Posted on Jan 30, 2014
Should service members wear their duty uniform to civilian courts? is it a dishoner to the service? Personal gain for yourself or is it ok
72.9K
57
19
3
3
0
Edited >1 y ago
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 15
I'm very disturbed at the automatic assumption that just because a service member is a defendant, they're automatically guilty.
(9)
(0)
CMDCM Gene Treants
I agree. The entire justice system of America is based on the Assumption of Innocence! Somewhere along the way we have all lost sight of that.
(0)
(0)
<p>Actually quite a few years back up until about mid-90s, whenever SMs had to go to court whether it was for positive or negative reasons, they were required to wear their class A's to court, than many units converted to wearing the duty uniform from BDUs to ACUS, it has just evolved over the years.</p><p><br></p><p>While some may think it could be derogatory to the military, the mentality was to show you were proud of your service and were willing to show that pride and take your punishment like a Soldier/Marine/Airman/Sailor/Coast Guardsman and still represent the best of the best. It did become sort of a plus at times for receiving leniency for negative court appearances and the judge for your service to country, so it did/does have some benefit.</p><p><br></p><p>In recent years though it has many times resulted in negative results as many judges will state you should no better because of what you represent and then proceeds to max you out on the fine and penalties.</p>
(8)
(0)
The question is this: Claimaint, witness, or defendant?<br><br>In civil/family court for divorce, custody, claims, and so forth I see little issue wearing the uniform that states your position in society. Who you are matters a great deal in those cases.<br><br>As a witness? It lends additional credibility, so most definitely.<br><br>As a defendant? I understand why someone would want the personal gain but ... come on, guy ... really? Isn't it bad enough you're in court already? Don't drag Uncle Sam in there with you, he didn't make you do it. That aside, I can imagine a number of situations in which military status might have some positive bearing on an innocent service member being on trial. Just don't wear it if Chris Hanson brought you here.
(8)
(0)
SFC(P) (Join to see)
That is exactly my point. I hear soldiers all the time saying "I got out of this infraction case becuase I was in uniform". makes me think about how society looks at us.
(1)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
What about if you are innocent of what you're accused of doing, SSG Beutler? If you're innocent, and you're pleading not guilty, why not use the uniform for more credibility? You're not going to tell me no service member has ever been wrongfully convicted of anything in civilian court...
(5)
(0)
Read This Next