Posted on Dec 17, 2013
What will be our Vietnam Wall Memorial for OIF/OEF?
58.2K
210
124
18
18
0
I love the wall in DC. Feels like you are walking on holy ground. I have seen numerous make shift, temporary, unit or event specific memorials for our fallen in these two wars. Is there a project in the making for a more permanent, all inclusive design
What would you like to see? A wall or something else?
I'd love to see some brainstorming and maybe even some personal stories on here from those who have lost a friend/family member to these wars.
Also should it be a combined memorial or one for each war?
What would you like to see? A wall or something else?
I'd love to see some brainstorming and maybe even some personal stories on here from those who have lost a friend/family member to these wars.
Also should it be a combined memorial or one for each war?
Edited 12 y ago
Posted 12 y ago
Responses: 48
(25)
(0)
Sgt James Quinn
Also a "Dog Tag Display" at the Harold Washington Library in Downtown Chicago. Type in a name and it will show you a brief profile, maybe a picture, and the general area of the dog tag display where that name 's dog tag is located ! Very impressive. Jim Quinn (Sgt.
USMC Mike 3/5...RVN 1968)
USMC Mike 3/5...RVN 1968)
(4)
(0)
SSG Charles Pursley
SSG. Charles Pursley Vietnam War VeteranTo: 1SG Johnny what's Ground Zero got to do with my BROTHERS & SISTERS who died in Nam this country denied us of our HONOR now you want to mess with OUR WALL and other Memorials don't mess with what little Honor we have received
(4)
(0)
CPL Jerald Nott
I would like to find out the travel schedule for the traveling Vietnam wall. I would love to see it being I probably will never get to Washington,DC.
(0)
(0)
<p>I haven't seen anything in the works for OIF/OEF yet but it is definitely coming.</p><p> </p><p>I've visited all of the memorials in DC mutliple times and I am always struck by what the design and execution of each says about the conflict and the general populations views.</p><p> </p><p>World War I Memorial - only for DC area WW I vets and, up until only a couple of years ago, abandoned and forgotten in a corner of the Mall.</p><p> </p><p>World War II Memorial - big, loud, and ostentatious . . . it screams "We kicked a**!"</p><p> </p><p>Korean War Memorial - a little bit somber bur forceful . . . it says "we did something important and necessary but it wasn't easy."</p><p> </p><p>Vietnam Wall - heart wrenching . . . "we failed in our objective but it was not through any fault of those who served and made the ultimate sacrifice."</p><p> </p><p>OIF/EOF Memorial? I think it is still too soon to tell. The public has been overwhelmingly supportive of the soldier/marine/sailor/airmen while often being very critical of the government for our involvelment. It will be interesting to see what the final product says about 'our war'. </p>
(19)
(0)
CPL Jerald Nott
[ ~1649372: SPC Ralph Starr] - I was a clerk-typist handling medical records of wounded from Vietnam at Camp Drake, Asaka, Japan 7/68 to 7/70. There were 3 or 4 Army hospitals in Japan, mine was ten miles north of Tokyo. My brother was in the Navy on a destroyer and my dad was in the "Battle of the Bulge".
(1)
(0)
CPL Jerald Nott
SPC (Join to see) - I worked in Medical Records at Camp Drake hospital at Asaka, Japan 7/68 to 7/70. It was around ten miles north of Tokyo. Two guys I worked with were John Skaggs and Alva Walston.
(1)
(0)
SPC (Join to see)
Oh I thought you were a medic in Vietnam where I was A company 15th Medical Bttn. part of the 1st Calvary Airborne Division 1965-1966 I then served state side in the *@nd Airborne Div. until my ETS in Jan. 1968
Thank You for the response and good travels
Marvin
Thank You for the response and good travels
Marvin
(1)
(0)
CPL Jerald Nott
You are welcome. I have been searching for a couple of Army buddies I worked with at Camp Drake hospital for a few years now. They are John Skaggs and Alva Walston.
(0)
(0)
There should be two memorials but they should be co-located. I think they should also be in D.C. Not sure what it should be but I'd leave the wall for Vietnam and come up with something else.
(13)
(0)
MAJ (Join to see)
You don't think it should be a memorial for each war? Â They are different. Â Why combine them?
(4)
(0)
SSG (Join to see)
I agree with you sir, two memorials co-located in D.C. . It is the same war but it is not the same campaign. I guess we have to pull out of the war before a memorial goes up first. Â
(5)
(0)
(4)
(0)
SGT Aaron Cordial
I believe they should have one of each. And I believe DC should be the main location due to it would be cheaper to the tax payer for the cost.
(1)
(0)
I think the problem with calling in a GWOT memorial is I dont think that war will ever end.
(4)
(0)
(1)
(0)
SSG Robert Burns
Well since out country considers school bullies terrorists now then you may be right.
(1)
(0)
SGT Ben Keen
That is true but then again how is a terrorist defined? Â Is it only a battle against terrorism if the battle starts in a certain part of the country or were the citizens of the colonies considered to be terrorists against Britain or couldn't the Confederate Army have been labeled as terrorists against the United States as well?
Like I mentioned before, this new era of fighting against multiple fronts against what most would consider different enemies will make things such as coming up with a memorial a little difficult. Â Either way, I say find the ground, get the money and let's get this roll! Â I don't want to be 78 years old and visiting a moment built for us for the first time.
(1)
(0)
No it should NEVER BE COMBINED...
2 wars 2 DIFFERENT AMERICAN HOMECOMING RESPONSES...
VIETNAM VETERANS WERE TREATED LIKE THEY DIDN'T BELONG HERE..
OEF... BIG ASS PARADE...
TOO MUCH DIFFERENCE TO BE COMBINED..
2 wars 2 DIFFERENT AMERICAN HOMECOMING RESPONSES...
VIETNAM VETERANS WERE TREATED LIKE THEY DIDN'T BELONG HERE..
OEF... BIG ASS PARADE...
TOO MUCH DIFFERENCE TO BE COMBINED..
(3)
(0)
CPL Jerald Nott
Back in the early 70s, our country was in turmoil. Now, people are thanking all veterans, including Vienam veterans, for their service.
(0)
(0)
This week the 101st placed a donated combat boot for every service member, regardless of service or unit killed since September 11th on the lawn of division headquarters in the dated order of ultimate sacrifice. I went through the formation of more than 8000 boots and found many aviator friends who I personally served next to who sacrificed. I gave each of them a few moments of my time and prayer and after a couple of hours was able to leave with fond memories of each of them.
This Saturday at Fort Campbell, beginning at 0830, there will be a 5k walk/run where all 8000 plus boots are repositioned along the entire route of the run to honor and memorialize these fine Americans. It is temporary, but a huge service of honor these folks have put on. Each boot has a flag, photo, name, service and date of sacrifice and location. Some have been visited and left with writings on the boots and gifts. An amazing feat.
This Saturday at Fort Campbell, beginning at 0830, there will be a 5k walk/run where all 8000 plus boots are repositioned along the entire route of the run to honor and memorialize these fine Americans. It is temporary, but a huge service of honor these folks have put on. Each boot has a flag, photo, name, service and date of sacrifice and location. Some have been visited and left with writings on the boots and gifts. An amazing feat.
(3)
(0)
I feel that they should be separated. Each memorial reminds us of the many differences in each action. All those who served should be acknowledged for their duty in a way unique to that war.
(2)
(0)
PO1 Arthur L. Overbey
A very well stated fact that we have been over looking while talking about construction of future memorials. I was an HM3 in 1965, In 1967 I entered country as an HM2 and before leaving country I was an HM1, I saw way to much lose of life and wounded disabling injuries to last a life time. On one operation alone we lost 9 corpsmen from the Battalion. As far as the Wall goes I have been there 5 times and every single time it has felt like the first and every single time I end up crying like a baby just remembering all of my Marines and corpsmen that died for our Country. May God Bless all Vets for their service.
(0)
(0)
I believe that our fallen should be recognized and memorialized in public places. If combined, then there should be separate sections representing different conflicts.
(2)
(0)
MY two cents as a Vietnam Era vet. In a very real sense OIF/OEF are not over. Combat forces are still in theater, still fighting. Even when they finally all come home, the conflict that are a part of is likely to remain very much ongoing. Regardless, it will take some years before we have the proper perspective. None of the newer ones were established quickly. Korea was authorized in 1986 with ground broken in 1992. WWII was not opened until 2004, and Vietnam a relatively short 17 years opening in 1982.
(2)
(0)
Having visited the wall in Washington does in fact feel like it's hallowed ground, very emotional seeing Brothers name's, those know, and unknown is difficult, so I reflect on the times of cursing, and laughing. Since that time I've been blessed with two magnificent children, however since they are both special needs children, the possibility of seeing the Vietnam Memorial in DC is a long shot at best, so the traveling Wall provides the opportunity to have them see the names of those who gave their final full measure, and this is my way of sharing their lives, and not just a name on a Wall. Simply my opinion.
(2)
(0)
Read This Next

Memorial
Operation Enduring Freedom (OEF) - Afghanistan
Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF)
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)


