Posted on Sep 30, 2022
My previous NCOER had me rated qualified but had me ranked 2 of 3 SSG's. Does this make any sense?
Suspended Profile
4.09K
12
6
My previous NCOER from my recent unit under the Senior Rater comments had me rated 2 of 3 as a SSG but put qualified. I spoke with my PSG and they stated that even though it says qualified the rater comments will make it sound like highly qualified (is that true?). However, my NCOER before had the same thing but had me as highly qualified. I have never received any article 15's, GOMARs, or anything negative in my records. Will this negatively affect me when I get looked at for SFC? I have 101 college credits (still working towards my degree), Drill Sergeant, and a lot of military schools.
Posted in these groups: 
Promotion Board
Human Resources
Senior Human Resources NCO (S1)
Board Member
HRC
Promotion Board Human Resources Senior Human Resources NCO (S1) Board Member HRC
Posted 2 y ago
Responses: 5
What did the senior rater comments say about promotion?
-Promote immediately?
-Promote ahead of peers?
-Any sentence with the word "promote"?
-Promote immediately?
-Promote ahead of peers?
-Any sentence with the word "promote"?
Number one, the NCOER says what it says. Boards fully understand the duties and responsibilities, they also understanding how ratings work. While your NCOER does not sound to be oustanding it does not berate you.
The board sees a great deal of documentation and makes decisions based on the total package, Dow stage NCOER have an impact, certainly it does, so does everything else.
What you now need to focus on is outperforming your peers, seek council with the senior rater an ask what it is in there eyes that placed you where they did. From there you and your rater can establish a plan. BTW, it is the senior eaters responsibility to council you on your rating anyway.
The board sees a great deal of documentation and makes decisions based on the total package, Dow stage NCOER have an impact, certainly it does, so does everything else.
What you now need to focus on is outperforming your peers, seek council with the senior rater an ask what it is in there eyes that placed you where they did. From there you and your rater can establish a plan. BTW, it is the senior eaters responsibility to council you on your rating anyway.
If you were rated as 2 out of 3 that means you are in the middle third of of your peers. That's not highly qualified, that's qualified. That is middle of the pack among your peers.
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google