Posted on May 4, 2016
Do you believe that these West Point first classman are violating the UCMJ by making a political statement while in uniform?
93.9K
1.65K
842
42
42
0
DOD directive 1344.10 states:
-A member of the Armed Forces on active duty may:
4.1.1.3. Join a partisan or nonpartisan political club and attend its meetings when NOT in uniform, subject to the restrictions of subparagraph 4.1.2.4. (See DoD Instruction 1334.1 (Reference (c).)
From the article "Racism Within West Point"
http://www.inthearenafitness.com/index.php/racism-within-west-point
-A member of the Armed Forces on active duty may:
4.1.1.3. Join a partisan or nonpartisan political club and attend its meetings when NOT in uniform, subject to the restrictions of subparagraph 4.1.2.4. (See DoD Instruction 1334.1 (Reference (c).)
From the article "Racism Within West Point"
http://www.inthearenafitness.com/index.php/racism-within-west-point
Edited 9 y ago
Posted 9 y ago
Responses: 236
Well there is obviously some subplot not mentioned here. Photo appears to show all female black cadets showing support of something, but what? See nothing to indicate any organization or club that they may or may not be representing. Raised fist can represent many things, perhaps some sports team just won, and unless there is something against rules leading up to it the photo is meaningless. Photo just seems to be cadets celebrating something, so no not a UCMJ violation.
(8)
(0)
CW3 Douglas Branson
If their sports team just won, why do they not look excited? I can't believe the kid gloves that this kind of crap gets handled with.
(3)
(0)
I don't see any actions that violate the DOD Directive quoted in that opinion piece. The writer's opinion is nothing more than that....an opinion.
(8)
(0)
A1C Melissa Jackson
CPT L S
Ahhh- my darling captain!
The joys of learning languages has escaped you. If they have not escaped you, then you surely know that I stupidly put "decline verbs" when I really meant conjugate verbs! I am a dork, and it has been a very long time!
And here I shall demonstrate by conjugating the English verb "run":
I run
She runs
He runs
They run
It runs
Past tense of "run"
I ran
He ran
She ran
They ran
It ran
I could go all day, but I have been up and RUNNING all night!
Latin verb "currere" (to run)
Present tense
curro
curris
currit
currimus
curritis
currunt
Ahhh- my darling captain!
The joys of learning languages has escaped you. If they have not escaped you, then you surely know that I stupidly put "decline verbs" when I really meant conjugate verbs! I am a dork, and it has been a very long time!
And here I shall demonstrate by conjugating the English verb "run":
I run
She runs
He runs
They run
It runs
Past tense of "run"
I ran
He ran
She ran
They ran
It ran
I could go all day, but I have been up and RUNNING all night!
Latin verb "currere" (to run)
Present tense
curro
curris
currit
currimus
curritis
currunt
(0)
(0)
MSG (Join to see)
ltc b i dont know were you grew up or how but i can tell you this that fist pump is black panther i grew up in those days, these wms are wrong need to be counselled, they are the future , i f you think black lives matter , then what about green lives matter, if a had one of these future o's leading me well they might not make it back
(0)
(0)
MSG (Join to see)
sgt g be very afraid , because what you dont understand is these same people will be the army future
(0)
(0)
While I believe their intent was to show solidarity for themselves - it takes a team to get through WP -- they showed poor judgment in the execution of the picture - perceptions can sometimes become reality. fairly or not. Give them some hours to walk off and move on.
(7)
(0)
CSM Chuck Stafford
CPT L S -
While there are blue cords for the infantry, I am an intel guy (98C, 35N nowadays) - SIGINTer, so the cord is "oriental" blue. Earned my silver spurs as an old 1SG; it was a fun/not fun experience. But you never quit and you lead from the front. Strykehorse 5-14 CAV now the 2-14 in Hawaii.
While there are blue cords for the infantry, I am an intel guy (98C, 35N nowadays) - SIGINTer, so the cord is "oriental" blue. Earned my silver spurs as an old 1SG; it was a fun/not fun experience. But you never quit and you lead from the front. Strykehorse 5-14 CAV now the 2-14 in Hawaii.
(0)
(0)
CSM Chuck Stafford
CPT L S - The Strykers do have infantryman and some wear their baby blue acorns -- That said, I was promoted out of a job, but my boys got their gold spurs and did well in Iraq -- so well that their SIGINT actions are forever memorialized on a trophy/plaque at the NSA. Additionally, the other platoons, UAV and CBRN set trailblazing standards for their actions. Truly a high water mark in a great career -- If you ain't CAV... ;-)
(0)
(0)
Here is another article on the topic... If you read no other article regarding the photograph in question, read this one. Well written, and very moving for someone--like me--who finds it difficult to put their feet into the shoes of a person of another race and gender.
https://www.facebook.com/notes/mary-tobin/this-is-not-about-a-fist/ [login to see] 340936
COL Jean (John) F. Burleson Capt Tom Brown A1C Melissa Jackson MSG (Join to see) CPT Aaron Kletzing SFC David Pratt LTC Raymond Millen PVT John Williams MSgt Rena Schmidt SSgt Jim Gilmore SPC Thea Davis PO2 Brian Harrington GySgt Steven Robeson PVT Tim Wayne SFC (Join to see) SGT Bryon Sergent
MSG Donald Johnson LTC (Join to see) COL (Join to see) Lt Col John (Jack) Christensen
https://www.facebook.com/notes/mary-tobin/this-is-not-about-a-fist/ [login to see] 340936
COL Jean (John) F. Burleson Capt Tom Brown A1C Melissa Jackson MSG (Join to see) CPT Aaron Kletzing SFC David Pratt LTC Raymond Millen PVT John Williams MSgt Rena Schmidt SSgt Jim Gilmore SPC Thea Davis PO2 Brian Harrington GySgt Steven Robeson PVT Tim Wayne SFC (Join to see) SGT Bryon Sergent
MSG Donald Johnson LTC (Join to see) COL (Join to see) Lt Col John (Jack) Christensen
(7)
(0)
CPT John Sheridan
COL Sam Russell - Good article. My empathy frequently fails me as well when I lack sufficient commonality. So, I try to move past my knee jerk responses and rely on my reason. I prefer evidence before a conclusion, so I tend to discount untested hypotheses. Something is not true until sufficient and honest effort to prove it false has failed. I see a photo in which a group of West Point cadets who appear to be black women are posing for the camera and making a gesture. Beyond that, I know nothing. I could develop some hypotheses about meaning and intent, but feeling one way or the other about those doesn't make them true. So, a lot of people believe that this photo has meaning and some of them find something nefarious in the presumed meaning. Perhaps this warrants their chain of command looking into it. Beyond that, I'm not sure it matters what all of us who look at this photo think about it.
(1)
(0)
SFC (Join to see)
Sir that was a great article and touched in it, I think I need to explain what I meant that something should be done. Counseling not negative but, something that a PAO or Senior Offcier might give in unintended consequences. What the picture shows out of context is a group of Cadets creating a exclusionary group " insert group that you want the raised fist to stand for" What they did may have been innocent but a social media post in uniform has to abide by certain standards
(0)
(0)
Sgt Edward Padget
That was an insightful observation, I appreciate that she took the time and made the effort to speak about the journey these women have taken based on her own personal experience. When I think back on her words and what the "fist" represents in my eyes she is right. I see it as a negative, that being said I can honestly say I've never seen it used in a positive manner. I'm left wondering do the graduates at Spelman, Hampton, Morehouse or Howard raise a fist with each graduating class instead of tossing their caps in the air? I'm not trying to find fault in the story as I think she did a great job expressing and sharing her thoughts. I am trying very hard to understand this notion of "It's a black thing you wouldn't understand" being an acceptable way to communicate the plight of black women attending West Point.
(0)
(0)
SSG(P) (Join to see)
Incredible, inspiring story. However... West Point was a choice she made. The Army was a choice she made.
I was born with a congenital birth defect which made my right foot smaller and deformed (I don't have toes like everyone else) and my right leg lacks developed musculature and was shorter at birth. I grew up in a time where there was no PC-ness and I endured years of verbal abuse and ridicule. But I didn't let it get to me. I had surgery to correct my leg length, then waited 17 years for the opportunity to apply for a waiver to enlist. That finally came and I have just passed 9 years in the Army.
My physical deformities do indeed have a lot to do with who I am. However, they do NOT allow me to do what I want when I want how I want. I still have to purchase and wear approved footwear (two pairs at a time) and operate within the regulations. In fact, as a NCO, I have to live, demonstrate, and enforce the standard. I don't get to use my physical abnormalities in order to act outside the regulations nor standard. Have I been through a lot? Yes. Has footwear been a hassle and an expense for me? Yes. Does it give me the right to wear what I want? No, absolutely not. Why? Because I made a conscious decision, a CHOICE to join the Army and live by its rules and regulations. If I didn't want to do that, I wouldn't have joined. It really is that simple.
I was born with a congenital birth defect which made my right foot smaller and deformed (I don't have toes like everyone else) and my right leg lacks developed musculature and was shorter at birth. I grew up in a time where there was no PC-ness and I endured years of verbal abuse and ridicule. But I didn't let it get to me. I had surgery to correct my leg length, then waited 17 years for the opportunity to apply for a waiver to enlist. That finally came and I have just passed 9 years in the Army.
My physical deformities do indeed have a lot to do with who I am. However, they do NOT allow me to do what I want when I want how I want. I still have to purchase and wear approved footwear (two pairs at a time) and operate within the regulations. In fact, as a NCO, I have to live, demonstrate, and enforce the standard. I don't get to use my physical abnormalities in order to act outside the regulations nor standard. Have I been through a lot? Yes. Has footwear been a hassle and an expense for me? Yes. Does it give me the right to wear what I want? No, absolutely not. Why? Because I made a conscious decision, a CHOICE to join the Army and live by its rules and regulations. If I didn't want to do that, I wouldn't have joined. It really is that simple.
(1)
(0)
SSG Roger Ayscue
I thought the US Military was SUPPOSED to be colorblind....BUT then we do have Race/ethnic/gender quotas for promotions and awards....
(2)
(0)
LTC Joseph George
SSG Roger Ayscue - Since congress is involved in shortsighted policy making directed at a very small percentage of the populace. It started in the 1990's and has been a cancer eating away at society and now the military. Racism knows no bounds and does not adhere to regulations, it is total hatred.
(2)
(0)
What is the context of the picture? I graduated from USMA in 1982. I have seen a lifetime of groups taking pictures out of context. The most infamous was when we were at summer camp. A bunch of cadets were wearing sheets and playing like ghosts and someone took a picture. The NY Times ran it as KKK at West Point. They never retracted it even when someone pointed out that one of the hands sticking out under a sheet was obviously not white. There is a brotherhood at West Point that that is hard to describe. Any additional ties that bind you to one another such as being a minority bind you more. It is traditional for Seniors to have group pictures taken. Were they all on a sports team together? A clenched fist can be used to signify unity for many things. Those pictures mean these are our friends and we want our picture taken together. I doubt if it was political, but they need to be careful because perception can be truth. Ask the NY Times.
(6)
(0)
LTC (Join to see)
Sir... my Dad was class of '67. We both spoke about it and agreed essentially that perception is reality. The mere fact that some could view it as a Black Panthers salute(prevalent in my Dad's era) is enough to show that this was not a wise idea. Even if this is a BLM salute or an innocuous sign of unity really doesn't matter as the overall perception has run its course and we are all already having heated debate about it.
Did they break any UCMJ articles? That I don't know. I'm not interviewing them, and as you stated, we lack context. That being said, they probably shouldn't have taken the photo in the first place. At the least, they are likely guilty of poor judgment.
Did they break any UCMJ articles? That I don't know. I'm not interviewing them, and as you stated, we lack context. That being said, they probably shouldn't have taken the photo in the first place. At the least, they are likely guilty of poor judgment.
(1)
(0)
Capt Tom Brown
LTC (Join to see) - Some have also pointed out the the swastika started off as a legitimate symbol of something ages ago but was also co-opted by people who turned it into a de facto symbol of hate genocide and worse. Same has happened to the clenched fist of solidarity, mutual support and common purpose. It is a kind of perverted genius to take a perfectly honest and good symbol, dress it in a black glove, and associate it with violence and belligerent protest.
(0)
(0)
i think they need to re take ethics in the military 101 again, because they clearly failed that class
(6)
(0)
Sir,
This picture does not convey intention. I think people should be allowed to take a picture and raise their arms in the air wearing a uniform. I am sure if all white males stood there doing that same fist pump it would not be offensive. That is the true test of acceptability today. If a white male can do it and nobody gets offended, then it must not be grounds for investigation. More funding should be directed toward the ideal ratio for demographics in pictures and giving massages to monkeys. ITS THE ONLY WAY.
If it is in fact a statement linked to Black Power from the 60s or the BLM of today, I would question the education they are receiving.
This picture does not convey intention. I think people should be allowed to take a picture and raise their arms in the air wearing a uniform. I am sure if all white males stood there doing that same fist pump it would not be offensive. That is the true test of acceptability today. If a white male can do it and nobody gets offended, then it must not be grounds for investigation. More funding should be directed toward the ideal ratio for demographics in pictures and giving massages to monkeys. ITS THE ONLY WAY.
If it is in fact a statement linked to Black Power from the 60s or the BLM of today, I would question the education they are receiving.
(6)
(0)
CPT Ahmed Faried
SCPO (Join to see) - "It has also been adopted by the BLM movement, which is very vocal about a racist agenda against white America"
Can you source any of this. You can even include a rightwing source if you'd like. Also you should have clicked on the link, the author is clearly biased, you would have agreed with his opinion.
Can you source any of this. You can even include a rightwing source if you'd like. Also you should have clicked on the link, the author is clearly biased, you would have agreed with his opinion.
(1)
(0)
2LT (Join to see)
CPT Ahmed Faried -
Sir,
This is a response to your post here and in the SPC's thread.
Read this link if you have a moment: http://lelav.blogspot.com/2016/05/having-black-unity-and-pride-as-black.html That was not an erroneous connection.
Bottom line, it is not my skin color that sends black people to jail, its their crimes. There is a demand problem for racism in America today. Meaning, there is not enough racism to fit the national narrative of systemic oppression ( at least in my lifetime. ) I acknowledge history is full of racism. White America did not invent it, but white America did end it. There is pride in that for me whose ancestors fought in every war this country engaged in, including the civil war in the iron brigade. To use that history as an excuse represents a lack of personal responsibility and belittles decades of hard work by this country including heroes like Martin Luther King. Please don't forget my history of the story though. It was not a history of my people oppressing yours, it was a history of my people fighting for the betterment of black America and keeping the country together.
The fact is that the problems protested by BLM are cultural problems, and does nothing to solve the reality of the black community's problems. In fact, it propagates the problems and allows race pandering by an entire segment of mainstream politics that promises more free stuff rather than a real solution to drag the culture into mainstream productive society. Obviously these are averages and there are exceptions. That does not negate the problem or the solution. There are plenty of poor, criminal white people as well. They also tend to vote a certain way.
When BLM protests the decay of the black family home, high rates of criminals, high black on white and black on black murder, and low rates of high school drop grads, then I will listen. Why is a black on white murder never a hate crime, even when it happens 10x more than the opposite? For now, they have no more substance behind the movement than the KKK or any other terrorist organization. There is never any talk about Asian privilege. Or why the white and Asian populations have to score 30% better on tests for the same college or advanced schooling. Asians fit the criteria of white male privilege even more so that whites. They make more money, they go to jail less ect... BLM directs its hate at the biggest target.
There is a study that says you have to do four things and you will not be poor in America. It's simple. 1) graduate high school. 2) don't have children before marriage 3) stay married 4) get a job out of high school, even a minimum wage job to start, and keep working at job after job until you retire. If those 4 things happen, you WILL NOT be poor in America. If that happens for 2 generations, the family an be millionaires.
I do not believe in subsidizing denial. Don't tell me I can't comment or understand because of my skin color. That is a racist argument based in your own bubble of hate. It seems that the group doing the protesting doesn't even understand the true cause of their "oppression." But go ahead, keep blaming my skin color like a RACIST, I will continue to work hard every day and succeed because for me that is the only option.
Sir,
This is a response to your post here and in the SPC's thread.
Read this link if you have a moment: http://lelav.blogspot.com/2016/05/having-black-unity-and-pride-as-black.html That was not an erroneous connection.
Bottom line, it is not my skin color that sends black people to jail, its their crimes. There is a demand problem for racism in America today. Meaning, there is not enough racism to fit the national narrative of systemic oppression ( at least in my lifetime. ) I acknowledge history is full of racism. White America did not invent it, but white America did end it. There is pride in that for me whose ancestors fought in every war this country engaged in, including the civil war in the iron brigade. To use that history as an excuse represents a lack of personal responsibility and belittles decades of hard work by this country including heroes like Martin Luther King. Please don't forget my history of the story though. It was not a history of my people oppressing yours, it was a history of my people fighting for the betterment of black America and keeping the country together.
The fact is that the problems protested by BLM are cultural problems, and does nothing to solve the reality of the black community's problems. In fact, it propagates the problems and allows race pandering by an entire segment of mainstream politics that promises more free stuff rather than a real solution to drag the culture into mainstream productive society. Obviously these are averages and there are exceptions. That does not negate the problem or the solution. There are plenty of poor, criminal white people as well. They also tend to vote a certain way.
When BLM protests the decay of the black family home, high rates of criminals, high black on white and black on black murder, and low rates of high school drop grads, then I will listen. Why is a black on white murder never a hate crime, even when it happens 10x more than the opposite? For now, they have no more substance behind the movement than the KKK or any other terrorist organization. There is never any talk about Asian privilege. Or why the white and Asian populations have to score 30% better on tests for the same college or advanced schooling. Asians fit the criteria of white male privilege even more so that whites. They make more money, they go to jail less ect... BLM directs its hate at the biggest target.
There is a study that says you have to do four things and you will not be poor in America. It's simple. 1) graduate high school. 2) don't have children before marriage 3) stay married 4) get a job out of high school, even a minimum wage job to start, and keep working at job after job until you retire. If those 4 things happen, you WILL NOT be poor in America. If that happens for 2 generations, the family an be millionaires.
I do not believe in subsidizing denial. Don't tell me I can't comment or understand because of my skin color. That is a racist argument based in your own bubble of hate. It seems that the group doing the protesting doesn't even understand the true cause of their "oppression." But go ahead, keep blaming my skin color like a RACIST, I will continue to work hard every day and succeed because for me that is the only option.

Fierce and Fabulous: Having BLACK UNITY and PRIDE as a black woman at WEST POINT and in...
Sweet. Mother. I don't even know where to start. There's my white privilege giving people the benefit of the doubt. Now If only the pesky band aids could be darker to make people feel accepted by society. 1)My favorite line is that they are above rebuke by anyone who does not believe in what they are doing, effectively dismissing all criticism. Must be nice to live in that subsidized bubble of ignorance. I guess I am not allowed to interpret...
(1)
(0)
CPT Pedro Meza
SCPO (Join to see) - Women have done this since recorder time: Ishtar (English pronunciation /ˈɪʃtɑːr/; Transliteration: DIŠTAR; Akkadian:
(0)
(0)
THIS IS WRONG as Two boys....No wait, I am retired and this is a new Army. All kidding aside this is wrong. As Soldiers we are to be above all this crap. Running the risk of being called names (and I really am not afraid of what anyone can type about me.) I would ask the "Black Lives Matter" folks, what part of "Obeying the Law Matters" do the majority of these folks that interacted with the Police not understand. By the way, more black lives are taken by black criminals in a weekend in Chicago or Detroit than have been taken by cops in years put together.
If you want to protest, TAKE OFF YOUR UNIFORM, find a job as a community organizer, and then go protest the Mayor of Chicago to put a stop to Black on Black crime before you crucify a cop that is trying to keep the peace.
If you want to protest, TAKE OFF YOUR UNIFORM, find a job as a community organizer, and then go protest the Mayor of Chicago to put a stop to Black on Black crime before you crucify a cop that is trying to keep the peace.
(5)
(0)
So if they were white cadets doing a German ww2 style salute would it be an extremist gesture? It's a posed picture they knew what they were doing someone needs to take action. I've seen enlisted Soldiers get hemmed up for trying to be funny and throwing gang signs while in uniform. What is the difference here the black lives matter movement has had more than a couple violent acts attributed to it and are a political movement. Further, I support the basic premise of the Black Lives matter movement however being a political movement when in uniform you can not endorse political movements. What kind of SH__storm would we see if these same Cadets showed up at a Trump rally in uniform?
(5)
(0)
SFC (Join to see)
LTC Joseph George - Basic premise of black lives matter treat all people equally however like you have mentioned to many people have used it as a pulpit for hatred and racism not equality. When it first popped up I was not against it but when violence and threats to police officers occurred I knew that it had been corrupted. My ponderings have led me to wonder when people will learn that real social change occurs more often with peaceful demonstration than violence... Ghandi, MLK, and even Liberia for that fact. However as I am sure you know change is one thing and revolution another.
(0)
(0)
SFC (Join to see)
CPT Ahmed Faried - Communist party 1922, Black Panther Movement, International Brigades, Hugo Chavez, Anarchist Black Cross, Communist Refoundation Party, Albanian, National Liberation Front, Librarians against DRM, Industrial Workers of the World and there are many others so in all regardless of whether they were showing support of Black Panthers or Librarians Against Digital Rights Mangement it is a political symbol that was adopted from an ancient sign of solidarity. They made a gaffe and just need counseling this should not effect the rest of their career as long as they take it as learning point of unintended consequences of their actions. The third and fourth order effects
(0)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Maj Rob Drury
SFC (Join to see) -
"...but when violence and threats to police officers occurred I knew that it had been corrupted."
BLM was never "corrupted." The peaceful equality was a sham. They were POS thugs from the beginning.
"...but when violence and threats to police officers occurred I knew that it had been corrupted."
BLM was never "corrupted." The peaceful equality was a sham. They were POS thugs from the beginning.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next