Posted on May 3, 2017
PFC Power Generation Equipment Repairer
115K
1.38K
598
53
53
0
3287a568
Posted in these groups: Running logo RunningP542 APFTImgres Physical Training
Avatar feed
Responses: 239
CPT Gurinder (Gene) Rana
0
0
0
Most of these responses are in Jest. We had this happen on a Record APFT once, the length was slightly longer and the stretch on one end of the field had an elevation just slightly over 3%. As officers we ran our butts off and made it in time, but a few stragglers got short changed. The MFT adjusted the time for all equally and suddenly all passed, with a few distinctions. Length and Grade of the course does indeed affect time, but it can be corrected at the Unit Trainer or MFT level, so why escalate?
(0)
Comment
(0)
CPT Gurinder (Gene) Rana
CPT Gurinder (Gene) Rana
>1 y
True; however, a MFT has the authority to correct an inaccurate course. This is also known as 'a course correction'.

Remember; not every issue is covered under a rule or regulation. Odd situations are decided within the parameters prescribed, by leaders. No one is perfect, so a course selected may not be as perfectly prescribed by rules. In such conditions, adjustments and course correction are best to overcome the inaccuracies or change the course and repeat the test.
(0)
Reply
(0)
CPO Hospital Corpsman
CPO (Join to see)
>1 y
Yes the MFT should help straighten out the command's course selection, but I do not believe the MFT has any authority to pencil whip the results. (Does it happen? Yes. Should it? Probably not as often as it does. Is it officially sanctioned? No.) The official answer is the APFT is invalidated and tossed out for everyone who ran the 2.13 mile course and everybody has to retake a new APFT administered properly.

I am curious how long this course has been in use and how many Soldiers have used it for their Record APFT. Using an extended course basically screws everyone that runs it. All Soldiers obtain longer run times then they should have, which results in lower APFT scores and fewer promotion points for Jr Enlisted. A lot Soldiers are also incorrectly assessed as failing on extended courses and wrongfully disciplined for the results of an invalid APFT - - which in turn results in more damage to, and the possible termination of, the Soldiers career. It costs money. It costs promotions. It costs careers.

I understand the tactic of operating at the lowest level possible and I'm aware of some of the many field expedient solutions that people come up with, but I don't think that is the answer for an inexperienced PFC seeking to get his command to obey regulations, follow established standards, and run a proper APFT.
(1)
Reply
(0)
CPT Gurinder (Gene) Rana
CPT Gurinder (Gene) Rana
>1 y
No leader in any military command bypasses his or her commanders; nor does the MFT pencil-whip changes. However, upon recommendation and with consent, the MFT makes course corrections on behalf of the Command. This is why units are assigned MFTs or units send NCOs for MFT certification.
(0)
Reply
(0)
CPT Gurinder (Gene) Rana
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
PO3 Grant Skiles
0
0
0
I am going to respond in this way. When I was in the NAVY I scored an Outstanding on every PT test. I also was invited to try out for the All Navy Softball team. We were underway and myself and 3 other shipmates could not make the tryouts. Even though I always scored an Outstanding and was athletically inclined I was also a part of the FAT BOY CLUB. My body fat was always just making the standard. I asked and received a chance to be measured when dropped into a water tank. There was a 7% difference to the better than being measured. Since the Navy at the time only recognized the tape measure way to determine body fat. I this fair NO but did I sit there and complain that I am kicking everyone ass in the PT but have to do extra work every day NO. I this soldier all that I can say is quit complaining because if you did not make the time then you have to work harder. The better that you are physically the better off that you will be when you encounter a real hardship.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Ernest Schroeder
0
0
0
Go to the Engineer BN an get a surveyor's wheel, also called a clickwheel, hodometer, waywiser, trundle wheel, measuring wheel or perambulator is a device for measuring distance. Next measure the course with one of your NCO's. Show your result's to the 1SG, if your right I an sure they will correct it by having you retake you APFT over using new course, and if you are not right well you just failed and got on someone's shit list.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Horizontal Construction Engineer
0
0
0
Yes dispute it, the problem with units who create their own standards is that no one knows what right looks like anymore. I can remember going from one unit to another or one base to another and not having to worry about not being within the standard. TRADOC for example, seems to have its own standard in certain situations that differentiate from the rest of the Army. Things like 2.13 mile runs for a pt test when the standard is 2.0 miles is small but a slippery slope. The 4 mile by 9 minute pace is also problematic because there are females who are allowed longer than 9 minutes per mile to pass their pt test. An example is that I am 37 years old and allowed 18:18 to run my 2 mile time. So if I met the standard for my 2 mile and averaged a 9:09 minute pace over 4 miles, I would fail the 4 miles by 36:00 with a time of 36:36. Though I am within the standard as big Army sees it, I have just failed a policy that I’ve yet to find outlined in FM 7-22. Perhaps I need to re-visit the FM for updates but I’m confident in my knowledge base. The old bullshit of “you can add to the standard but not take away” doesn’t fly anymore either because it is unenforceable via UCMJ. Something I’ve had to point out personally in the past. In the end, pt is an individual effort and the Army has pretty clear cut instructions on how a pt test is to be conducted and if the test is conducted as laid out, then the soldier either passes or fails. If the test isn’t laid out as specified then it is on the integrity of the leadership to ensure that every soldier is given the opportunity to re-take the test under the correct conditions. That’s the professionalism demanded of leaders regardless of personal opinions.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Jonathan Fretwell
0
0
0
Run faster. You should be striving to max your or test all the time
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Justin Wilbanks
0
0
0
I’ve seen a couple hundred Junior enlisted dispute the APFT, and every single one was told: “get the fuck away from me with your Air Force wannabe bullshit” and that’s the end of that..
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
PO1 Charles Babcock
0
0
0
If you failed it by less than the time it took you to run that .13 miles you might have an argument for taking it over. If you failed it by MORE than that time, you still failed.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Randall Smith
0
0
0
If you don't pass you're going to have to retake it anyway. I had to retake the PT test to graduate. I had a hard time on the bars. Why are these guys wearing shorts and t-shirts? We wore boots and fatigues for all PT.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SP5 Larry Morris
0
0
0
you either pass or you don't if not putting in the time then no one needs you quit crying train train or get out
(0)
Comment
(0)
CPO Hospital Corpsman
CPO (Join to see)
>1 y
Is that your same advice for all the Soldiers denied promotions, improperly flagged, erroneously separated from the Army, or otherwise screwed over by the command because leadership cannot figure out how to accurately measure 2 miles?
(0)
Reply
(0)
SP5 Larry Morris
SP5 Larry Morris
>1 y
I'm not being nasty or mean just saying that one needs to be up to what ever you have to do one can't wait too the last min then cry beceause you are not ready, no one in thjs world cares about you and one needs to take it and if one wants to go to nicks level then be up for it
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGM Mike Obrien
0
0
0
If you just train just make the minimum in anything, failure is waiting for you
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close