Your Response was posted! Click here to see it.
Posted on Nov 9, 2015
Michigan city elects first-ever Muslim majority city council. What is your immediate reaction?
2.41K
39
49
3
3
0
I think this is extraordinary, especially because we are in an era where distrust and/or hatred of Muslims or Arabs is seemingly de jure. With false claims of no-go zones or the sky is falling warnings of impending Sharia laws. What are your thoughts on this?
From the Christian Science Monitor:
http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/USA-Update/2015/1108/Michigan-city-elects-first-ever-Muslim-majority-city-council?cmpid=FB
The city of Hamtramck, an enclave of Detroit, made history this week when it became what is likely the first city in America to elect a Muslim-majority city council.
Historically Polish, the city of about 22,000 voted three Muslim Council candidates onto the six-member panel, one of whom was an incumbent Muslim council member not up for reelection this year. This means that the freshly formed council now has a two-thirds Muslim majority. The mayor, Karen Majewski, is Polish.
According to Bill Meyer, a Hamtramck community leader who isn’t Muslim, the incumbent Muslim councilmen have accomplished a lot for the city.
"[They’ve] helped bring stability, security and sobriety while lessening the amount of drugs and crime in the city,” he told the Detroit Free Press.
The election was also a landslide, he added. "The election was far from close, with the three Muslim winners each gaining over 1,000 votes, while the other three candidates garnered less than 700 votes each."
Many believe it’s the first time an American city has elected a Muslim majority city council, though the city itself has been under a similar spotlight before. In 2004, Hamtramck garnered heavy attention when the city council allowed a mosque to broadcast its call to prayer from loudspeakers. Opponents claimed it was an intrusion of Islam into their lives.
At that point, only one city council member was Muslim.
But Hamtramck’s Muslim population has been steadily growing, thanks to heightened immigration. Today it is estimated that half of Hamtramck is Muslim. According to University of Michigan-Dearborn professor Sally Howell, Hamtramck might have become the first city to have a Muslim majority in 2013.
“The growth is taking place in these Muslim communities, and they are transforming the city scape,” Howell told Washington Post. “It’s become much more visible in the last 15 years.”
In the early 20th century, Polish immigrants flocked to Hamtramck because of a Dodge Brothers plant built in 1914. By the 1970s, Polish-Catholics made up 90 percent of the city. But Asian and Arab immigrants began to settle there as the Poles moved to the suburbs. Most of them come from Bangladesh and Yemen.
The latest US Census surveys found that Hamtramck is now 24 percent Arab, mostly Yemeni, 19 percent African American, 15 percent Bangladeshi, 12 percent Polish, and 6 percent Yugoslavian. Out of the four new Muslim council members, three are Bangladeshi and one is Yemeni.
Getting to a Muslim majority wasn’t easy. In the past, Muslim candidates have been harassed, accused of terrorism, and some Bangladeshi voters were asked to show proof of citizenship by poll workers.
One of the winners Tuesday is Saad Almasmari, a 28-year-old student who received the highest percentage of votes – 22 percent. He moved to the US in 2009 and two years later, he became a US citizen.
At the end of the day for Hamtramck, he said, it’s not about religious unity.
“Although we are Muslims, it doesn’t have anything to do with serving the community,” Almasmari said. “It’s not about religion. It’s not about Muslim unity. We are planning to work for everyone.”
From the Christian Science Monitor:
http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/USA-Update/2015/1108/Michigan-city-elects-first-ever-Muslim-majority-city-council?cmpid=FB
The city of Hamtramck, an enclave of Detroit, made history this week when it became what is likely the first city in America to elect a Muslim-majority city council.
Historically Polish, the city of about 22,000 voted three Muslim Council candidates onto the six-member panel, one of whom was an incumbent Muslim council member not up for reelection this year. This means that the freshly formed council now has a two-thirds Muslim majority. The mayor, Karen Majewski, is Polish.
According to Bill Meyer, a Hamtramck community leader who isn’t Muslim, the incumbent Muslim councilmen have accomplished a lot for the city.
"[They’ve] helped bring stability, security and sobriety while lessening the amount of drugs and crime in the city,” he told the Detroit Free Press.
The election was also a landslide, he added. "The election was far from close, with the three Muslim winners each gaining over 1,000 votes, while the other three candidates garnered less than 700 votes each."
Many believe it’s the first time an American city has elected a Muslim majority city council, though the city itself has been under a similar spotlight before. In 2004, Hamtramck garnered heavy attention when the city council allowed a mosque to broadcast its call to prayer from loudspeakers. Opponents claimed it was an intrusion of Islam into their lives.
At that point, only one city council member was Muslim.
But Hamtramck’s Muslim population has been steadily growing, thanks to heightened immigration. Today it is estimated that half of Hamtramck is Muslim. According to University of Michigan-Dearborn professor Sally Howell, Hamtramck might have become the first city to have a Muslim majority in 2013.
“The growth is taking place in these Muslim communities, and they are transforming the city scape,” Howell told Washington Post. “It’s become much more visible in the last 15 years.”
In the early 20th century, Polish immigrants flocked to Hamtramck because of a Dodge Brothers plant built in 1914. By the 1970s, Polish-Catholics made up 90 percent of the city. But Asian and Arab immigrants began to settle there as the Poles moved to the suburbs. Most of them come from Bangladesh and Yemen.
The latest US Census surveys found that Hamtramck is now 24 percent Arab, mostly Yemeni, 19 percent African American, 15 percent Bangladeshi, 12 percent Polish, and 6 percent Yugoslavian. Out of the four new Muslim council members, three are Bangladeshi and one is Yemeni.
Getting to a Muslim majority wasn’t easy. In the past, Muslim candidates have been harassed, accused of terrorism, and some Bangladeshi voters were asked to show proof of citizenship by poll workers.
One of the winners Tuesday is Saad Almasmari, a 28-year-old student who received the highest percentage of votes – 22 percent. He moved to the US in 2009 and two years later, he became a US citizen.
At the end of the day for Hamtramck, he said, it’s not about religious unity.
“Although we are Muslims, it doesn’t have anything to do with serving the community,” Almasmari said. “It’s not about religion. It’s not about Muslim unity. We are planning to work for everyone.”
Edited 10 y ago
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 14
Non-issue. I won't hold a politician's Muslim faith against them any more than I will a politician's Christian or Jewish faith. Their job is to govern the city, not to convert it or force upon it religious laws. Honestly I am more concerned about Fundamentalist Christians than about moderate Muslims. Extreme fundamentalism in any faith is a very dangerous thing.
(6)
(0)
Based on their own words: "It’s not about religion. It’s not about Muslim unity. We are planning to work for everyone,” my reaction is "not a problem...maybe not even newsworthy." As long as their actions match their words, all is well, and this city will be better off as a result.
(3)
(0)
SGT Roberto Mendoza-Diaz
But Muslim is a religion not a race or a country. It's like saying a christian or a wican is running for mayor. Why not ask from what country that person is or what are their qualifications.
(0)
(0)
Sgt Kelli Mays
Col Joseph Lenertz SGT Roberto Mendoza-Diaz The question that should be asked is does this Mayor believe in Sharia law and or will they be trying to enforce it?
DEARBORN MICHIGAN...another suburb area around Detroit. They have a Sheriff who is Muslim and believes in Sharia law. There has already been a few investigations in DEARBORN and it's a town/city that is being watched by many.
Recently more than ONE news outlet has gone into Dearborn and interviewed folks there....and the MAJORITY of them favor Sharia law.
All I have to say is SHARIA law does NOT belong in the US....it has no business here.
Out of many of the interviews when asked since they prefer sharia law over the US constitution, and it's never going to be allowed to happen here, why do they stay. Most of them replied they stay because they LOVE the US and the freedom they have.
Isn't this contradicting themselves?
DEARBORN MICHIGAN...another suburb area around Detroit. They have a Sheriff who is Muslim and believes in Sharia law. There has already been a few investigations in DEARBORN and it's a town/city that is being watched by many.
Recently more than ONE news outlet has gone into Dearborn and interviewed folks there....and the MAJORITY of them favor Sharia law.
All I have to say is SHARIA law does NOT belong in the US....it has no business here.
Out of many of the interviews when asked since they prefer sharia law over the US constitution, and it's never going to be allowed to happen here, why do they stay. Most of them replied they stay because they LOVE the US and the freedom they have.
Isn't this contradicting themselves?
(0)
(0)
I don't agree with your initial statement and don't find it extraordinary that a majority Muslim district would elect a majority Muslim city council.
(2)
(0)
What is this de jure distrust or hatred of Muslims or Arabs? There may be a de facto disposition against Muslims, but the laws continue to operate in favor of protecting all religious practices. Ironically, doesn't the fact that such a notable election took place show that there is no de jure opposition to Muslims or Arabs?
(2)
(0)
CPT Ahmed Faried
I suppose another way of looking at this issue Sir is this. Will a person who was running for office, who happens to be muslim win in an area that wasn't majority Muslim? It may bot be codified but there certainly are major barriers for Muslims who want to run for office. We only have to look at the insinuations leveled at the President in regards to his faith to see what I'm referring to.
(0)
(0)
LTC (Join to see)
CPT Ahmed Faried, what you are describing is de facto, not de jure. The difference is significant.
I'm all but certain that Muslim candidates have been elected in non-majority Muslim jurisdictions. Even so, a candidate's electability is a function of the whole personality of the candidate; the people are entitled to vote for, and thereby elect, whoever they feel will best represent them. What are you proposing; that unsuccessful Muslim candidates be allowed to sue for and win an office if they can prove they lost the election because they are Muslim? That would be ridiculous.
Anti-discrimination laws extend to who can vote, run for, and hold office, but they do not extend to who wins elections. You seem to be looking for proportional representation, but that is not what this country is about.
I'm all but certain that Muslim candidates have been elected in non-majority Muslim jurisdictions. Even so, a candidate's electability is a function of the whole personality of the candidate; the people are entitled to vote for, and thereby elect, whoever they feel will best represent them. What are you proposing; that unsuccessful Muslim candidates be allowed to sue for and win an office if they can prove they lost the election because they are Muslim? That would be ridiculous.
Anti-discrimination laws extend to who can vote, run for, and hold office, but they do not extend to who wins elections. You seem to be looking for proportional representation, but that is not what this country is about.
(1)
(0)
CPT Ahmed Faried
LTC (Join to see) - Sir, I know some friends of mine that have had a hard time. Laws are one thing, their application, another. Your Representative Keith Ellisons are anomalies and even he was put through the ringer and was questioned on his allegiance. Something no other candidate who isn't a Muslim faces.
(0)
(0)
CPT Ahmed Faried Fine by me, so long as, like I would say about any religion, they're not trying to bring their religion into their governing. The vast majority of Muslims on the planet just want to live their lives...just like the vast majority of any group of humans.
(2)
(0)
Sgt Kelli Mays
SN Greg Wright - There have been several articles about it...and the sheriff gives orders to his deputies...most of which are NON Muslim to back off and not do anything about certain situations. ...I'll just keep my mouth shut about this for now.
(0)
(0)
SN Greg Wright
Sgt Kelli Mays - Why? If you're reporting facts, then people being offended by the nature of those facts will have to just deal with it.
(1)
(0)
Sgt Kelli Mays
SN Greg Wright - LOL Cause it'll just open another can of worms and I'll have to deal with those on the LEFT her make comments on it....and sometimes I just can't take the stress I get on this site. LOL
(0)
(0)
CPT Ahmed Faried
Sgt Kelli Mays - hardly an issue of "those on the left". You are making a claim that is popular among conservatives that Sharia law is a fact of life in some corners of the US. Please present proof.
(0)
(0)
Sgt Kelli Mays
Capt Seid Waddell I believe an eye should be kept on this city and on Dearborn Michigan too.
(1)
(0)
I'm not surprised. There is a huge Muslim population around the Detroit area.
DEARBORN MICHIGAN...another suburb area around Detroit. They have a Sheriff who is Muslim and believes in Sharia law. There has already been a few investigations in DEARBORN and it's a town/city that is being watched by many.
Recently more than ONE news outlet has gone into Dearborn and interviewed folks there....and the MAJORITY of them favor Sharia law.
All I have to say is SHARIA law does NOT belong in the US....it has no business here.
Out of many of the interviews when asked since they prefer sharia law over the US constitution, and it's never going to be allowed to happen here, why do they stay. Most of them replied they stay because they LOVE the US and the freedom they have.
Isn't this contradicting themselves?
DEARBORN MICHIGAN...another suburb area around Detroit. They have a Sheriff who is Muslim and believes in Sharia law. There has already been a few investigations in DEARBORN and it's a town/city that is being watched by many.
Recently more than ONE news outlet has gone into Dearborn and interviewed folks there....and the MAJORITY of them favor Sharia law.
All I have to say is SHARIA law does NOT belong in the US....it has no business here.
Out of many of the interviews when asked since they prefer sharia law over the US constitution, and it's never going to be allowed to happen here, why do they stay. Most of them replied they stay because they LOVE the US and the freedom they have.
Isn't this contradicting themselves?
(1)
(0)
Sgt Kelli Mays
PO1 John Miller CPT Ahmed Faried - Haddad.....not Muslim? Okay...Then I wonder why the program I watched Some special on Dear born and Muslims state this and this article.
If it's true, then I stand corrected.
If it's true, then I stand corrected.
(1)
(0)
CPT Ahmed Faried
Sgt Kelli Mays - Haddad is a popular Lebanese name. Most Lebanese are Christian, though some are Muslim.
(1)
(0)
PO1 John Miller
Sgt Kelli Mays and CPT Ahmed Faried
My home state of Michigan, and particularly Dearborn, has the largest population of Arab Americans per capita in the country. Many of them immigrated in the early 20th century to work in the automotive industry as Dearborn is the home of the Ford Motor Company.
As CPT F. stated, a majority of Lebanese are Christians. So though they are Arab and have Arab names, they are not Muslim.
My home state of Michigan, and particularly Dearborn, has the largest population of Arab Americans per capita in the country. Many of them immigrated in the early 20th century to work in the automotive industry as Dearborn is the home of the Ford Motor Company.
As CPT F. stated, a majority of Lebanese are Christians. So though they are Arab and have Arab names, they are not Muslim.
(1)
(0)
Not surprised by this as Michigan has been a state where Muslims seem to move to. Was only a matter of time for Michigan.
(0)
(0)
nothing... wait until what they are doing something then I will start "making decision". :)
(0)
(0)
Read This Next

Islam
Politics
Government
