Posted on Aug 9, 2016
Waiting in the ER - at what point does waiting become unacceptable?
13.5K
138
66
16
16
0
Responses: 35
Consider yourself lucky if you are waiting. Its the patient's who are being hurried back that are having an emergency. An emergency is something that is a threat to life, limb, or eye sight. It is not a sore throat, back pain, migraine, or an STD. The reason waits are so long is that ERs are overused and abused by people without true emergencies and who do not utilize primary care. Do not begrudge the medical providers - you are triaged and seen by order of importance and severity. If the sore throat has been waiting for 8 hours, they will not be seen before the chest pain patient simply because they got there sooner. If you have a non emergent issue, an urgent care or primary care is more appropriate and will free up the ER to do what they are there for - EMERGENCIES.
(12)
(0)
SGM Erik Marquez
CPT (Join to see) - I do use Homeopathic options when i think I may have an onset, or have the initial onset... it rarely works.
Cherry juice, even to the amounts causing intestinal distress work to delay the severe symptoms, so that helps, but does not remove enough uric acid to stop the attack.
Apple cider vinegar, cherry juice, diet change.
Unfortunately Im assigned to a MTF staffed with civilians and select Mil folks. And it is what it is...urgent care is just not a provided option, no matter how much sense it makes.
Cherry juice, even to the amounts causing intestinal distress work to delay the severe symptoms, so that helps, but does not remove enough uric acid to stop the attack.
Apple cider vinegar, cherry juice, diet change.
Unfortunately Im assigned to a MTF staffed with civilians and select Mil folks. And it is what it is...urgent care is just not a provided option, no matter how much sense it makes.
(0)
(0)
CPT (Join to see)
SGM Erik Marquez I'm really disappointed to hear that about your access to care. I always tried to hook up my commanders, 1SGs, staff, and senior commanders because y'all never have a set schedule to where you can stick to appointments.
I just left Hood, but if I was still there I would have been more than happy to hook you up.
I just left Hood, but if I was still there I would have been more than happy to hook you up.
(0)
(0)
SGM Erik Marquez
CPT (Join to see) - This is post retirement.
While in, I had world class treatment, even if not from a "PCM" as we had huge Doc shortages. I had NO complaints with Med services while in, from privet though SGM.
The last few years I had direct access to the Div Surgeon, and My position was always the same,,,, I want nothing the private does not have, if they can not get it, why should I...I dont want it because of who I am, I want it because Im a US Soldier.
While in, I had world class treatment, even if not from a "PCM" as we had huge Doc shortages. I had NO complaints with Med services while in, from privet though SGM.
The last few years I had direct access to the Div Surgeon, and My position was always the same,,,, I want nothing the private does not have, if they can not get it, why should I...I dont want it because of who I am, I want it because Im a US Soldier.
(0)
(0)
Maj John Bell
SGM Erik Marquez - I left service before earning medical retirement benefits, so I know nothing of Tri-care. However the rural Family Practice clinic I use will issue scripts for non-narcotic and non anti-biotic meds for chronic conditions after a phone interview with a nurse practitioner or physician's assistant. Hours are 0600-2200. I phone in and they typically return the call within 20 minutes, usually with in 10 minutes. It might be worth while to see if something similar is offered by a different Family Practice in your area.
(0)
(0)
when the agony of the wait overcomes the ailment that brought you to the ER.
(9)
(0)
The only time I go to the ER is if I'm in pain above my typical tolerance level. The last time was years ago for kidney stone. That was a good 6 hours of agony. Did I want to get seen ASAP? Of course. However, as a former Corpsman, I know how triage works and I'm a bit more patient, even when I'm in pain.
(7)
(0)
The ER is for emergencies, think heart, brain, lungs or prevent loss of life , limb, or eyesight. If you are there for any other reason (sniffles, my knee hurts, etc), you will wait, wait for those who are there, triaged by urgency, to be seen first. If a same day sick call, urgent care type clinic available, use that.
(6)
(0)
CPT (Join to see)
When I've had to wait for (non-life threatening pain) including clavicle fracture, complex regional pain syndrome, I've had a pretty long wait. When I've had eye complaints (foreign bodies, corneal abrasions, etc.) I've been seen immediately. They don't mess around with life, limb, or eyesight.
(0)
(0)
The challenge here is process. A huge numbers of ER visits could have been appropriately dispositioned by the Primary Care team IF they can get access (same-day) appointments. While there are certainly some cases that MUST be managed by the ER, there are huge volumes of low acuity (not very sick peeps) that sit in ER beds resulting in low throughput (longer wait times). At our ED, the busiest in the state, about 30% of patients get admitted to the hospital (due to risk aversion or significant illness/injury). Those beds stay filled until a hospitalist/specialist come to admit them. This has given rise to the "minute clinic" or "urgent care" business where rapid assessments and quick dispositions are business models and drive profits (for those with cash and/or great insurance). The ER sees you regardless of severity of illness and ability to pay....they come in droves, and camp out. George, I feel your pain....and mine is greater.
To your point, average times are tough to compute because boarders skew the data. The facts are these. Wait times are going up. Obamacare has increased access to care, but often inappropriate access via emergency rooms rather than primary care.
Peeps get triaged by priority, not by wait time. That said, the scariest patient and sometimes the sickest, is the dude rotting in the waiting room... It is a national problem.
To your point, average times are tough to compute because boarders skew the data. The facts are these. Wait times are going up. Obamacare has increased access to care, but often inappropriate access via emergency rooms rather than primary care.
Peeps get triaged by priority, not by wait time. That said, the scariest patient and sometimes the sickest, is the dude rotting in the waiting room... It is a national problem.
(6)
(0)
CPT(P) (Join to see)
I concur !
There is no hard and fast answer on this topic.
While we often have to practice on the fear of litigation and missing something because we are not their PCP's (for the less emergent cases) - it makes ER wait times just hang in the balance. I always felt the sickest people are the most quiet about their complaints... To their sometimes unfortunate demise. So sad - so backwards too.
There is no hard and fast answer on this topic.
While we often have to practice on the fear of litigation and missing something because we are not their PCP's (for the less emergent cases) - it makes ER wait times just hang in the balance. I always felt the sickest people are the most quiet about their complaints... To their sometimes unfortunate demise. So sad - so backwards too.
(2)
(0)
SGT Tim Soyars
I absolute agree. The other problem is admissions. This should be a "pull through" process, but delays in discharges, bed readiness, and unit staffing have made it a "push through". Who losses? The patients who truly need our care.
(1)
(0)
CPT Lawrence Cable
The local hospital runs an "Urgent Care Clinic" beside the hospital that bleeds off most of the non Emergency types with Insurance. I use it sometimes instead of my family physician simply because you normally can get in, seen and out in a timely manner, so if you have something like a sinus infection, it just makes since. Time of day makes a huge difference with ER's. I laid my knee open back enough that I knew it was going to require stitches, so I rolled into the ER about 5AM. No one else was there and only one doctor on duty. I was seen, stitched and out in a timely manner.
I won't talk about what they charged for that half hour of care.
I won't talk about what they charged for that half hour of care.
(0)
(0)
SFC (Join to see)
SGT (Join to see) - Thanks. I only do one show per day. Please bus your own table and tip your wait staff.
(0)
(0)
This is a good question for some of our loyal medical & nursing staff. Maybe Col Dona Marie Iversen and Col Rebecca Lorraine as well as others of our medical members can offer insights on endless waits in the emergency room, whether VA or local hospital.
(4)
(0)
SGT Tim Soyars
As a paramedic and ED RN for over 30 years, I see a large part of the problem is the improper use of the ED for minor issues and as someone's primary care provider (PCP). I have literally asked a patient who their PCP was and have them give me the name of one of our ED Doc's. I have even had a parent with a child show up and request a sports physical. This at an ED (trauma, stroke, and cardiac center) that saw over 100,000 patients a year! And then they will complain because we took the chest pain patient back first.
(4)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Col Dona Marie Iversen
Capt Tom Brown missed this conversation earlier, note to self wear glasses when on computer.
As a former Emergency Dept. (ED) nurse and a hospital clinical operations administrator...
Hospitals , ED's and staff are held accountable and responsible to and for regulatory standards. ALL patients must be triaged within minutes of arriving, the metrics for "door to triage" and "triage to treat" are required to be reported.
Triage is classified as urgent, emergent and routine. Loss of life, limb or site is urgent, chest pain or evolving stroke is emergent and tooth aches or "I need my birth control pills" are routine.
Many visit the ED as if it's a clinic or PCP office which bottlenecks the ED.
Waiting greater then 30 minutes for a routine visit is unacceptable unless of cause there is a multi trauma event...
As a former Emergency Dept. (ED) nurse and a hospital clinical operations administrator...
Hospitals , ED's and staff are held accountable and responsible to and for regulatory standards. ALL patients must be triaged within minutes of arriving, the metrics for "door to triage" and "triage to treat" are required to be reported.
Triage is classified as urgent, emergent and routine. Loss of life, limb or site is urgent, chest pain or evolving stroke is emergent and tooth aches or "I need my birth control pills" are routine.
Many visit the ED as if it's a clinic or PCP office which bottlenecks the ED.
Waiting greater then 30 minutes for a routine visit is unacceptable unless of cause there is a multi trauma event...
(1)
(0)
Unfortunately, ER's do not work on the "First come, First served" method. You will be seen based on the severity of your condition. Depending on patient density, that may be 10 minutes, it may be 10 hours. Be glad you are being made to wait. It means you are not in immediate danger of dying right then.
Incidentally, just because you arrive by ambulance does not mean you will be seen faster either. I've put dozens of patients in the triage waiting room to wait. The look on their face is priceless!
Incidentally, just because you arrive by ambulance does not mean you will be seen faster either. I've put dozens of patients in the triage waiting room to wait. The look on their face is priceless!
(2)
(0)
Read This Next


Medical
Patient
Health
