Can I get a waiver for my NTR?

That's the whole reason it means Never to Return. SFAS isn't about how physically ready you are, but being physically ready makes it easier to handle. It's about how you perform once you're past your breaking point. When your body says it's done are you the kind of person who tells it to keep on going or not?

In SFAS you aren't just assessed on your physical performance, there are multiple areas - whole Soldier concept - that are taken into consideration together. You can be a beast but not get along with others. You can be the weakest member but still be value added to the team in other areas. Where do you think you scored in other areas?

Exceptions to policy are for exceptional people or exceptional circumstances. What about you or your circumstances is exceptional? If your request for an ETP reads that you simply showed up unprepared - twice - nobody wants that guy on their team. That's why there is a two time NTR policy. So how do you plan to lay out your appeal to the Commandant of SWC, a Major General, to explain how you or your situation has changed exceptionally and how you would be a valuable member to a team?

Did you get an ARSOF NTR or just SF NTR? You probably won’t go back through SFAS. But you can go to Pysops or CA if you didn’t get an ARSOF. If you did you can still do tier 1 units (smus) ranger or SOAR

NTR (Never To Return) in Monopoly speak is "Do Not Pass Go, Do Not Collect $200.00." If the SFAS told/marked you as NTR, then that's it.