans
The NOPD is asking for the public's help in finding an armed robber who found himself on the run after the victim turned the tables. Investigators say the wh...
Glock 30S .45 But go to the range and become very proficient with you side arm. Learn to shoot with left and right. Or you could just be a bad ass like this guy and use whatever the bad guy is using.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnlLeWLS5Iw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnlLeWLS5Iw
(2)
(0)
2
2
0
I shoot a .40 Taurus and keep it in my gun purse. Has a laser on it too for extra accuracy. Beretta 9mm is a great and easy weapon to use. But glocks are the easiest and smoothest to shoot for me. I'm just speaking about cheaper weapons not the fancy and pricey handguns out there.
(2)
(0)
1
1
0
All of them will work, shot placement is the key.
Ok, I'll ask the question, "If you got shot in the head, which caliber would you prefer to be shot with???
Ok, I'll ask the question, "If you got shot in the head, which caliber would you prefer to be shot with???
(1)
(0)
SGT Carl Blas
SSG Paul Headlee - After seeing that guy die from shock, I then knew and understood, why in the Army we were always taught to treat for shock.
(1)
(0)
SSG Paul Headlee
SGT Carl Blas I'm surprised (and happy) that your store owner didn't expire from shock. BTW, you make excellent points and I agree with you.
(1)
(0)
SSG Paul Headlee
SGT Carl Blas I found this and agree with it. Your comment about shot placement is rock solid. I've always emphasized marksmanship over volume of fire.
https://shootingthebull.net/blog/357-magnum-check-center-mass-hit-check-instant-stop-er/
https://shootingthebull.net/blog/357-magnum-check-center-mass-hit-check-instant-stop-er/
.357 Magnum? Check. “Center Mass” hit? Check. Instant Stop? Er… | Shooting The Bull
If there’s one thing that drives me batty, it’s the insistence upon certain folks that there’s such a thing as a “best” caliber, or that certain bullets or certain calibers have a higher percentage of “one shot stops” than others. And the one that gets talked about most often is … the .357 Magnum.
(1)
(0)
1
1
0
.40S&W works for me. The Sig P239 SAS model is a great slim-gripped single stack magazine hand gun and is easily concealed--especially when paired with an alien gear IWB holster. I have never shot better with another hand gun and I have used a bunch over the years. That said, I shoot pretty good with a $300 Ruger 9mm that my dad gave to me over 20 years ago. I guess it all comes down to practice and fundamentals of good marksmanship.
(1)
(0)
SSG Paul Headlee
That is precisely what it comes down to, along with a good dose of situational awareness and a good tactical plan (to include battle drills).
(1)
(0)
1
1
0
.45! I prefer to only have to shoot once. I want to make sure when I hit them, they are going down.
(1)
(0)
1
1
0
1
1
0
Whatever you have and are accurate with, shot placement is more important than size/calibre!
(1)
(0)
1
1
0
.380 is solid enough. Plus, do you truly conceal carry a .45? If so, great. But, for me, I want a weapon that is not cumbersome.
If you're worried about stopping power, then you might not have the true intent of a concealed weapon. If I ever feel the need to pull out my weapon to defend my life, I'm not looking to slow you down. Too many variables. I'm looking to take you out. My .380 has enough gusto to turn the lights out; assuming I group my shots well enough.
If you're worried about stopping power, then you might not have the true intent of a concealed weapon. If I ever feel the need to pull out my weapon to defend my life, I'm not looking to slow you down. Too many variables. I'm looking to take you out. My .380 has enough gusto to turn the lights out; assuming I group my shots well enough.
(1)
(0)
SPC Randy Torgerson
Hmm, I assume we're talking about America? A class on "hostile environments and complacency" may be beneficial for other reasons but seems odd to take this class to help determine what firearm and caliber to carry for a non-hostile country....
Shouldn't you carry what you like? What feels good to you? What your willing to want with you everyday? I mean a grenade is the best all round way to get the bad guy, but it has severe consequences. Just like someone who is not comfortable with a .45 1911, there will probably be severe consequences. You should carry what your comfortable using and concealing. That will be your best defensive firearm.
Just my opinion of course.....
Shouldn't you carry what you like? What feels good to you? What your willing to want with you everyday? I mean a grenade is the best all round way to get the bad guy, but it has severe consequences. Just like someone who is not comfortable with a .45 1911, there will probably be severe consequences. You should carry what your comfortable using and concealing. That will be your best defensive firearm.
Just my opinion of course.....
(0)
(0)
MAJ(P) (Join to see)
I'm well-versed and well-trained with my weapons and personal physical security. This includes the differences in caliber and a slew of weapon types. My time with CJSOTF was very beneficial and trust me, they were pros.
I proudly stake my life on the .380 I carry with the rounds I choose. If the time arises, I'll place a well grouped shots to the chest or head - situation dependent. If I'm in or near my vehicle, I'll pull out my .40 or my M4. But, my concealed weapon of choice is what I'm comfortable with having on me at all times (off post).
But, hostile environment? My course of action is to avoid a hostile environment at all cost. That's usually very possible in the US.
Now, I ask, are you going to chastise and assume everyone who chooses not to carry the caliber of your choice that they are less informed and need "professional" training?
I proudly stake my life on the .380 I carry with the rounds I choose. If the time arises, I'll place a well grouped shots to the chest or head - situation dependent. If I'm in or near my vehicle, I'll pull out my .40 or my M4. But, my concealed weapon of choice is what I'm comfortable with having on me at all times (off post).
But, hostile environment? My course of action is to avoid a hostile environment at all cost. That's usually very possible in the US.
Now, I ask, are you going to chastise and assume everyone who chooses not to carry the caliber of your choice that they are less informed and need "professional" training?
(0)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google