Posted on Sep 29, 2025
1LT Chaplain Candidate
3.61K
25
14
13
13
0
Consider an average discussion about self-defense, something civilians and vets can and should talk about. Then, consider how that discussion quickly leads to different types of defense. You might mention knives, and talk about the way knives are gripped, hanlded, and used and explain quickly that some pierce and some slice, but the point is to do damage and make an escape. People must be careful with knives because they can hit a bone or different parts of the flesh and end up hurting themselves in the process. Knives demand skilled use in terms of self-defense. Or, somebody mentions handguns, as they should. You quickly mention the difference in calibers and what their effect is, how some bullets enact enough force to put people down on the ground, some don't, some go through the body and some don't. All of this is part of an intelligent and responsible discussion about self-defense.

However, some consider this grotesque and unecessary. We don't need to be talking about the tearing and ripping of flesh, or hitting bones with knives, or putting people down. Fair enough. Yet, isn't that the age-old discussion around us military folk anyway? Violent things happen all around the world and we're often involved in them. We should talk about them. Yet, people's sensitivities to violence can often make this discussion hard to have.

How do you handle this? Do you tone it down, give a disclaimer, lean into it?
Posted in these groups: Refuse Self Defense
Edited 3 mo ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 7
Lt Col Charlie Brown
3
3
0
You're right, it's a very difficult discussion. I preface with, "this is just my point of view" and I don't get into specifics about handling weapons except to say, it is important to be comfortable and well trained on whatever method/weapon you choose. And if you choose "none" then make sure you are very alert and conscious of your surroundings at all times.
(3)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MSgt Electrical Power Production
2
2
0
I really don’t talk to anyone about it. I only worry about the safety of my family. What I have or what I know is nobody’s business. I say this only because of the world we live in today and the drastically different points of view. I will say I do carry a knife daily but I consider it only a tool. Must times I don’t even know it’s there.
(2)
Comment
(0)
SFC William Farrell
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MSgt Steven Holt, NRP, CCEMT-P
2
2
0
Unfortunately, I work with an 'ultra-liberal' individual. We tend to avoid such topics as they are a devout "we could live in Utopia if everyone would just give up guns" type person. We avoid those topics because they always end up offended and I end up in HR.

For the more reasonably minded, I usually tailor my comments to the audience at hand. Even then, it boils down to a version of "pick whatever device for defense you prefer and train until you are comfortable and proficient".
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close