Posted on May 2, 2017
LTC Student
53.1K
2.22K
250
32
32
0
34319d2e
I wanted to open up the holistic/theoretical envelope and see what people wanted to change.
Don't feel constrained by the survey questions, just something to get the creative juices flowing.
Posted in these groups: Leadership abstract 007 LeadershipTumblr static tumblr mtb09amgp11s0247uo1 1280 Military LifeTrain2 Training
Avatar feed
See Results
Responses: 80
Votes
  • Newest
  • Oldest
  • Votes
SFC Retention and Transition NCO (USAR)
25
25
0
Treat Soldiers with more respect and not piss on them just because you can and thats the way you were treated. Thats why we have good Soldiers wanting to get out of the military so early in their careers. Because they have been bullied.
(25)
Comment
(0)
LTC Student
LTC (Join to see)
8 y
That's a very interesting response. I have always found that the best leaders are the ones that the Soldiers respect, because if they don't respect you they wont go the extra mile to make sure they, the unit and you are successful.
(1)
Reply
(0)
SGT Fdc Check
SGT (Join to see)
7 y
This is something I’ve been saying for awhile. Respect is different than being a soft and cuddly leader. You can be stern and “hardcore” yet still be a leader who listens to his soldiers, doesn’t constantly degrade them, and shows respect. A leader who shows respect, will get respect back from his soldiers. I’ve had a couple platoon sergeants that I respected a lot, and though I admit that I enjoyed my sham shield for a bit, once I had leaders I felt actually gave a damn about me, I found myself wanting to actually work for them. I would go the extra mile like you said to make sure things were done right because I wanted to make sure they looked good to their leadership as well. In a respectful chain, you all have each others back.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Ronnie Dawsey II
22
22
0
We need to stop with the pussifying of our soldiers. Today's BCT is shit. They have stress cards they can throw because the DS hurt their Itty bitty pussy feelings. Well, PVT Snowflake, if you didn't want to get yelled at you should have stayed the hell home. But you're in the army now, and Mommy isn't gonna come save you and put her tits in your mouth. Fugging PC BS...
(22)
Comment
(0)
SGT Cryptologic Linguist
SGT (Join to see)
7 y
As has been pointed out on numerous occasions, stress cards are an urban legend. Though I think you may be trolling anyway.
(4)
Reply
(0)
SSG In School
SSG (Join to see)
7 y
Just once would I like to the mythical stress card. Don't get me wrong, basic has wussified 10 fold since the early 90s.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
PO1 Brian Overman
19
19
0
The BMI is such bullshit. I had a guy in my reserve battalion who was and engineer for UP Railroad and an amateur bodybuilder. When competition season is in his body fat was at best 7% and hung around 12% in the off season. At the time of his discharge from the Navy he was told his BMI was to high... Almost 30%, even though he had recently win an amateur contest and spend most of his off time getting ready for the next competition. So, my question is...How is someone who is very visibly physically fit get a failing grade on his BMI enough times to be not allowed to reenlist to serve our great Nation?
(19)
Comment
(0)
SPC Tony Savarino
SPC Tony Savarino
7 y
Because they are calculating BMI with little more than a fucking measuring tape. That is the single most inaccurate and outright LAZIEST ways to determine BMI. You can get a faster and more accurate reading with a handheld fat loss monitor (Omron HBF306C) for $40 at Walmart and the results are displayed in under a minute.
(1)
Reply
(0)
SPC Erik Thompson
SPC Erik Thompson
7 y
I lifted weights my whole time in the Army. I maxed PU'S, SU's and my two mile run. I am 5'11" and weighed 195. I had a 33" waist and my 1st Sgt gave me grief every single day for almost a year.
(3)
Reply
(0)
CPL Cord Nipper
CPL Cord Nipper
7 y
SPC Erik Thompson That's bullshit. Any 1SG who has a soldier in your position should make you an example to the company of what to work towards.
The BMI is the biggest POS in fitness/health.
I'm 44. 5'8 and 185. Not as fit as I used to be but definitely not obese as the BMI says I am.
(2)
Reply
(0)
SPC Erik Thompson
SPC Erik Thompson
7 y
CPL Cord Nipper My first day in the company he said to me, "Your kinda big aren't you?" I merely referred him to my last PT test that I scored 300 on. He didn't care. Told me he didn't want "body builders" in his company.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Cryptographic Technician
19
19
0
Wow ! have things changed since basic training in 1967. I can remember DI's up your ass 24/7 helping you get mentally and physically fit. At the end of basic you were a better person or a washout. Force marches 5 miles full pack, running partway with your M14 over your head. Then a full set of PT before you could get into chow line everyday.
I may have a false impression but it sounds like things have gotten soft.
(19)
Comment
(0)
SSG Combat Engineer
SSG (Join to see)
7 y
Funny thing is, exactly what you described sounds soft. Everyone will always say in the end they had it worse.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Breck Wilson
17
17
0
Go back to pressing uniforms and shinning boots
(17)
Comment
(0)
CPL Cord Nipper
CPL Cord Nipper
7 y
I've been out over 20 years.
Yesterday I was putting on a pair of BDU pants to work in my yard.
I thought about how many hours I spent shining boots and ironing uniforms and the attention to detail it instilled.
Made me wonder what troops today do to fill the time.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Shoyn Jones
17
17
0
Promotion system and promote for knowing your job
(17)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MSgt George Cater
14
14
0
Get rid of that gawdawful current blue service uniform and make EVERYTHING worn on the uniform specific to and earned only by the individual, thus somewhat reducing the well noted gaudiness of the Army uniform.
(14)
Comment
(0)
MSgt George Cater
MSgt George Cater
7 y
I suppose you could wear your medals and such on your cammies for parades and such like some foreign armies, but I think most would agree there is some use and merit to at least a service uniform like Marine Greens for when cammies are just not appropriate. BTW, the current Marine forest greens are directly descended from our WW1 uniform with the standing collar turned down into lapels, replace the EGAs and adding the existing khaki shirt and tie. So one could say that the Corps complies with your suggestion. SGT Phil Smith
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Steve Daugherty
12
12
0
Make it difficult to quit during training, bring back remedial platoons in basic, to provide incentives to those who didn’t grow up in a culture of finishing what you started. Some of the best soldiers I knew came out of those platoons after a rocky start. I have a nephew who enlisted a few years ago and was home practically before getting through 3-4 weeks of training. You don’t make good soldiers without some discipline to harden them.
(12)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
FlorAnne Cruz
11
11
0
Active Duty CHIROPRACTORS!!! The military puts a toll on our bodies! Chiropractors can help prevent that & prevent the usage of pain meds, which just cover up the symptoms.
(11)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
1SG First Sergeant
11
11
0
I have two answers. One is a thing that needs to go away. The other is a system that needs a huge fix and overhaul.

PT belts need to go away. We all know it from the top to the bottom. Which bothers me even more about them. We all know that a PT belt isn't doing any good for safety during PT. Then we are wearing them in combat and other crazy places.

The system we need to have an overhaul on is the way we do assignments and sponsorship. I think assignments could be made better by creating some kind of a "job board". Something that shows open or soon to be open assignments. Where a Soldier could "apply" for the position. Let the leadership at the distant end look at a Soldiers record and decide who they want. An example of why I think this is needed is you have many Soldiers that would like to take on certain leadership roles and you have others that may what some staff time. But it seems like you also have some platoon sergeant who doesn't want to be there and some E7 in S3 dying to take over a platoon. Hand in hand with that would be sponsorship. It is definitely getting better in the 11 years I have been in the Army but I still think we could improve how it is handled. Some of the things a Soldier needs to do to in-process could be handled prior to arrival. i.e user account paperwork.
(11)
Comment
(0)
LTC Student
LTC (Join to see)
8 y
I appreciate the candid response, and I believe that you are right it is getting better but it will take time with everything. One bit of info for you is that there is currently a system in place for the unit on the distant end to view prospective candidates for a job, but it is only currently done for Joint Assignments at the MAJs level and above. I believe it could be easily implemented at a much lower level.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.