Should a 4-year degree be a requirement for selection to E-9?
We shall have to agree to disagree on this one. However, I do appreciate the fact that you took the time to respond to my question. I did not realize that there was no notice given when someone responded to you, so I am no going back through to make sure I did not miss any.
Now, should it be a requirement, no. One thing though, if they make it a requirement via the regulations for SGM, CMSgt, or Master Chief...they have to pay for it...and with the way budget cuts are around, downsizing, and all that, I doubt DoD will cut out a budget to pay 100% for E-9s to have a Bachelor degree. Also, if and when they make it a requirement, they have to provide the time for the E-8 (or lower ranks) to get it.
I propose that while not necessarily our job, it is possible for us to do both. And you SGM stand as an example of this fact. Granted most of us accomplish it where and when we can, but we get it done.
As an educator, a Reserve SGM, and someone who has an M.Ed. and a post-grade certificate in educational administration, I would say that definitely having a B.A. or B.S. should be required. By the time a Soldier makes E8/9 they have had long enough to earn a degree. I believe that a education not only makes you better prepared for new things but also helps one to experience new ways to learn and comprehend the broader world versus the narrow way of the military. And, it makes you more marketable once you decide to retire. Your Army experience may look nice once you retire but I know for a fact that companies are looking for civilian education, too.
Is it hard to get one? Yes. Does it take time and commitment? Absolutely. But, in today's world, it is absolutely critical to have an education beyond high school. And, I don't think colleges should grant credit for military experience. Go out and learn something that interests you beyond just the military. It will help you no matter what area you choose and which branch you serve in. If you want to get promoted, get a degree. It's not the 1960's anymore where a Soldier could get by with a high school diploma, GED or even no degree.
Just my two cents...