Posted on Sep 24, 2014
Do you believe that Sharia Law is compatible with our Constitution?
31.9K
566
329
6
6
0
I want to know whether anyone believes that Islam in America demanding Sharia Law will work in America with our Constitution and Bill of Rights. With the growing Muslim population (both legally and illegally) and all of the special treatment they get regarding their religion as compared to any other in America are you worried about whether our Constitution will survive?
Posted in these groups: 
Constitution
Islam
Constitution Islam
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 92
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
No. Sharia law requires a totalitarian form of rule to operate. Our constitution works best in a secular environment.
(0)
(0)
0
0
0
I will have to agree to some degree; here's why; and no it is not in accordance with our laws here but some of those laws I do agree with such as crime. rape, murder, theft, and other major crimes are dealt with on a different level. you rape kids or murder someone. you are put to death within weeks and I like that. I think crime will stop overnight here in this country and that's very effective. the problem is that we have too many people and companies making money off of the justice system. we have too many criminals that are walking the streets because of flaws and loopholes in our judicial system. so some of the sharia law I do support when it comes to crimes committed. that's just my take on it.
(0)
(0)
COL George Antochy
I do not believe that Sharia Law will allow for us to pick and choose which ones we like and which we disapprove of. I do agree that our criminal justice system has gone to hell these past 50 years, and we need to revamp the entire system.
(1)
(0)
SPC Paul Shene III
Draconian penalties do not solve basic impulses. Many rapist get started by a culture where women are systematically de-valued. The theft of billions remains unpunished because the theft was done by robosigning foreclosure proceedings rather than with a firearm. Our judicial and correctional system favors wealth over truth. Adding draconian penalties won't make crime disappear. it just gives another way to clamp the iron boot on the throat of the poor and powerless.
(0)
(0)
0
0
0
A big overwhelming no. Shariah law minus the banking has penalties for crimes that involved murder and other means which are illegal. Finally, US laws supersede foreign laws. States are already clamping down on this to ban at both a state and fed level.
Shariah Law may work there when culturally, every country there hates one another and is an artificial construct post Ottoman Empire and WW2. To rule some of those countries and areas where it is a revenge tribal based society, a heavy hand seems to be needed.
Shariah Law may work there when culturally, every country there hates one another and is an artificial construct post Ottoman Empire and WW2. To rule some of those countries and areas where it is a revenge tribal based society, a heavy hand seems to be needed.
(0)
(0)
0
0
0
I think our Constitution will survive, but I think it's sad that your question is probably a valid one. How in the world does Sharia law threaten our country? It shouldn't, but I can see how it might ... all in the name of "tolerance" and political correctness. You ask a great question, in my opinion, and our political leaders - the folks we elect to represent us - will have to answer the question as we go forward.
(0)
(0)
SPC Paul Shene III
Religious dominion by any religion is incompatible with our constitution. Only freedom of and from religion is compatible. No establishment, no prohibiting free exercise thereof.
(1)
(0)
PO1 Steven Kuhn
Mr. Shene it is not protection from religion but the protection from being forced in to believing or forced to following a religion. Please read the First Amendment and tell me what you think.....
(0)
(0)
LTC W. H. "Wally" Wallace
Our politicians are just a bunch of cowards and refuse to do anything about it. They just sit on their hands and do nothing.
(1)
(0)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Our Constitution will survive.As Isoroku Yamamoto put it You cannot invade the mainland United States. There would be a rifle behind every blade of grass.Islam does have a foothold in America but it will not dominate.Sharia Law is not compatible with our Bill of rights or Constitution.
(0)
(0)
SSG Maurice P.
I CANT WAIT FOR OPEN SEASON... SO FAR, THERE IS 23 ISIS I NEED PAY BACK ON... THAT WOULD BE 16 FOR MY FELLOW BROTHER TANKERS (19k)also my brother (11B) AND MY FRIENDS THE SCOUTS (19D)3 IRAQI INTERPRETERS THAT THEY KILLED WHO WORKED FOR US...AND THE 4 PEOPLE WHO GOT BEHEADED...ALL I NEED TO ACCOMPLISH MY MISSION IS MY SHOTGUN MY .45 ACP AND MY SUPER SHARP K-BAR AND 23 DRESSES
(5)
(0)
(0)
(0)
SSG Maurice P.
of course it did TOP...........im not politically correct,as you can see i retired a staff sergeant
20 years active duty 14 years active reserve 34 years total time in uniform...My Armor Bn lost 16 soldiers and 3 Iraqi Interpreters...I WANT AND NEED PAYBACK....WHAT DONT YOU UNDERSTAND.....Those people arent afraid to die or to kill you or i so how do you combat someone who has nothing to lose.......they hate women so send them home in a dress disgraced...break their minds....
20 years active duty 14 years active reserve 34 years total time in uniform...My Armor Bn lost 16 soldiers and 3 Iraqi Interpreters...I WANT AND NEED PAYBACK....WHAT DONT YOU UNDERSTAND.....Those people arent afraid to die or to kill you or i so how do you combat someone who has nothing to lose.......they hate women so send them home in a dress disgraced...break their minds....
(1)
(0)
PO1 Steven Kuhn
God will have the vengeance brother. He might use you to get it, but do not let it poison you or break your happiness. When we serve against evil, some of us fall and some of us carry on. God Speed to you, but more importantly God's Peace and Love....
(1)
(0)
0
0
0
No, I do not feel it is compatible. When the US Constitution is treated as being equal or secondary to any other legal system then it loses it's value and protections. Our freedoms that the Constitution were intended to be bestowed on man by a force more powerful than government which was intentional because anything granted by the government can be taken away by government. Sharia law is incompatible based on the punishments and power it gives to the authority over man.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google