Posted on Jul 6, 2016
SA Tony Minton
61.5K
61
49
2
2
0
Posted in these groups: Ribbons banner2 MedalsUs medals Awards524395 331088503647420 191451722 n Stolen Valor
Avatar feed
Responses: 43
MCPO Anthony Cole
19
19
0
I have actually done this, I had an individual who was a past commander of our VFW post, I was talking to him one day, he is a year younger than me, mid 40s. He didn't know me from Adam, but the first thing he says is he's a SEAL, did all these top secret missions etc. I asked him his class number, as I went to BUDS 201, and he says he has to go. A while later I became the Quartermaster and those who sit in some way as a board member I require their DD214. He gave me his and on it said Navy SEAL, closed and top secret record, and it was in different type. I am a retired Command Master Chief and in looking at his 214 I could see he exited the military from an F14 squadron. So I call a friend in records, and under the POIA I get his real DD214. Now I could have brought it up at a meeting, and wanted to since good friends who actually were SEALs had died and it really pisses me off. I also learned that the only reason many liked him and voted him in was due to his awesome record and such. I decided to just sit him down and advised him first that we would no longer need his services on the board and since he was drinking heavily again I would not allow him to drink here (he has 8 DUIs and just got out of prison and I don't want him to kill himself or someone else, and our VFW would be found liable), and then I just left him an envelope with the real 214 inside, I said don't open it till later, but you're lucky I don't whip your ass for this, good men have died who earned that trident and the one person who should be the most proud of their service is the person that served. I haven't seen him around to much since and every time I'm there he turns around and leaves.
(19)
Comment
(0)
PFC Rick Phillips
PFC Rick Phillips
>1 y
My dad was a master cheif on a destroyer and he passed away shortly after he retired. I was at Ft Belvoir Va for AIT and my First Sgt approached me and handed me a leave packet. My dad was transferred to Walter Reed in his last few days. Thanks for your story it made me think of him he gave over half of his life to the United States Navy. To this day I haven't met a tougher man than him. I don't know if he was ever a seal but he had so many stripes and hashes (I think that they are called). Not to mention the seventeen tons of ribbons upon his chest. I was in my Pvt 32nd uniform with all three ribbons and my expert M16 badge . I never saw him so proud.my brother was in the Marines and constantly gave me shit over joining the army. The last thing he said to me was telling me to let my brother know that he's just a sea goin bell hop.sorry to ramble just wanted to say thank you for your service and thank you for making me think of my dad.
(2)
Reply
(0)
PFC Rick Phillips
PFC Rick Phillips
>1 y
Supposed to say Pvt E2
(0)
Reply
(0)
PO2 Richard C.
PO2 Richard C.
>1 y
I had an almost identical experience. See my response above (below?)
(0)
Reply
(0)
SGT Dave Tracy
SGT Dave Tracy
>1 y
I have many reservations about busting Stolen Valor d-bags, not because they don't deserve it, but because there have been cases where someone legitimate was wrongly called out. 'Tis better to let 100 fakes go than publically call out a legitimate (truthful) vet or SM. Besides, many Guardians of Stolen Valor are more about their own ego and the social media recognition for the great job they did; ironically not too dissimilar than the reason most fake their military status and/or accomplishments...needs of the ego.

So from the above perspective, you handled the situation well.

That said MCPO Cole, yours might have been a case worthy of a public shaming for that guy's demonstrable lies.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Rene De La Rosa
9
9
0
Oh, that is dangerous ground to walk on. If one has served honorably, and finds out that someone else is out there getting rewards for merely putting on a uniform and learning a couple of phrases, there will be some serious questioning of the liar in question. After that, it will be contentious.
(9)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Joe S. Davis Jr., MSM, DSL
7
7
0
SA Tony Minton I would try to correct it person to person and then report it to the authorities.
(7)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close