How is it moral to have a new NCO to the unit pull extra duty watch on a Soldier who received UCMJ before that NCOs arrival?

What if that NCO is on staff duty? Technically aren't they on watch? To me, it's no big deal if that's the case. I'd also think about what the current mission of the unit is. If the unit is in the middle of a mission, then maybe they can't lose an NCO to extra duty watch and so that's the easiest thing to do. There can be so many reasons. To put a blanket statement to say if it's moral or not would be wrong. It all depends on the circumstances.

How is it moral? I'm sorry but that question makes no sense. It is the burden of leadership that requires NCOs to make sacrifices, including their time.
I hope that maybe you had a few too may before asking that in a public forum full of crusty old salts like me.

Ok I see I’ve struck a nerve in some individuals. Maybe the use of the word moral was t used properly. The real question is, in other units extra duty is watched by either the SDNCO or if there is an NCO serving on extra duty. Why is it that some units make the Soldiers immediate NCO support channel supervise him/ her on extra when there’s no NCO serving extra but staff duty is present? Does that clear things up a bit? I’m not saying that the Soldier should not have NCO supervision during his/ her punishment. And I can see the developmental benefit to the NCO on watch. Please don’t misunderstand. I know we all have a job to do. Why isn’t there one standard across the Army as a whole?

How is it not? Your an NCO, you are part of the unit, da goes with the territory! Buck up!

Your sins follow you.

bin there dune that. it`s there job to insure that every body is on the same page, [ knows there job ] no mater what.

So the Soldier that has extra duty is also being processed for a chapter. The NCO watch is coming from the Soldiers platoon. And the SMs original supervisor is still in the platoon just PCSing soon. The platoon is rotating watch between NCOs both old and new. My question is, why are the new NCO even in the mix if the soldier. There is no NCO on extra duty. I see this as unfair to NCO who did not commit the crime or even existed when the punishment was implemented. I want to fight this because I’m the PSG having to assigned these duties. Call me a newbie but I strongly believe if you didn’t commit the crime then why do the time. Soldiers can make there own decisions no matter how much development you do to him/her. And this one Soldier made the wrong one. But somehow NCOs who did in fact do their jobs still serve the punishment.

Not good, UCMJ is like a misdemeanor.